Here's my super-long readup post.
4. Santos, Precooked Mafia Goon (Anago), Lynched day one
13. GreenCrayons, Townie (Maguro), stabbed night one
For my reference ^
Post 1-27 - Confirmations
Post 28-34 - puns
Post 35 - game starts, first random vote
Post 42 - Plum uses RVS logic for defense.
Post 57 - Hybris notes how player numbers may = scum.
Post 62 - Seraphim asks for more votes on the RBT wagon.
Post 73 - More Seraphim on RBT wagon.
Hybris in Post 74 wrote:Green Crayons wrote:I'm assuming it's 13 to lynch?
Actually, no. Its twelve due to the secret role in the game that makes all lynches to need one less vote while alive.
lolumwot?
Post 77 - RBT self-votes.
Post 78 - Sirdanilot votes Hybris for Post 74.
Post 79 - Azhrei makes note of RBT but does nothing.
Post 81 - GreenCrayons votes RBT becuase he hates D1 self voters.
Post 85 - More Seraphim pushing wagon on RBT
Post 88 - MK's note of Seraphim being a lyncher or something. Probably nothing.
Post 92 - Seraphim saying it's only been one long RVS. I disagree, but meh. Noted, anyway.
Post 100 - OGML votes MK, with no other text.
Post 103 - Read yourself, OGML explains his vote. Good points, but why didn't he post that in 100?
Post 112 - RBT unvotes self, and justifies it as a sushi pun.
Post 115 - Read yourself. Raider seems a little too serious, though made me laugh at the same time.
Post 116 - Sirdanilot makes mini-case on Seraphim (with a vote), followed by an FoS on RBT for being surprised at the reaction to her self-vote.
Post 117 - Read yourself. Setenta (scum) makes minor connection to Seraphim, Sirdanilot, and RBT.
Post 118 - OGML pushes MK wagon.
Post 119 - Slicey agrees with Sirdanilot, and votes Seraphim.
Post 122 - MK responds to OGML's vote/wagon on him, though inadequately imo. (read yourself).
Post 123 - OGML speculates Raider as scumpartner to MK.
Post 126 - More of MK's inadequate defense. (Read)
Post 128 - Seraphim makes a case on three - MK, Slicey, and Sirdanilot.
Post 131 - MK's. Not sure what to say.
Post 136-138 - Ort's puts minor reason for unvoting MK.
Post 139 - Sirdanilot is displeased with Seraphim's 128.
Post 140 - Goes against Ort's reasoning for unvoting MK.
Post 142 - DGB makes a guess at some scum in this game. Nothing to really further the game, though.
Post 149 - DGB comes in to pressure Slicey. Legitimate, imo.
Post 150 - More OGML pushing for MK wagon.
Post 160 - MK responding to DGB's 142. Seems sure DGB is wrong, sort of.
Post 162 - Plum recap. Not bad.
Post 165 - Slicey says not voting for lack of scummyness to vote for. Wha?
Post 166 - OGML asks Slicey what he thinks about MK.
Post 172 - A few things here. Says for some reason posts 161-2 (made by plum) scream anti-town (I disagree). Also says can back the RBT wagon (and does), but can't be confident about it (?)
Post 175-177 - Talitha defends Slicey and votes MK for OGML's reasoning.
Post 178 - Sirdanilot reinforces vote on Seraphim (read this one, strong post imo)
Post 182 - More OGML against MK.
Post 183 - RBT votes Seraphim (read this)
Post 184 - Seraphim calls 183 an OMGUS.
Post 188 - OGML strongly pushing MK lynch.
Post 190 - Hybris comes in, and doesn't see any of the three main cases (and requests a repost of such info).
Post 215 - Seraphim picks out a random lurker, who happens to be Santos, confirmed scum. Coincidence? Probably.
Post 223 - Santos saying he had nothing to say. Why did nobody say something?
Post 225 - HP[leaves] with a solid post on MK.
Post 226 - Among many other things, is first person to jump on (and vote) Santos for his post 223.
Post 230 - DGB says scum is caught (with post 223 (santos) quoted).
Post 234-240 - Wagon on Santos finally starts. People include (Seraphim, sirdanilot, DrippingGoofball, Hybris, Sentata, Slicey ).
Post 249 - MK posts something very interesting:
Microphone_Kirby wrote:Santos wrote:Hmm, missed the next page. The 'I already did' was directed at Setanta.
Catching up on the next page I notice a
lot of people would rather vote for me being honest
as opposed to posting some BS excuse that I can't read a forum thread of a few pages and will do so in several days from now. Pathetic.
*sigh* Join the club.
Post 258 - OGML more pushing for MK lynch (and throws in Raider as a possible scumpartner).
Post 262 -
hp[leaves] wrote:I like the pressure on Santos; but I don't think he's that scummy to have another vote on.
Wha...?
Post 269 - More OGML pushing MK lynch.
Post 273 - Read this yourself. MK = scummy here?
Post 278 - OGML switches to the Santos wagon in lieu of his wonderful claim.
Post 285 - Azrhei hesitant, but votes Santos (L-1).
Post 294 - hp[leaves]: "You have a
safeclaim
?" - reeks to me, though second opinion appreciated.
Post 300 - Setenta hesitant, but against Santos.
Post 305 - Ort hammers Santos (finally).
Post 309 - Day Two Starts
And that's as far as I've gotten with my read. Will get Day two sometime tomorrow, hopefully.
My scumlist thus far (with scum-o-meter, 100 being definite, 30 being nuetral):
MK - 90/100
OGML - 90/100
hp[Leaves] 60/100
Seraphim 55/100
Setenta 40/100
DGB 35/100
Slicey 35/100
RBT 35/100
Ortolan 35/100
So I'm caught on who to vote for, though I'll probably vote OGML. Checking votecount...
Conclusions:
-OGML is strongly against MK, though doesn't say much about it. Suddenly switches to Santos at the last second.
-MK - somewhat contradictory, suggesting lynchers/jesters
-hp[leaves] - some odd posts.
-Seraphim - I don't actually remember why he was here, but he was at the top of my rolling scumlist at the end of post 166, where I cut off my read a little while ago.
-Setenta - mainly the hesitance to vote Santos.
-Ort - the beating around the bush with Santos. See below.
-The rest are general vibes.
Seriously, on the Santos wagon - his claim especially was BS. I'd have called him on it immediately and lynched. Obvscum, if I've ever seen it.
Votecount checked, this isn't a hammer -
Vote: OGML
Will expand on request.
Bastard ModGod. Mislynch fodder. Suave savior.