Dichotomafia- Games Over

[willows_weep]

Oh, I forgot to ask you this before:
Wacky why was it surprising who I investigated?

vote:nanook

Nothing in your 'defense' seems passionate enough :shrug:

[Wacky]

Nanook: If you are anything but mafia, you should at least give a full list of people targeted, and explanation as to why you contradicted yourself, what kind of twist you suspect it might be. This lack of effort is just disappointing.

<fuldu's confused gibberish goes here>

A clarification:

I can't remember who nanook claimed to have blocked n1 or n2. I'm not sure if he did, so if you find out, please tell.

Night 1: I don't remember who PB said he blocked, but MMCL investigates Tally, gets guilty result.

Night 2: Peacebringer claims he blocked nanook, who says his night action (blocking), didn't work. So that's the actions of two claimed blockers accounted for. BUT MMCL says he's blocked, or at least that his investigation didn't work [when we get back to the village, we better ask him who it is, because it might just be a godfather effect.... but then again, MMCL was paranoid/insane/random/other sanity]

This is the weird part, because that is a lot of blockers, and blocking a claimed cop that is in doubt seems like a weird thing for a pro-town role to do.


-----


w_w - It's surprising because the village almost got led into lynching the guy you investigated because they thought you had already investigated the guy N1 and got a guilty result, when in fact you investigated the night N2 and got an innocent result.

[NanookTheWolf]

What are you guys waiting to hear from me? .. I've already claimed my role, unless of course you want my name and such and who i've targetted. I guess with me being so close to a lynch, I can do that.

N1 The silent speaker
N2 Willows Weep

... as for name and such my pm basically just said that I have the ability to block. Didn't mention any names and special descriptions and such. It did mention a special twist about my role though, but of course Norinel didn't say what it was.

Here you go Wacky ..

[Norinel]

Considering a deadline. Seeking a replacement for Flying Dutchman, prodding KingEnigma, hoping PeaceBringer and Fishbulb will come out of the woodwork soon.

Vote Count:

NanookTheWolf- 4 (Wacky, Mgm, ralphmerridew, willows_weep)

Not voting (8): Save The Dragons, Flying Dutchman, Fuldu, KingEnigma, PeaceBringer, Fishbulb, NanookTheWolf, Coron

7 to lynch.

[Coron]

I wish you people would talk about games I wasn't mafia in
like the one that is going on right now, not the other one.

[Coron]

That is, I'm not mafia in this one... not this is one of the ones not to talk about...

[Norinel]

Mastermind of Sin replaces Flying Dutchman.

[Mastermind of Sin]

YARRRF...

I'll try to read the 34 pages in one sitting, and after I regain conciousness, I'll try to collect my thoughts and post.

[willows_weep]

Wacky- Oh yea, I remember that. I was reading that day that time, and was like "ohhh nono but ..."

[Coron]

I know the feeling MoS

[PeaceBringer]

I am not voting Nanook-- it should be I think

Vote Nanook

...

[Flying Dutchman]

*agrees.........*

Vote: NanookTheWolf

[Save The Dragons]

Mastermind of Sin replaces Flying Dutchman.

*agrees.........*

Vote: NanookTheWolf

Hmm...

Anyway, I think it is time to put the puppy down

Vote Nanook

[Norinel]

FD's vote doesn't count because he's no longer playing. Just in case you weren't posting because you thought it was twilight:

Not the end of day

Vote Count:

NanookTheWolf- 6 (Wacky, Mgm, ralphmerridew, willows_weep, PeaceBringer, Save The Dragons)

Not voting (6): Save The Dragons, Mastermind of Sin, Fuldu, KingEnigma, Fishbulb, NanookTheWolf, Coron

7 to lynch.

[Coron]

vote: Nanook

And hope for scum.

[Norinel]

That was quick.

End of Day Vote Count:

NanookTheWolf- 7 (Wacky, Mgm, ralphmerridew, willows_weep, PeaceBringer, Save The Dragons, Coron)

Not voting (5): Save The Dragons, Mastermind of Sin, Fuldu, KingEnigma, Fishbulb, NanookTheWolf

7 to lynch.

The Top 10 Reasons Dichotomafia != Tuthrededmafya:

10. Werewolfs are cool. (PeaceBringer, STD, King Enigma)
9. It's two, two, two roles in one! (FD, Fishbulb, tss)
8. Wacky can't count. (Wacky's fourth of ten reasons.)
7. Dichotomafia has a much cooler name (MMCL)
6. I rock the modding scene harder than those mathslamm guys (lulu muumuu, similar sentiments expressed by ralphmerridew)
5. Dichotomafia is not penguin excrement. (Inspired by IS)

Town Day 3/Village Night 3

For actions of days past that seemed like months passed, the town converges on NanookTheWolf. Eventually, they manage to lynch him despite a little bit of confusion with the ghost of Mastermind Of Sin's past life trying to cast the penultimate vote. By the fancy exterior of his mansion and the Mafia records inside of it, the town's hopes seem to have been realized.

NanookTheWolf (Godfather) - lynched by the town Day 3

It is now Night 4 in the town, send choices by the end of the Village's Day.

The villagers awaken, not expecting nearly as good a night as the townsfolk had the day. Their expecations are also realized; Wacky has apparently been torn to pieces while intently perusing his "Saving People From Werewolf Attack For Dummies" book.

Wacky (Apprentice Healer) - mauled Night 3 in the Village

It is now Day 3 in the Village, 6 to lynch.

Apprentice Healer is Nurse, standard backup doc.

Some people ought to be prodded and/or replaced, and I need to go dig up the next member of the Top 10 list, but that'll have to wait until tomorrow morning or so.

[Fishbulb]

Aww, just missed it.

Not sure where to begin today. The obvious suspicion would be on Save The Dragons and his continual reluctance to join in on Coron, but he made sure to make us think he wanted to. Of course, I don't think he would be that obvious if he was scum.

Hmm... I got nothing else at the moment.

[PeaceBringer]

sweet- gotcha Nanook! Damn lucky to nail the godfather night 2. Sweet.

any thought on where to go for the day.

[Talitha]

I'm confused about the ww investigation stuff.

[PeaceBringer]

So anyone have any thoughts on the day. I see no one has posted in quite some time.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Yeah, I don't really know what's going on, but I'll try to watch and see what sort of dynamics there are so I can look for specific things on my next reread

[Save The Dragons]

Are we any closer than from where we started? Meaning, could we pretend we're at day 1 and just random vote/bandwagon? I know it's stupid but I really can't think of much else.

[Talitha]

Yeah time to kick this game in the butt. I don't think we need to resort to randomness though.

There's no reason not to go back to my initial suspicion of Peacebringer. I just got the vibe that he was voting for a scum buddy when he voted for lulu yesterday. WW's investigation doesn't clear him because - he could be a godfather, or - she might not be sane.

vote: Peacebringer

[Mgm]

Heck, I'll go back to my previous suspicion of Wacky.

Vote Wacky

Isn't PB confirmed blocker now Nanook is dead, or am I confusing days and players?

[ralphmerridew]

MGM: You can't vote for Wacky; he was just killed.

Talitha: I think willows had two innocent results (any cop in her situation with opposite results would have announced that fact). While PB isn't certain to be innocent, he is, at least for now, more likely to be innocent than a random townie. If, later on, we lynch the GF, then PB can move to the "very likely innocent" list; if, after a large number of lynches, we've failed to catch the GF, that's cause to reexamine PB.

Vote: STD

for acting completely differently in the two games.