Monty Python Quest for the holy grail, GAME OVER!!!

[mathcam]

When stuck, go after a random lurker.

Vote: mole

Cam

[Werebear]

mole knows better... this is a deliberate bandwagon jump, for those wondering motive.

Vote: Molefia

*grin*

[Fishbulb]

Yeah, something is up with him.

Vote: mole

[korais666]

Well... wouldn't it be logical to wait until he says something?

FOS: Mole

, but I'd prefer a replacement to a random lynching (although I'd REALLY prefer that he just starts talking)

[Dragon Slayer]

I'd like to hear from him, too.

[bane221]

To address Fishbulb's concern/comment:

I first posted about the three-header (or whatever we'd like to refer to it/them as) previous to that comment by trying to help narrow down what characters may be evil:

Ok, lots of questions, let's see...

Three-headed thing would probably be another family, that seems like a decent guess.

The Rabbit... hmm... peculiar, a Vig or SK perhaps of some sort? Just spitballin here

And The French... not positive there, the mafia guess seems solid from the start though.

Then that comment he pasted up at you was taken out of context. Loose Cannon made a large list of evil killing roles and finished with a comment concerning the massive number of them:

I don't know if much of this makes any sense to you, but there seem to be too many killing roles

That was my reply to that. So if that seems to defend them: so be it. But I think if you reread that large list Loose Cannon proposed I was trying to find the simplest explanation to the list of too many evils.

If you read past my initial post you will find similar (and supposedly suspicious posts according to fishbulb) from werebear and massive.

Werebear defends the knights who say ni saying:

That's enough for me to worry about. The knights of Ni never killed anyone, they'll just make you chop down the largest tree in the forest with a herring.

and massive defends the black knight:

Werebear makes a good point about the Knights Who Say Ni ... the same point can be applied to the Black Knight

The entire discussion fishbulb is referring to was the town trying to figure some things out to properly address the game and be successful. Something he didn't seem to do and instead picked a part out and threw it out there for the town to chew on. If anything I'd

FOS: fishbulb

for the misdirection and/or incomplete reading.

And now that I think about it I keep worrying I'm getting the 3-header and the Knights Who Say Ni mixed up in my head... like their part in the plot... Time to watch the movie again, no loss . If someone wants to give us a refresher on their major contributions to the movie, evil, good, or otherwise, that'd be helpful too.

[Fishbulb]

Then that is your error. I read the entire aforementioned discussion. Just because I chose not to quote two pages it doesn't mean I didn't take note of it. The error here is that you don't remember the movie well enough to have this sort of an arguement. After viewing it again, you will notice that the three-headed knight is anything but helpful; and therefore, you will see my point in the above quote. It was not taken out of context and I didn't misinterepret what you were trying to say.

If someone wants to give us a refresher on their major contributions to the movie, evil, good, or otherwise, that'd be helpful too.

Good

Knights of the Round Table (King Arther, Sir Lancelot, Sir Robin, Sir Gallahad, Sir Bedevere, Sir Not-Appearing-In-This-Film)
Concorde
Patsy
Sir Robin's Minstrels
Prince Herbert
Tim (the Enchanter)Brother Maynard
Narrator

Evil

Three-headed Knight
Black Knight
French Guards
Black Beast of Aaauuuggh
Harmless Bunny

???

Bridge Keeper
Knights Who Say "Ni!"
Castle Anthrax (Zoot, Dingo)
Dennis
Witch
Roger (the Shrubber)

By no means is this a definitive list, but I think it's a good start.

[Werebear]

*slowly and patiently*

We. Have. Had. What. Appears. To. Be. Three. Killing. Groups.

The rabbit, the three-headed knight, and the french knights.

It is day 4. If you can show me the kills from the Black Knight, the Black Beast of Aaaarrgggghhh, of the women of Castle Anthrax (Antrax? ), etc., then I'll start worrying about them. Is that fair?

[bane221]

So your suspicion resulted from the fact that I questioned their evil when it was apparent? That makes sense. Well, I explained what happened then and my FOS for Mr. Bulb (or Fish for those that know him well) is sucked away like (insert profound sucking simile here).

[Fishbulb]

*slowly and patiently*

We. Have. Had. What. Appears. To. Be. Three. Killing. Groups.

*slower and more patiently*

It. Was. A. Response. To. Bane221. Above.

Please read the whole post. I mean, I quoted and everything. If it doesn't have anything to do with you, ignore it and move on. You don't have to respond to everything as if it was directed to you, you know?

So your suspicion resulted from the fact that I questioned their evil when it was apparent? That makes sense.

At least you understand now. Hey, I didn't even vote or FOS you. I just thought it was interesting. But it's not solid enough to really worry about it.

[Fishbulb]

Good

Tim (the Enchanter)Brother Maynard
Narrator

I wrote that in a hurry. Couple of errors there. That should be:

Tim (the Enchanter)
Brother Maynard
Historian

Don't know why I put narrator.

[mathcam]

Get annoyed with Bane all you want, Fishbulb, but Werebear was making a very valid point. Even if it wasn't addressed to him, all he was saying was that an improved list would be:

Evil

:
Three-headed Knight
French Guards
Harmless Bunny

Almost Certainly Good Because There's No More Room Left For Evil People

:
Black Knight
Knights of the Round Table (King Arther, Sir Lancelot, Sir Robin, Sir Gallahad, Sir Bedevere, Sir Not-Appearing-In-This-Film)
Concorde
Patsy
Sir Robin's Minstrels
Prince Herbert
Tim (the Enchanter)Brother Maynard
Narrator
Bridge Keeper
Knights Who Say "Ni!"
Castle Anthrax (Zoot, Dingo)
Dennis
Witch
Roger (the Shrubber)

Cam

[Fishbulb]

Get annoyed with Bane all you want, Fishbulb, but Werebear was making a very valid point. Even if it wasn't addressed to him, all he was saying was that an improved list would be:

Cam

Ugh... Not you, too?

Please pay attention here.

I was not annoyed with bane221, that is just plain false. Werebear made a valid point, but it was in direct response to what I posted. Which was in response to bane asking (here's the important part)

on characters allegience

specifically

in the

movie

.

Got it that time? Not with what is happening in this game; just about from the movie.

Obviously, since Zoot hasn't been hacking people up, we can assume she is pro-town in this game. However, taking a character study from the movie, you could not say she was

good

. Sorry I didn't preface it with

only bane look here

. Hopefully I will not forget such a warning in the future.

[Fishbulb]

We still haven't heard from

mole

. I think he's avoiding us...

[mathcam]

Fine, but Werebear's point had a larger context. People have been implying all game that other groups are possibly evil, while all along Werebear has making arguments to the contrary. It was not specifically a response to your last post, but rather a point simply worth emphasizing. Maybe he misunderstood what you were getting at with your post (i.e. targeting Bane), but there's no over-emphasizing good points.

Cam

[Fishbulb]

Right right... Like I said, it's partly my fault that I didn't spell it out clearer. And the

???

was probably a bad choice. I should've put

other

in compliance with the original bane request. I think it's safe to say that we don't have the Black Beast or Black Knight (since we've seen no deaths), but it is also safe to say that no one in their right mind would claim either of them as well. So my list isn't a complete digression from this game, either.

[Macros]

im getting a replacemtn for mole, i poked him to no avail.

[Fishbulb]

That's particularly odd since he has posted several times in other games recently.

[God]

in that case he must be scum

[Werebear]

I'll harass him tomorrow morning on AIM...

[Loose Cannon]

I was going to vote for mole, but since a post by mole or a replacement is imminent, I can wait a while longer before doing so.

[Macros]

saigon has replaced mole.

[Fishbulb]

Unvote: mole

[Saigon]

OK, I'm here.

But please give me a day or two to catch up with what's going.

I'll post again when I'm updated.

[mathcam]

Temporarily good enough for me.

Unvote: Saigon

Cam