Mini Normal 2327: Bird Species (Game Over)

[Hu Tao]

D1 threadplays are pretty much worthless. I'm more interested in what you guys did last night.

What did you do last night?

[NotAScum]

And of course today's threadplay is going to be interesting. Get your stories consistent.

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: Black

Why?

just trying it on and seeing how it feels

[Black]

And of course today's threadplay is going to be interesting. Get your stories consistent.

Do you have a guilty check on Hu?

[Black]

VOTE: Black

Why?

just trying it on and seeing how it feels

I'm town

[Save The Dragons]

well i'm convinced

[Hu Tao]

And of course today's threadplay is going to be interesting. Get your stories consistent.

Do you have a guilty check on Hu?

Why would you assume this?

[shaddowez]

So D1 reads aren't much to go off of, but T3 was SRing Cakez and gob, so not terribly useful there

Ari was SRing Black and NaS. Need to look further there - seems like there were better targets, so there's a better than good chance there's scum in those thar field...reads.

[gob]

D1 threadplays are pretty much worthless. I'm more interested in what you guys did last night.

what?

[gob]

Shaddowez the hedgehog

[shaddowez]

Shaddowez the hedgehog

While I'm not quite sure what you mean, I'm not completely against it. That is, provided you have rings for me.

[NotAScum]

What did you do last night?

slept well

Do you have a guilty check on Hu?

Why are you role fishing

[Snow2697]

Agree with Hu Tao that Cakez seems to be a vig kill. First, he got 4 votes at D1. There could have been a push against him at D2. Eg I have thought (mistakenly) that there is a scum between T3 and Cakez. Had Cakez survived, I would have played against him. Second, Cakez kill lets us know that all D1 votes came against towns. This is helpful for our today analysis. Alive Cakez would have made things unclear. Don't see a lot of sense in scums killing Cakez.
If so, this leaves us with a scum shot on Ari. She was pushing Black. An attempt by scums to help scum Black (or to compromise town Black)?
Don't agree with shaddowez' assumption in [ post] 754 [ /post] that T3 wagon contained 2 scums. It could be that 2 scums were in Cakez wagon (to distance themselves from a mislim) and thus they did not kill Cakez (to play against him) and killed a townie on the T3 train (to compromise other members of the T3 train). I am more inclined to look closer at Cakez wagon for scum search.
Don't quite understand Gob's point in [ post] 757 [ /post]. How is this relevant if both Cakez and T3 were townies?

[shaddowez]

It could be that 2 scums were in Cakez wagon (to distance themselves from a mislim) and thus they did not kill Cakez (to play against him) and killed a townie on the T3 train (to compromise other members of the T3 train). I am more inclined to look closer at Cakez wagon for scum search.

SirCakez (4) - Save the Dragons, T3, Hu Tao, gob

Unless you don't believe gob's claim, you're saying that both StD and Hu are scum, there's no "searching".

[gob]

im confused

[Hu Tao]

What did you do last night?

slept well

Do you have a guilty check on Hu?

Why are you role fishing

[Black]

What did you do last night?

slept well

Do you have a guilty check on Hu?

Why are you role fishing

Asking people what they did overnight is an easy way to get all of our power roles killed

You're clearing softing something here but if you want to withhold the info then that's fine

[Hu Tao]

You're saying that you think he has a guilty on me. But he named you too. Which would imply you think he has a guilty on you?

[Snow2697]

It could be that 2 scums were in Cakez wagon (to distance themselves from a mislim) and thus they did not kill Cakez (to play against him) and killed a townie on the T3 train (to compromise other members of the T3 train). I am more inclined to look closer at Cakez wagon for scum search.

SirCakez (4) - Save the Dragons, T3, Hu Tao, gob

Unless you don't believe gob's claim, you're saying that both StD and Hu are scum, there's no "searching".

I don't rule out that Gob is scum.
Note that he does not suspect voters for Cakez.
BTW same with Black - her suspects are all from T3 wagon.

[gob]

It could be that 2 scums were in Cakez wagon (to distance themselves from a mislim) and thus they did not kill Cakez (to play against him) and killed a townie on the T3 train (to compromise other members of the T3 train). I am more inclined to look closer at Cakez wagon for scum search.

SirCakez (4) - Save the Dragons, T3, Hu Tao, gob

Unless you don't believe gob's claim, you're saying that both StD and Hu are scum, there's no "searching".

I don't rule out that Gob is scum.
Note that he does not suspect voters for Cakez.
BTW same with Black - her suspects are all from T3 wagon.

i do. Just jot the focus for today

[Black]

You're saying that you think he has a guilty on me. But he named you too. Which would imply you think he has a guilty on you?

I don't necessarily think he has a guilty on you. I asked that to gauge his reaction

[gob]

I agree with Black that i think there is wolf on noth wagons.
However, there is 100% a wolf on the mislim wagon. Its possible the Cakez wagon is all green

[Black]

It could be that 2 scums were in Cakez wagon (to distance themselves from a mislim) and thus they did not kill Cakez (to play against him) and killed a townie on the T3 train (to compromise other members of the T3 train). I am more inclined to look closer at Cakez wagon for scum search.

SirCakez (4) - Save the Dragons, T3, Hu Tao, gob

Unless you don't believe gob's claim, you're saying that both StD and Hu are scum, there's no "searching".

I don't rule out that Gob is scum.
Note that he does not suspect voters for Cakez.
BTW same with Black - her suspects are all from T3 wagon.

Gob can't be scum here

[Snow2697]

Gob can't be scum here

Why?

[Black]

Gob can't be scum here

Why?

There is an unaccounted Vig kill. If gob is lying about being the Vig then the real Vig would counterclaim