Large Normal 247 - Postgame

[Gypyx]

this thread is now dedicated to creating signature material

[Psyche]

im at page 25 and have to do other things besides play mafia today im sorry for not being mroe focused everyone

[Psyche]

Psyche
Thomith
Random Nurse
Gypyx

Oblivion
geraintm

Naerys
Lycanfire

Snow2697
KayJayQueue
Titus

here's my more conservative read list atm
top tier is "id bet game these are town"
mid tier is "i normal townread these"
second-to-bottom tier is "i expect to townread these"
bottom tier is null. just null.

[Random Nurse]

Psyche
Thomith
Random Nurse
Gypyx

Oblivion
geraintm

Naerys
Lycanfire

Snow2697
KayJayQueue
Titus

here's my more conservative read list atm
top tier is "id bet game these are town"
mid tier is "i normal townread these"
second-to-bottom tier is "i expect to townread these"
bottom tier is null. just null.

Could you please give like 2-3 sentences on why Titus is at the very bottom fmof your list?

[Random Nurse]

Also you should be Scumreading AT LEAST one player. Come on now.

[Gypyx]

Elaborate on Oblivion please

it's a slot i've been getting wary about, i fear it's posting style just leads to looking town like that

[Psyche]

titus is very hard to read -- a rather muted and i daresay stilted style
i see a ranger vote in her iso, could be useful for sorting later depending on the timing
249 where she calls davescum and willowtown should actually lean me town too somewhat
...ok i guess i've talked myself into sticking her with naeyrs/lycanfire again

[Random Nurse]

Interesting.

[Random Nurse]

Was Dave/Ranger slot distancing/fake-fighting with any players in early game?

[Psyche]

the oblivion townread (and maybe also the geraintm townread -- but there's meta baked into that) are sort of vibes-based atm so it would be stretching too early to try to elaborate on them
but i'll definitely prioritize finding good language to back these up now that i know the slot is still in question

[Thomith]

Was Dave/Ranger slot distancing/fake-fighting with any players in early game?

FWIW Ranger randomly moving me and Gypyx from scum reads to top town reads was really weird to me.

I don't know what that means yet but wanted to throw that out. Maybe Ranger wanted to frame one/both of us because of a weird 180?

[Random Nurse]

Psyche, if Thomith/Gypyx Survive Night 3 and Night 4, would that change your stance on them at all?

[Random Nurse]

Was Dave/Ranger slot distancing/fake-fighting with any players in early game?

FWIW Ranger randomly moving me and Gypyx from scum reads to top town reads was really weird to me.

I don't know what that means yet but wanted to throw that out. Maybe Ranger wanted to frame one/both of us because of a weird 180?

I'm not sure.

I know Ranger enough to know she's good as Both Town and Scum, so you never know.

*puts a pin in it*

[Thomith]

Penguin has the same philosophy that I have. Early large wagons are quite valuable to town. I think Oblivion's take on Penguin meta is correct. It would be a very easy thing to fake as scum, so the town conclusion is a but suspect.
I can't town bin Oblivion on that because its approach was very similar in the last game and it flipped scum. It's only a sample size of 1 so not very strong.

Titus's vote isn't much more than a RVS, in fact it might be exactly that. I'd call that NAI.

Dave sus bc whiteknight.

What from me did you perceive as defending someone else?

Dave not to view his post as defending me

what post?

VOTE: Willow
is a worthy wagon.

Early game comments from Dave about other people that stood out to me on a brief skim

[geraintm]

woah! dave was ranger! i get to see what he's like as scum.

He be dead

[Psyche]

Was Dave/Ranger slot distancing/fake-fighting with any players in early game?

not seeing anything in particular that makes me suspect this

[Random Nurse]

Something tells me I'll need to scour that slot's post history and soon.

[Thomith]

woah! dave was ranger! i get to see what he's like as scum.

He be dead

Why are you still voting Gypyx?

[Random Nurse]

woah! dave was ranger! i get to see what he's like as scum.

He be dead

Oh my god you're ALIVE.

It's... a MIRACLE.

OK where are you on this game mtfr?

[Thomith]

VOTE: Snow

FWIW Dave put Snow on E-1 on page 2

[geraintm]

but why is it

scummy

? he doesn't have your pov.

Because when Gypyx flips town, I 100% die next, since I will be confirmed at that point.

Random Nurse is actively working to remove two people who are sure of each other being town from the game, which is benefits scum.

WHO CARES if you die as Town?

Town doesn't GAF about self-preservation, and Informed Town Neighbors is a big pile of nothing when it comes to Town power.

this just in Masons is a useless role

Town-Informed Neighbors.

But now you're clarifying that your role PM says "Mason," Gypyx?

Masons are a group of people who mutually know they're town and have a PT together

Me and Thomith are a group of people who mutually know they're town and have a PT together

the word isn't there but i'm calling it that

You have a private thread with each other?

[Thomith]

Would it be too WIFOMY to believe scum likely don't do that to a partner that quickly?

[Thomith]

but why is it

scummy

? he doesn't have your pov.

Because when Gypyx flips town, I 100% die next, since I will be confirmed at that point.

Random Nurse is actively working to remove two people who are sure of each other being town from the game, which is benefits scum.

WHO CARES if you die as Town?

Town doesn't GAF about self-preservation, and Informed Town Neighbors is a big pile of nothing when it comes to Town power.

this just in Masons is a useless role

Town-Informed Neighbors.

But now you're clarifying that your role PM says "Mason," Gypyx?

Masons are a group of people who mutually know they're town and have a PT together

Me and Thomith are a group of people who mutually know they're town and have a PT together

the word isn't there but i'm calling it that

You have a private thread with each other?

The only PT we share is the Neighbourhood.

[Random Nurse]

VOTE: Snow

FWIW Dave put Snow on E-1 on page 2

Yes, yes, go on.

[Thomith]

Would it be too WIFOMY to believe scum likely don't do that to a partner that quickly?

This was my follow up to the E-1 thing.

I'm wondering if this may soft clear Snow?