JOAT uPick | FIN!

[LadyTerminallyOffline]

Now we have one claim end-to-end that SHOULD have been sent to Bell, but was not.

Yes but the fact remains that several abilities were redirected and that those abilities were targeting different players. So if they are lying how would their ability work?

I'm not sure myself what is going on with Ircher's ability not being redirected.

Yeah see Chart, Edition two.

[LadyTerminallyOffline]

I am going to shamelessly put this at the top of a page again.

[Dunnstral]

Teeeeeeeeeeechnically I did something at the end of D1. It doesn’t relate to any of this though.

I would read the last 15 or so pages better, but I am currently shivering with no power. I’ll be back later, folks.

I thought you weren't here eod?

I wasn’t. I made that post, went to sleep to not deal with the cold, and all that RH thing happened. If I was I would’ve gladly join the crusade against RH and gloat about how I gottem at page 2.

What I meant was, how did you use an action during the end of the day if you weren't around when RH was being hammered?

[Doctor Drew]

The real villain is Greedant.......who chose some roles that kept me out of all the N1 fun heh

I shoulda just inned when the game was in sign ups, could have had some Maid Cafe type fun

Sorry, a mini rant

[LadyTerminallyOffline]

The real villain is Greedant.......who chose some roles that kept me out of all the N1 fun heh

I shoulda just inned when the game was in sign ups, could have had some Maid Cafe type fun

Sorry, a mini rant

I must admit, I feel like I sold myself short seeing some of the items that did get approved.

At least I did get three?

[Sakura Hana]

Sakura, at your next convenience please re-ask how your role interacts with Lightning Rods since your query before was about bus drivers? If you already ddi this and I missed it, I apologize.

Already had done, but was busy, i already received an answer tho, both of my targets get redirected to the new target, effectively causing bell to self-target.

[Doctor Drew]

The real villain is Greedant.......who chose some roles that kept me out of all the N1 fun heh

I shoulda just inned when the game was in sign ups, could have had some Maid Cafe type fun

Sorry, a mini rant

I must admit, I feel like I sold myself short seeing some of the items that did get approved.

At least I did get three?

You give people here to pick their own roles around these parts, there will some bonkers shit.

I also will jump on the band wagon about why Light wouldn't soft a guilty on Turtle

And I really don't think Maid is scum here.

[LadyTerminallyOffline]

That is actually great news, it means that we can potentially rule out your role as the reasoning for the discrepancy down the line if you flip, or we get more data in general. Best case scenario, actually.

Thank you for being prompt.


(I think Sakura is town here, thread, but we need to be impartial about mechanical solving, right? And some of the stuff you submitted is a little weird from what I know, so PLEASE be checking my logic like Dunnstral has been)

[LadyTerminallyOffline]

I also will jump on the band wagon about why Light wouldn't soft a guilty on Turtle

In Light's shoes, it would have been an extremely hard guilty, not a soft one, but regardless, to do nothing with it is ????????

[LadyTerminallyOffline]

Or rather, If I were in Light's position with the result Light claimed.

[Sakura Hana]

I thought Lemon's intended target was light.

[Doctor Drew]

That is actually great news, it means that we can potentially rule out your role as the reasoning for the discrepancy down the line if you flip, or we get more data in general. Best case scenario, actually.

Thank you for being prompt.


(I think Sakura is town here, thread, but we need to be impartial about mechanical solving, right? And some of the stuff you submitted is a little weird from what I know, so PLEASE be checking my logic like Dunnstral has been)

Shouldn't you have Fire as conf town in your chart?

Just for ease of reading

[LadyTerminallyOffline]

I knew I forgot to fix something, Sakura.

And yeah, I probably should have done that.

I am no longer at a keyboard, though, so it will get updated tomorrow, unless somebody else wants to take up the mantle.

[Sakura Hana]

It almost looks more like the "mass redirect" only hit people targeting Hu Tao directly onto Bell, not everyone.

Maybe more people took no action than you are thinking.

I mean, the chart I posted contains all claimed actions so far. There's more than three of them.

Maid Cafe logically acts before watcher to affect it so not seen.

Firebringer could be rb'd or no action.

I don't think that's how Watcher works. Only way to dodge a watcher seeing you is being a Ninja or roleblocking the watcher.

[Sakura Hana]

I'd like Pooky and Ircher to fill in my blanks here. It doesn't even need to be a SPECIFIC role claim, just if they acted or not and who their initial target was.

I forgot Light. Light as well.

I acted, strong-willed gunsmith, HolySpiritTurtle has a gun

Why didnt u mention this at the start of the day? or at least the potential guilty?

[Dunnstral]

surely this is a policy lim VOTE: maid cafe

Yeah they voted maid cafe with a potential guilty on someone else without mentioning it.

[Sakura Hana]

Smells of rolefishing imo

[Sakura Hana]

convenient strong willed gunsmith guilty.

[LadyTerminallyOffline]

surely this is a policy lim VOTE: maid cafe

Yeah they voted maid cafe with a potential guilty on someone else without mentioning it.

Is it my fate for something I am screaming over in my head to get pointed out by somebody else first?


This is two in a row.

[Dunnstral]

tbh the last 3 are probably looking like drew/hu tao/light/ and maybe maid cafe?

Not a fan of light_ganski going straight to policy elim without any consideration that their townread yesterday flipped mafia. No reconsideration with new facts.

I was going to grill lemon for their actions yesterday and role claim but today they seem believable to me.

VOTE: light_ganski

This is what I am thinking right now for similar reasons.

If roles didn't exist in this game, and I had to shoot somebody within the next few minutes, Light would be on my short list. There's surprisingly little in the volume of posting, but this could be a play style mismatch with me.

I thought Drew was quasi-conftown’d but if all of triple parity went into Bell instead, my solve atm is Hu Tao, Drew, and light.

There is considerable suspicion of light_ganski this day phase before the result as well. Including by HolySpiritTurtle.

[Dunnstral]

This could be a real gunsmith but mafia aligned as well. And just coincidentally strong-willed.

[Sakura Hana]

UNVOTE:
Clearly Hu Tao is not the answer today.
So we got Light with a gunsmith guilty which conveniently has strong willed and decided to withhold because ??? and instead try to policy lim maid.
And we also got Maid who is apparently lying because Ircher's invention doesnt have strong willed and should've been redirected.

[Dunnstral]

UNVOTE: HolySpiritTurtle

[Sakura Hana]

I guess i should've expected this game to be Mech hell, but i didnt expect it to be THIS hellish.

[Maid Cafe]

I'm not lying. There's no reason for me to come into the thread and make up some sort of wild lie like that.

Do I know why Ircher's action went through? No. All I know is I used a lighting rod causing every action to be on Bell. Maybe action order messes with that but shrug.jpg