The Werewolves of Millers Hollow (Game Over)

[dingoatemybaby]

Typically. While the men bravely huddle together, the women are cowardly wandering around the forest looking for a way to defeat werewolves.



@Zoneface - Any thoughts on yesterday? You were mighty quiet.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Um, just a query, but does this mean the girls basically get to skip today? Is there anything we are allowed to say and/or do?

Pretty much. I considered making a QuickTopics thread where the ladies could socialize, but concluded that I didn't potentially want things from a QT being brought into the actual game.

[millar13]

I win with the town! GO TOWN!

[Yosarian2]

I win with the town! GO TOWN!

You know, all you had to do is say:

Xtoxm told a half truth; if I get lynched, I won't die, but I'll basically be tree stumped; I will be able to post, but I won't be able to vote and won't count towards the vote count. My role name is "village idiot".

and there is a very good chance you would have been believed and not lynched; it makes sense, and I wouldn't have been at all surprised to hear that Xtoxm told a half truth. If you win with the town, then I'm not sure why you did all that stuff yesterday...

[millar13]

I didn't really understand the role....plus I was pissed off at the mod for bringing me into the game in such a crap position

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Actually, I have a question for the mod: What would have happened if Xtoxm was voted Mayor and later lynched? I mean, given the wording of the rules earlier on, it appears that he'd remain Mayor, since Mayorship is only passed on upon death, but lose the right to vote. Is that correct?

[zwetschenwasser]

Anscumone wanting to get in my face about double hammering yesterday?

[Yosarian2]

Anscumone wanting to get in my face about double hammering yesterday?

Hmmm...interesting to see you get so defensive.

Anyway, I really don't entirly understand why you defended Xtoxm/Millar all day but then hammered him anyway. Could you explain? The only explination you gave yesterday was that you "enjoy hammering" and that dosn't do it for me.

[Mufasa]

Hmm, this is an odd turn of events. Theoretically there may not even be any scum to lynch today given that 8 people are unlynchable. But the chance of one scum in our group is much greater than all in theirs.

Is this a suggestion for a no lynch?

[Jahudo]

Hmm, this is an odd turn of events. Theoretically there may not even be any scum to lynch today given that 8 people are unlynchable. But the chance of one scum in our group is much greater than all in theirs.

Is this a suggestion for a no lynch?

No, there's a much greater chance of 1+ scum than 0 scum here.

Answer the question:

What do you mean by "good con voyage"? Why do you want to lynch someone who you think has had a great contribution? Also, we can't lynch BM because he's away collecting mysterious plants. You're not reading close enough.

[Shadow Knight]

Bah! Go Town!!

[MikeSC6]

Yay, I said that Village Idiot could be someting other than a jester Although, I said just about everything at one point or another... We don't know if that's as far as it goes though, there could be more to it than just that.

Mufasa, could you please explain what you meant by post 595? And then you tried to make out that Jahudo was calling for a no-lynch when he blatantly wasn't, without offering any explanation for your previous post. Just odd.

Has ZONEACE even posted yet? Haschel, has ZONEACE PMed you about his absence or anything like that?

[Percy]

Anscumone wanting to get in my face about double hammering yesterday?

Sure! Nice to see you're trying to wriggle out of it already, by pre-labelling your attacker as scum.

You had spent

SO LONG

saying that it was a pile of WIFOM, that we shouldn't lynch him, then saying he was a jester, then saying he wasn't, and then hammering without stating why you'd had a change of heart or concisely stating your position. So, explain yourself.

Mufasa has been acting really weird too. Answer the questions put to you.

ZONEACE promised a post on Wednesday. I am going to

Vote: ZONEACE

until he comes up with some fucking

excellent

scumhunting.

[Jahudo]

@Zwet: What were the main reasons that made you decide to lynch millar? Which people made the best argument that changed your mind?

Zoneace hasn't posted anywhere on this site, so it doesn't look like lurking. He could use a prod in another day or so.

[Mufasa]

My bad guys the con voyage i meant to put conveying but my spell check came up wrong, and as far as the entire no lynch, I just thought he might be insinuating a no lynch, which I by far am against myself, but I was just curious to his stand.

[Firestarter]

Responding to prod?

Will post later on.

[zwetschenwasser]

*facepalm* It's fine for a jester to win so we can cut back on the WIFOM which would otherwise plague us until the end of time.

This is the pre-hammer post where I changed my mind on things.

[dingoatemybaby]

ZONEACE promised a post on Wednesday. I am going to

Vote: ZONEACE

until he comes up with some fucking

excellent

scumhunting.

In your experience, does this kind of vote actually get lurkers to post? Would you support pushing up the vote count on him and eventually lynching if he doesn't provide "excellent scumhunting"?

[Percy]

Calling out lurkers, voting for them and demanding quality participation doesn't seem like a bad idea. I don't have much experience, so I can't comment on its overall efficacy, but I'm willing to give it a spin.

If he doesn't get replaced and starts actively participating, then I won't want him to be lynched. For the moment, I just can't see how anyone would be OK with a player

skipping all of the first day

and then posting only to defend themselves. Lurkers (especially ones like this) should be lynched as scum.


@zwet: were you seriously worried about millar sticking around until endgame?

[millar13]

He should be!

[millar13]

If you think about it....I am the only pro-town player that i confirmed, although I have no vote. Therefore, if I start playing properly I can be a huge asset. Only opposition to the town, are going to discredit me in an attempt to reduce the town further.

[Yosarian2]

If you think about it....I am the only pro-town player that i confirmed, although I have no vote. Therefore, if I start playing properly I can be a huge asset. Only opposition to the town, are going to discredit me in an attempt to reduce the town further.

Your general role is confirmed. Your alignment is not; you may have some strange kind of role with a win condition other then "You win when the threat of lycanthropy is eliminated".

That being said, you most likely are pro-town, and I'm interested to hear what you have to say.

[Firestarter]

For all we know, M13, if he has a win condition, has probably been met.
In a post I made earlier, I found that one of the conditions is convincing town to lynch a village idiot...

In any case, alignment is unknown. So ignoring him may be the best idea.

_____________________

I'm not believing that one haha so reviewing day one the most likely person to lynch is Battle Mage for his contribution is so great that he needs to be lynched on the simple matter that he has a good con voyage.

Mufasa, you explained the typo, but you did not explain why BM should be lynched. Explain

FoS: Mufasa

[Barrylocke]

Concerning Lurkers, I think since theirs plenty of time, if he's gone from the whole site, it might be better to see if he gets prodded and replaced. Of course, I know players can let mods know that they're lurking on purpose, so if he is, he probably wont be replaced. But I still feel calls for prods should happen before lynchs.

[Haschel Cedricson]

ZONEACE has been prodded.