Lol I grossly exaggerate my success rate.In post 3724, Oatsmaster wrote: Ngl, I would be surprised if grack got more mafia than town with that tell
You think oats is forced to bus now?In post 3720, Grackaroni wrote:I also want to follow up on this.In post 3711, Grackaroni wrote: I'm seeing scum equity between Gob/Oats. Oats started off by attacking Gob for his reasoning at the start of the game and Gob interacts with Oats more than any other player.
After re-reading a bit this post stuck out to me:
This post approaches Gob from a weird angle to me. I don't think Oats was scum reading Gob at the time but his default approach is to consider whether it would make sense for Gob to make his vote as mafia based off the two possibilities for Dan's alignment. This seems like a very unnatural approach to me. The more normal reaction imo is just to try to get more information.In post 1531, Oatsmaster wrote:Okay so I’m trying to rationalize this vote as mafia!gobIn post 1454, gob wrote: I legit cannot remember why I thought dannfloor was scummy... I had a good reason why he was the right vote at work but i forgot it.
VOTE: DarthPunk
so im switching gears.
Assuming mafia!dann
This is a quick distraction play to discredit dp and sow some confusion, it’s extremely basic and likely to break down under more intense scrutiny especially once dann flips.
Assuming town!dann
I just don’t see any reason gob swaps here, it’s super striking and he’s been doing a good job of floating around without attracting too much suspicion and he votes the 1 person that thinks he’s mafia.
Idkkkkk I mean maybe I’m giving gob too much credit
At the same time as Oats make this post DP is questioning me on my read on Gob, which leads to me voting Gob to try to get an answer for his Dann posts and Oats reacted like my vote was ridiculous.At the end Gob never even responded about Dann he just came back into the thread and claimed mafia.In post 1546, Oatsmaster wrote: Grack what are you doing cmon
The ending of Oats' post seems crafted/unnatural as well with the 'idkkkkkk i mean maybe I'm giving gob too much credit'.
This is a very big tell for me. If a post seems to be scum-motivated/seems like it's coming from an unnatural place and at the same time utilizes stilted language/unnatural speech, very likely it's coming from scum.
Sorry to disappoint :pIn post 3726, Grackaroni wrote: You know Oats I'm going to be laughing my ass off if my random hunch that Hu Tao red-checked you caused you to fumble your response to her question making Dann push you.
People are taking issue with her reasoning being inconsistent (ruling out active players as mafia at some points and moving them into teams in other points), but the reality is that she's just posting her thought process way more than she needs to as mafia and changing her reads more than she needs to as mafia. To me she seems like an open book.In post 3728, DarthPunk wrote: grack can you explain why you are so sure on Ninja!town?
Cause I have been thinking about that slot a lot and I am not so sure.
I think the bolded is just easy to fake for some people though.In post 3733, Grackaroni wrote:In post 3728, DarthPunk wrote: grack can you explain why you are so sure on Ninja!town?
Cause I have been thinking about that slot a lot and I am not so sure.People are taking issue with her reasoning being inconsistent (ruling out active players as mafia at some points and moving them into teams in other points), but the reality is that she's just posting her thought process way more than she needs to as mafia and changing her reads more than she needs to as mafia. To me she seems like an open book.
There's also posts I liked where she was complaining that she put a lot of effort into analyzing the vote counts from the previous day and that nobody bothered to respond to her posts about it. I think that's a very townie thing to do.
She doesn't come off to me as super experienced with mafia in a way that she could pull this off as scum. I haven't seen many people that are able to pull off this level of activity and openness as scum.In post 3734, DarthPunk wrote:I think the bolded is just easy to fake for some people though.In post 3733, Grackaroni wrote:In post 3728, DarthPunk wrote: grack can you explain why you are so sure on Ninja!town?
Cause I have been thinking about that slot a lot and I am not so sure.People are taking issue with her reasoning being inconsistent (ruling out active players as mafia at some points and moving them into teams in other points), but the reality is that she's just posting her thought process way more than she needs to as mafia and changing her reads more than she needs to as mafia. To me she seems like an open book.
There's also posts I liked where she was complaining that she put a lot of effort into analyzing the vote counts from the previous day and that nobody bothered to respond to her posts about it. I think that's a very townie thing to do.
Not really. I'm just not looking to sink more than a few hours a night into the game.In post 3735, DarthPunk wrote: Grack are you super busy IRL?
I'm much more confident on this than I usually am with reads, so I would like to hear opinions on it.In post 3720, Grackaroni wrote:I also want to follow up on this.In post 3711, Grackaroni wrote: I'm seeing scum equity between Gob/Oats. Oats started off by attacking Gob for his reasoning at the start of the game and Gob interacts with Oats more than any other player.
After re-reading a bit this post stuck out to me:
This post approaches Gob from a weird angle to me. I don't think Oats was scum reading Gob at the time but his default approach is to consider whether it would make sense for Gob to make his vote as mafia based off the two possibilities for Dan's alignment. This seems like a very unnatural approach to me. The more normal reaction imo is just to try to get more information.In post 1531, Oatsmaster wrote:Okay so I’m trying to rationalize this vote as mafia!gobIn post 1454, gob wrote: I legit cannot remember why I thought dannfloor was scummy... I had a good reason why he was the right vote at work but i forgot it.
VOTE: DarthPunk
so im switching gears.
Assuming mafia!dann
This is a quick distraction play to discredit dp and sow some confusion, it’s extremely basic and likely to break down under more intense scrutiny especially once dann flips.
Assuming town!dann
I just don’t see any reason gob swaps here, it’s super striking and he’s been doing a good job of floating around without attracting too much suspicion and he votes the 1 person that thinks he’s mafia.
Idkkkkk I mean maybe I’m giving gob too much credit
At the same time as Oats make this post DP is questioning me on my read on Gob, which leads to me voting Gob to try to get an answer for his Dann posts and Oats reacted like my vote was ridiculous.At the end Gob never even responded about Dann he just came back into the thread and claimed mafia.In post 1546, Oatsmaster wrote: Grack what are you doing cmon
The ending of Oats' post seems crafted/unnatural as well with the 'idkkkkkk i mean maybe I'm giving gob too much credit'.
This is a very big tell for me. If a post seems to be scum-motivated/seems like it's coming from an unnatural place and at the same time utilizes stilted language/unnatural speech, very likely it's coming from scum.
Shhh he might hear youIn post 3742, Grackaroni wrote: I wonder how mind blown Vivax will be at the end game after we successfully pulled off that distancing today after he caught you/me/Luca at the start of the day.
