Mini 774: Case Closed Mafia (One Truth Prevails!)

[millar13]

Vote: Millar13

for taking an anti-town policy in order to help his scum play.

FOS:BATTUOSAI

for applying "tactics" in the random voting stage

[pacman281292]

sorry, sudden V/LA strikes.

/confirm
/read

[pacman281292]

Vote: Korlash

for always self voting in the random stage... Also for being a sexy devil... rowl... I would totally close his case if you know what I mean... seriously, do you? i have no freaking Idea what that could possibly mean...

*agrees*

Vote: Korlash

[StrangerCoug]

Vote: Millar13

for taking an anti-town policy in order to help his scum play.

FOS:BATTUOSAI

for applying "tactics" in the random voting stage

And the thing wrong with that is?

[afatchic]

Vote: afatchic

for the absolute worst case I've seen of sucking.

That's a nice OMGUS you got there.

[StrangerCoug]

Vote: afatchic

for the absolute worst case I've seen of sucking.

That's a nice OMGUS you got there.

Exactly

[Firestarter]

afatchick & Strangercoug are both obv-scum.

Time I got me a wagon together!!

UNVOTE; VOTE: afatchick

[Rage]

Vote: Pacman281292

Entirely random. I just want to participate!

[millar13]

Vote: Millar13

for taking an anti-town policy in order to help his scum play.

FOS:BATTUOSAI

for applying "tactics" in the random voting stage

And the thing wrong with that is?

I've only known scum players to try and make a game serious A.S.A.P
so doing so was a scum tell

Towny doesn't feel akward around the random stage

[StrangerCoug]

Vote: Millar13

for taking an anti-town policy in order to help his scum play.

FOS:BATTUOSAI

for applying "tactics" in the random voting stage

And the thing wrong with that is?

I've only known scum players to try and make a game serious A.S.A.P
so doing so was a scum tell

By that same token,

YOU

could be scummy for trying to start serious discussion at the earliest possible moment. I don't see anything serious about Battousai's vote, nor do I see anything wrong with applying tactics in the random voting stage since truly random votes, e.g. voting with dice, are actually frowned upon. Random voting does not last forever as Mafia is not a game of Russian roulette. Therefore, I'm questioning the validity of your FoS.

Unvote: afatchic
Vote: millar13

Hey, guys! I found a good wagon here!

[Firestarter]

Vote: Millar13

for taking an anti-town policy in order to help his scum play.

FOS:BATTUOSAI

for applying "tactics" in the random voting stage

*****************

Vote: Millar13

for taking an anti-town policy in order to help his scum play.

FOS:BATTUOSAI

for applying "tactics" in the random voting stage

And the thing wrong with that is?

I've only known scum players to try and make a game serious A.S.A.P
so doing so was a scum tell

Towny doesn't feel akward around the random stage

So, by your own admission, your scum...

Thank you..

UNVOTE; VOTE: millar13

[Korlash]

Um... You two are so dumb... yeah I said it, want to fight about it?

How can miller be blamed for trying to start serious discussion after Battousai already made it serious? seriously SC...

And you Johnny... *shakes head* Shame on you... Twisting his words like that...

Man this taking random votes seriously thing is fun... I should do it more often!

[StrangerCoug]

How can miller be blamed for trying to start serious discussion after Battousai already made it serious? seriously SC...

Uh... Go through my thought processes in post #34 again.n

[Korlash]

Sure...

By that same token, YOU could be scummy for trying to start serious discussion at the earliest possible moment

... which is false... By applying tactics Bat already "tried to start serious discussion at the erliest Possible moment" and as Miller called him on it miller is no longer "trying to start" anything as it has already been started. So false. You're first sentence is false. And becuase of that, as you started off with a falseity, I don't give a rat's ass how sound the rest of your logic is. But just for the sake of continuing this fun inane conversation...

I don't see anything serious about Battousai's vote, nor do I see anything wrong with applying tactics in the random voting stage since truly random votes, e.g. voting with dice, are actually frowned upon.

In this case it doesn't matter what you see. To Miller he sees serious discussion starting, and thusly he has gone along with it. If everyone's actions were dictated by the thoughts and opinions of others this game would never end becuase no one would allow another to be right. This is actually a matter of difference of opinion, and as such that should be taken into account when making a vote.

Random voting does not last forever as Mafia is not a game of Russian roulette. Therefore, I'm questioning the validity of your FoS.

You are questioning the validity of a FOS made in the random vote stage... by arguing that applying tactics during the RVS is ok... I don't know... I kinda think an FOS is technically a tactic isn't it? It's a tactic to apply pressure without actually commiting to it...

So... pretty much your thought process was false, difference of opinions, and not even close but I'm going to lable it as a contradiction just to see what you say. I think I hit the nail on the head the first time.

[afatchic]

afatchick & Strangercoug are both obv-scum.

Time I got me a wagon together!!

UNVOTE; VOTE: afatchick

So why vote me instead of him?

[Firestarter]

UNVOTE; VOTE: afatchick

So why vote me instead of him?

Because I wanted to.. Why?

*picks up baseball bat and heads straight for Korlash*

[Korlash]

Bring it on, I'm ready to *laugh* light it up.

[millar13]

Strangecoug is probably a townie who believes he is a "scum-hunter" but is going in all gones blazing. You really don't need to put your vote down at the first possible chance. A town player doesn't need to rush into a vote, and FOS first normally work better in your favor.

As for Firestarter: I think that you are likely a scum partner who has seen this comment

Strangecoug:
"Hey, guys! I found a good wagon here!"

And used it to your advantage by doing just that. Forming a wagon so early in a game really is quite a scummy thing to do, for the simple fact that at Page 2 wagons shouldn't form.

What makes me think your even more scummy is this earlier post.

Firestarter:
"afatchick & Strangercoug are both obv-scum.

Time I got me a wagon together!!

UNVOTE; VOTE: afatchick"

Town players don't look to start or join wagon so early on in a game, unless they are genuinely sure. For this reason I think that Battousai in fact should not have been under my watch and that in fact you should be instead.

FOS: Firestarter

[Battousai]

V/LA for the rest of the weekend

[Sajin]

Vote: Millar13

for taking an anti-town policy in order to help his scum play.

FOS:BATTUOSAI

for applying "tactics" in the random voting stage

And the thing wrong with that is?

I've only known scum players to try and make a game serious A.S.A.P
so doing so was a scum tell

Towny doesn't feel akward around the random stage

Your right don't feel awkward about the random stage....

so why would you not vote, like everyone else is doing?

and why would you FOS the 2 people who put a slight bit of pressure on you, millar13?

[millar13]

If you read Post 42 Sajin you would have noticed, that I no longer FOS Battousai and instead I am looking at Firestarter in stead

And three people have put pressure on me so far, not including you...so I think you need to check your facts first and then come back to me.

I won't confirm and actually place my vote, until I am sure I that the person I am voting for appears the most scum looking. At the moment, I have suspicions but not hard fact

[Sajin]

If you read Post 42 Sajin you would have noticed, that I no longer FOS Battousai and instead I am looking at Firestarter in stead

And three people have put pressure on me so far, not including you...so I think you need to check your facts first and then come back to me.

I won't confirm and actually place my vote, until I am sure I that the person I am voting for appears the most scum looking. At the moment, I have suspicions but not hard fact

Thanks for answering the questions millar13, looks townie.

You still don't want to vote in the random voting stage, looks neither alignment, in and of itself, but stops information, slightly scummy.

You still fear being suspected though, scummy.

I do agree that the wagon needs to back off more for post content though. Wagons are bad for us, especially this early. Town needs more posts with content.

[millar13]

I don't want to vote now...because the "random stage" has stopped, and we are now very much past morning tea and gone into the seriousness of Day 1. Votes should be value not thrown around with no real reason.

And yeah I do fear of being suspected being scummy, but then again must people do tend to feel that way now and again. I just want to help the town bring the scum down to its knees.

[StrangerCoug]

Vote: Millar13

for taking an anti-town policy in order to help his scum play.

Explain how that's applying tactics, Korlash.

[Firestarter]

Hehe, Millar13, well done.

You've cracked the game, bravo...

Moreover, you've gone on to establish that a bit of pressure is scummy.

WRONG.

Pressure reveals quite alot, to ascertain who IS scummy under pressure/who IS town under pressure.
To be frank, there was no pressure at all, and your worry at appearing scummy if you had have voted is.. scummy

In the random stage no wagon will ever gather serious steam unless a scumbag does something catastrophic on their part.

So I would ask you to relax, and not get too carried away with yourself right now.

At this time, only scum can be sure of who's who, and with the little information gathered thus far, tonwies have no clue.

But pressure leads to info, and info is good for townies.

Morning tea seems to be done alright, and for this time I shall..

UNVOTE