Mini 715: Legends of Literature Mafia (Over)

[CarnCarn]

neko, what do you think about massclaim?

Also, rofl, I'm OK with Caboose choosing, but would prefer neko/Jazz/ice to be towards the front of the line.

[icemanE]

I agree with the massclaim, and would also like to hear from Jazz about her reasoning.

I don't see how we can determine whether it's another mafia or an SK - does it really matter, though? We want to lynch it either way, right?

[CarnCarn]

does it really matter, though?

It matters if you want to look at connections.

[roflcopter]

does it really matter, though?

It matters if you want to look at connections.

qft

if its one more mafia, its almost definitely simenon

if its a serial killer, we're practically starting over from scratch with our scumhunt, but a massclaim will surely help.

[Caboose]

We don't know the specifics of Tenchi's role, so no conclusions of his bussing can be determined.

How about yours?

I would like Simenon to go first in the massclaim.

[CarnCarn]

I would like Simenon to go first in the massclaim.

Meh, fine.

[icemanE]

That's a good point, about connections. Are we claiming popcorn-style here?

[CarnCarn]

I'm fine with popcorn or Caboose as Claimmaker.

[Simenon]

Isn't it enough and safe to assume he was playing for the mafia but the mafia wasn't aware he was part of their team?

No. I'll maintain that speculating on tenchi's possible bussing is terrible play.


I'm Sherlock Holmes, a vanilla townie. So it's fairly obvious that I'm going to be lynched today, because that is an *awful* role.

[Simenon]

FWIW you guys had better have a back-up plan.

[Caboose]

Ghostwriter, you're up.

[neko2086]

CC, I was in favor of massclaiming since page 1.

I'll maintain that speculating on tenchi's possible bussing is terrible play.

Sim, could you please provide some sort of reasoning for that?

[CarnCarn]

CC, I was in favor of massclaiming since page 1.

Wow, so you

were

serious about that. And that was just for claiming books, not roles.

[Caboose]

Ghostwriter, you're up.

Oh, and claim your name, role, book, and author.

[CarnCarn]

Ghostwriter, you're up.

Oh, and claim your name, role, book, and author.

I'm disappointed you've chosen him to go before any of the other 3 I mentioned, but oh well.

[GhostWriter]

I'm Tweedledee, town mason. From Lewis Carroll's Alice in Wonderland, of course. Partnered up with Carn over there.

[CarnCarn]

I'm Tweedledee, town mason. From Lewis Carroll's Alice in Wonderland, of course. Partnered up with Carn over there.

QFT

[neko2086]

GW, pick the next person to claim

[CarnCarn]

pick Jazz

[Jazzmyn]

Jazz, massclaim, yes or no?

Sure. Sounds good to me.

jazz, i'm not seeing the carncarn scenario, please elucidate.

my opinon is most likely remaining scum, if one more mafia is the case, is simenon.

You could be right, and it is possible that my views on CarnCarn might be influenced by meta, so I will look at him again. Simenon would be my next best choice for scum at present.

if its an sk, i have to do some thinking, but maybe ghostwriter?

If it's an SK, I too will have to read again and think more about it as I haven't played in any games to date in which there has been a SK, so I have not really turned my mind to who might be one.

Regards,
Jazz

[Jazzmyn]

Ahh, I guess I should have read page 14 before replying to posts on page 13, since it appears that the claiming is already underway which makes part of my last post redundant.

In any event, I am happy to claim at whatever spot in the lineup the claim-maker chooses, if that's the method that we're going with, or at whatever spot I am called upon to do so by the popcorn method if that's the method we're going with. I'm not sure which method we are using, though, since initially it looks like the claim-maker method with Caboose calling the order (Simenon, Ghostwriter) but then after Ghostwriter claimed, neko asked Ghostwriter to choose the next person, which would be the popcorn method.

Either is fine with me, but I think we should use one or the other and not a combination of two different methods, in order to keep things, well, orderly.

Also, I am suspicious of Simenon's claim for reasons similar to why I was suspicious of Riceballtail's claim.

Regards,
Jazz

[GhostWriter]

If it's up to me, I'm going to say Jazz as well, so... yeah...

[roflcopter]

popcorn is cool at this point as well. i just wanted someone who i was sure is town to start the claiming.

[neko2086]

rofl, can you answer my question from the last page, please?


Jazz, after everyone has claimed, you're going to need to elaborate on your suspicion of Sim's claim.

[Simenon]

Jazz, after everyone has claimed, you're going to need to elaborate on your suspicion of Sim's claim.

I

could elaborate on what is suspicious about my claim. She has to elaborate on why it's similar to RBT's.