Urza, so glad you could join us. What's your role?
i am teh scumz
ive got the vanilla townie PM in the rules post, hurr durr
Thanks, Urza!
On with business...
This isn't really a matter of whether we want to gamble on keeping a town power role; we essentially have zero power roles at this point. The only question is: do we think destructor is scum, or ThAdmiral? While yes, it's a little safer to lynch destructor, since we know we can't immediately lose if we do (if it's a mislynch then the traitor can't be alive) I skimmed through their posts and I feel like ThAdmiral is just a more likely candidate.
destructor's playing is consistent with his claim: he dances around a bit on the first day (nothing to worry about, it being the first day), often coming back to CarnCarn, which supports the idea that he would have chosen CarnCarn as a target. Then, he pretty much fires the missiles at CarnCarn all of day two - consistent with him having gotten a 'guilty'. Then he goes straight for Mizzy on the third day, having his "true" guilty. Plus it seems to me that there is just plenty of contribution from him in general.
ThAdmiral doesn't have anything particularly concrete for me to go on. He didn't talk as much, didn't contribute as much, and his votes tended to go on people we can now confirm were not one of the two mafiates. Towards the start of the game he tended to direct his comments at specific people, which feels a little odd to me, as it lets him direct discussion to specific things (and other players) already on the table and avoid drawing attention to himself. Nothing really solid, but I think as compared to destructor - who is necessarily the opposite alignment to him - ThAdmiral looks like the worse.
/discuss?
