Mini #704: Hunchback of Notre Dame, Game Over

[ortolan]

Aren't we highly, highly likely to be in LYOL regardless of what he flips?

In which case that attitude makes no sense if you're town...

[Thestatusquo]

you know what, fuck me, I'd rather lynch admiral.

vote: thadmiral

[ortolan]

You know what, same

Unvote
Vote: ThAdmiral

[ThAdmiral]

retards

no wonder town is going to lose.

[ortolan]

it's a gambit, but town has very little chance of winning at this point anyhow.

[petroleumjelly]

Day Four: Vote Count #2

4 ThAdmiral (destructor, Machiavellian-Mafia, Urzassedatives, ortolan)
1 destructor (ThAdmiral)

With

7

alive it takes

4

to lynch, and

3

to lynch at deadline. Deadline is February 9, 11:59 pm CDT.

Not Voting – 2 – Axelrod, korejora

The old church, all vibrating and sonorous, was in a perpetual joy of bells.

ThAdmiral, Town, has been lynched!

It is now

Night Four

. Choices are due on February 6 at 9:59 pm CDT.

[petroleumjelly]

It is that setting sun which we mistake for the dawn.

Axelrod, Town, has been killed!

It is now

Day Five

. With

5

alive, it takes

3

to lynch, and

2

to lynch at deadline. Deadline is February 20, 9:59 pm CDT.

[Korejora]

WTF ORT.

[Korejora]

I thought you thought I was town. :/

[ortolan]

I don't understand your question at all kore? I don't see any way you can be scum ruling out bastard modding. Plus your contributions recently haven't been at all scummy.

I'm highly surprised scum hasn't won already, but evidently the traitor has been lynched or night-killed. On a whim I would guess CarnCarn or Mizzy, but I may be wrong

In retrospect my rationale for voting ThAdmiral was kind of retarded- Urza looked like obv-scum to me and rather than opt for the obvious destructor-MM scumpair (I thought MM's support was too unashamed to actually be a scumbuddy), I thought Urza was trying to bus his scumbuddy, ThAdmiral in the hopes that destructor would be lynched as town anyway (which was, theoretically speaking, the safest town move), and then, while ThAdmiral would be caught, Urza could say "I believed destructor's claim all along".

However destructor cannot be telling the truth at this point- as an insane cop he's claimed innocent results (which means they're guilty) on both Mizzy and ThAdmiral, and only one can be the traitor (if either are), which means his claim cannot be true, and he is scum.

Who do you think the second scum is after destructor Urza?

[Korejora]

I dunno, I just don't see why you'd hammer someone who didn't have

either

of the townies on him. I guess anything's possible.

Anyway, mise well let the other players talk instead of setting up the mafia's story for them.

[destructor]

I read my result wrong on ThAd yesterday. I actually had a "Mafia" on him and got it mixed up along the way. Worst mistake I've ever made in a Mafia game and I expect to be hounded for this for a while. There is basically nothing else I can say.

I investigated MM last night and he's scum. I saw his quick vote on ThAd as really freakin weird given the state we were in. I though it was the likely action of a scumbuddy wanting to distance and quickly, but that obviously can't be true. It seems more likely now that he saw an opportunity to secure a win by taking full advantage of my mistake and ensuring two mislynches - ThAd and then me today. Even if I had been lynched first, the town would have lynched ThAd today given my result. So, in some ways, I'm especially glad I wasn't lynched yesterday, heh.

Urza is the most likely scum-buddy. MM had Caboose/Urza as his suspect for most of the game but never truly did anything to make his lynch likely.

ort's hammer of ThAd was definitely odd and uncharacteristic of his play most of this game, but I still can't see why he would have switched from CR to Nat like he did in Day 1 if he were scum (unless CR/Kore is scum, which is not likely) and that's secured him as town in my mind since early Day 2.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

I have to say destructor has played a masterful game up to this point, but it ends here. I'm not buying destructor-scum's excuse one bit.

Vote: Destructor

And obviously Urza is the scumbuddy.

[destructor]

However destructor cannot be telling the truth at this point- as an insane cop he's claimed innocent results (which means they're guilty) on both Mizzy and ThAdmiral, and only one can be the traitor (if either are), which means his claim cannot be true, and he is scum.

To be fair, I

thought

I was telling the truth. lol

Mizzy was definitely the Traitor.


It should be noted that we're in LYLO.

Regarding my mistake and explanation, I'd ask you all to consider in the context of the rest of my play and it's merits.

[Thestatusquo]

Destructor and orto have to be the scum.

Vote: Destructor

[ortolan]

Well, if you were town, then yes, we are. But you're not.

Vote: destructor

[petroleumjelly]

Day Five Vote Count #1

3 destructor (Machiavellian-Mafia, Urzassedatives, ortolan)

With

5

alive, it takes

3

to lynch, and

2

to lynch at deadline. Deadline is February 20, 9:59 pm CDT.

Not Voting - 2 - destructor, Korejora

~

And the crowd burst into a laugh, especially the boys and young girls.

destructor, Mafia, has been lynched!

It is now

Night Five

. Choices are due to me by February 11, 9:59 pm CDT.

[petroleumjelly]

Now that spirit seemed to have departed; the cathedral seemed gloomy, and gladly remained silent; festivals and funerals had the simple peal, dry and bare, demanded by the ritual, nothing more

Korejora, Town, has been killed!

It is now

Day Six

. With

3

alive, it takes

2

to lynch, and

2

to lynch at deadline. Deadline is February 25, 9:59 pm CDT. I may extend deadline once by one week if two players send me a PM asking for such an extension.

[Thestatusquo]

So uh...
Orto, MM...

Which one of you is scum?

(Did I mention I hate this game?)

[ortolan]

trick question???

at present there's no way I'm going to vote MM over you.

Should you be town, would you care to list you who you think is scum out of myself/MM and why?

[Thestatusquo]

No.

This is the worst mafia game I have ever played in my history on the site. I have given up. Vote me and let me lose already.

[ortolan]

That's not going to help your case, in my experience if someone tells/asks you to lynch them your best bet is to comply.

[Thestatusquo]

i'm not trying to help my case. I'm serious. I've lost all will to play this game. I did so about 2 game days ago.

[ortolan]

Well this endgame is going to be interesting...

I'm waiting for Mr. MM to make an appearance

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

As I have said all along, I like TSQ as scum.