Mini 746: Speed Dating - I've Had The Time Of My Life (Over)

[EGL]

Hey sorry I haven't put in much time here lately. I've asked the mod to replace me as I've just taken a job on a mayoral campaign during a special election so our timeline is condensed.

[Max]

Well technically yes, but that would make the game dull and it may make me use my mod ability to change rules if I deem fit.

[BSG]

No, Monkey. I want to hear an explanation for this:

Yeah, Zwet is still the scummiest out there, unless someone can give me a good reason why he's not. My vote stays.

Unvote: Zwet

Don't we should be lazy and lynch the doc just because his partner is scummy.

Both posts were made after 'the doc claim'. So why didn't you unvote the first time if you'd like to keep the 'claimed' doc around?


Mole, do you think that EGL is the doc. And if so why?

[molestargazer]

Mole, do you think that EGL is the doc. And if so why?

I can't be certain, but I'm leaning towards the claim being genuine.

I would've said otherwise had the claim been unnecessary - but since Zwet was at L-2, and would almost certainly had gained more votes from the "Mrs." saga, I think that if I were him I would've claimed at the same time as well - and doing so certainly halted the lynch which could have ended our D1 prematurely and possibly killed our doc.

The lack of a counter-claim also leads me to think it's genuine. If a real doc had counter-claimed, he certainly may have been NKed, but we would have lynched a scum member in the process. Since the doc would (Probably - not sure how nights work) not have left with someone married, then he wouldn't automatically lose - and if we won, then so would he. So I think that'd be a worthwhile trade-off.

Of course, we can't discount the idea that it could be a scum ruse - but for now, I don't think it's worth the risk lynching him.

[Kmd4390]

Ok. I have reason to believe EGL probably is NOT a doc. I'm not claiming doc here, but based on my role, I don't think he is the doc. I'm not going to say more than that though.

[molestargazer]

Why have you only revealed this now?

[Caboose]

Why have you only revealed this now?

This.

The lack of a counter-claim also leads me to think it's genuine.

Be careful about this.

Jebus is still scummy. A bandwagon would be nice here (notice, NOT a lynch yet).

[MonkeyMan576]

No, Monkey. I want to hear an explanation for this:

Yeah, Zwet is still the scummiest out there, unless someone can give me a good reason why he's not. My vote stays.

Unvote: Zwet

Don't we should be lazy and lynch the doc just because his partner is scummy.

Both posts were made after 'the doc claim'. So why didn't you unvote the first time if you'd like to keep the 'claimed' doc around?


Mole, do you think that EGL is the doc. And if so why?

I changed my mind.

[zwetschenwasser]

You all are neglecting the possibility that this game might have no doc.

[Kmd4390]

Ok. I have reason to believe EGL probably is NOT a doc. I'm not claiming doc here, but based on my role, I don't think he is the doc.

I'm not going to say more than that though.

[zwetschenwasser]

Why?

[MonkeyMan576]

Ok. I have reason to believe EGL probably is NOT a doc. I'm not claiming doc here, but based on my role, I don't think he is the doc.

I'm not going to say more than that though.

I would need more info to put a vote on a possible doctor. As of now I have no reason to trust you.

[Nightfall]

You all are neglecting the possibility that this game might have no doc.

-_-'

I'm ok with lynching Zwets, I'm not sure who should go with him, but I don't think it should be a (semi) claimed doc.

[zwetschenwasser]

There are other roles that can have PhD's, you know.

[The Countess]

Let us proceed in an orderly fashion, if you get my drift...

[Nightfall]

There are other roles that can have PhD's, you know.

Which is why I wrote semi, but still, not worth the risk right now in my eyes.

[Max]

As I am searching for two replacements, I suggest you make a

Replacement Vote: XXX

So I know which player you would rather be brought back to the game

[zwetschenwasser]

The risk of what? Of killing a vanilla townie and a claimed powerrole that's being questioned by role-based info?

[roffman]

The last few posts confuse me. Are people debating the viability of the doc claim, or am I missing something?

I've been thinking about it, and realised a rather startling fact. In this game, I don't think the mafia actually have a night kill. If they did, 1 mislynch followed by a NK would leave 8/9 people in the game, 2 or 3 of which could be mafia. Which, seeing as we lynch 2 by 2, is lylo. This makes me doubt the presence of a doc role in this setup, as the potential killing power of the mafia far exceed normal balance measures. Added to this zwet's actions, and I feel I have a compelling reason to vote off the entire table.

unvote, vote: zwetschenwasser

N.B. My numbers and percieved effictiveness of the mafia's supposed NK may be off. If you see any number fallacies that I may have made, please point them out so I may correct my assumptions.

[Kmd4390]

The last few posts confuse me. Are people debating the viability of the doc claim, or am I missing something?

Ok. I have reason to believe EGL probably is NOT a doc. I'm not claiming doc here, but based on my role, I don't think he is the doc. I'm not going to say more than that though.

[molestargazer]

Is asking why you're not going to say any more yield any information, or is this a situation of trying to draw blood from a stone?

[MonkeyMan576]

The last few posts confuse me. Are people debating the viability of the doc claim, or am I missing something?

I've been thinking about it, and realised a rather startling fact. In this game, I don't think the mafia actually have a night kill. If they did, 1 mislynch followed by a NK would leave 8/9 people in the game, 2 or 3 of which could be mafia. Which, seeing as we lynch 2 by 2, is lylo. This makes me doubt the presence of a doc role in this setup, as the potential killing power of the mafia far exceed normal balance measures. Added to this zwet's actions, and I feel I have a compelling reason to vote off the entire table.

unvote, vote: zwetschenwasser

N.B. My numbers and percieved effictiveness of the mafia's supposed NK may be off. If you see any number fallacies that I may have made, please point them out so I may correct my assumptions.

Well, there could be a reviver or something to balance the game. I don't see that as a compelling reason to lynch the doctor.

[Caboose]

The last few posts confuse me. Are people debating the viability of the doc claim, or am I missing something?

I've been thinking about it, and realised a rather startling fact. In this game, I don't think the mafia actually have a night kill. If they did, 1 mislynch followed by a NK would leave 8/9 people in the game, 2 or 3 of which could be mafia. Which, seeing as we lynch 2 by 2, is lylo. This makes me doubt the presence of a doc role in this setup, as the potential killing power of the mafia far exceed normal balance measures. Added to this zwet's actions, and I feel I have a compelling reason to vote off the entire table.

unvote, vote: zwetschenwasser

N.B. My numbers and percieved effictiveness of the mafia's supposed NK may be off. If you see any number fallacies that I may have made, please point them out so I may correct my assumptions.

Ever thought that this game could be protective role heavy?

[roffman]

Even if there is a reviver or multiple protective roles, it still leaves an extremely high chance for town to be in lylo day 2. Also, if there was multiple docs, counter claims would already have occured.

[Kmd4390]

Is asking why you're not going to say any more yield any information, or is this a situation of trying to draw blood from a stone?

I only will do so if I have to claim.

counter claims would already have occured.

Why so sure?