Dichotomafia- Games Over

[willows_weep]

Heya,
Ok, Im also not clear on the 'std explain yourself' part.

But reading back in answer to someones question: PB was 'cleared' in the thread that just closed.

And Talitha in reply to your comment previous, Im on a constant limited access.Sorry!

[willows_weep]

Oh, wait , Tally isn't here right now right?

[Fishbulb]

Nope, she sure isn't.

[Coron]

I'm here everyone!

[Norinel]

*bump*

Prodding Mastermind of Sin and Mgm, seeking replacements for KingEnigma and Silgado106.

[Mgm]

Other obligations have kept me from rereading, but the prod reached me in perfect order. I'm still here.

[Mastermind of Sin]

proddy prod prod!

Can anybody recap what claims have been made, if any? In the meantime, I'll

vote: Coron

, cuz he's younger than I am.

[PeaceBringer]

MOS- I am live Roleblocker who managed to block godfather day 2- have not blocked anyone in the following 2 days

I think I maybe the only live claim at the moment-

[Save The Dragons]

I'd say let's go random, but apparently nobody likes that. So I'll just sit here and ferment with the rest of you.

[ralphmerridew]

STD: You claimed you were a vig in the village. Would you demonstrate that ability by killing somebody who hasn't been cleared in the village?

[Save The Dragons]

Oh ok, who do you want me to kill?

[Fishbulb]

Uh... Not me?

[ralphmerridew]

He can't kill you in the village; you were just lynched there. And I'm not sure who STD should target; he's the only person I find suspicious village-side.

[Coron]

Can we start talking about town

not

village, I'd rather not remember that I was scum.

[Mgm]

Let's stir things up.

Vote:Fishbulb

[Coron]

I'd say that our scum is somewhere in this group(all of it)
Save The Dragons
Mastermind of Sin (Replacing Flying Dutchman)
Mgm
Fuldu
willows_weep
Fishbulb
ralphmerridew

vote: MoS

He help lynch both tally and MMCL and is on this list, the other one that did that was StD. He is my second choice.

[Save The Dragons]

Wow! We lynched two people we thought were scum! Doh! How could we have been so dumb?

Please, don't you people have any other stones to throw at me?

Vote Coron

[Save The Dragons]

That was an overreaction, sorry, but I feel like I've heard this arguement 1000 times.

If you believe that people shouldn't be killed for what even remotely looks like a lepton's gambit, then good for you, let the scum claim cop and go free.

I have no better place to put my vote anyway.

[Fishbulb]

Let's stir things up.

Vote:Fishbulb

Well, I feel stirred...

Now what?

Is this still Day 1?

[Coron]

I think that the tally lynch almost surely contains a good # of scum and the mmcl one might have a few too. Especially the Tally lynch.
Fishbulb, I guess is another canidate for scum on that list.
MoS got my vote by abitrary voting on day 4. Otherwise it'd have been a toss up.

[Mgm]

I think you're theory is flawed, Coron. Because MMCL was lynched based on Tally's information, there was a good chance townies were going to go after Tally regardless of her claim. Several people expressed that thought, and I think that there were enough townies for a substantial bandwagon to form without too much scum help.

No doubt, there's scum in these wagons trying to appear like clueless townies, but I think you have a better chance at finding scum by looking at people's voting patterns instead of just being on those two wagons. Who was overeager? Did we even have any succesful scum lynches in the town? See who stayed away from those.

[Coron]

I did look at who seemed to attack nanook the first couple days, I crossed them off the list.

[Fishbulb]

No doubt, there's scum in these wagons trying to appear like clueless townies, but I think you have a better chance at finding scum by looking at people's voting patterns instead of just being on those two wagons. Who was overeager? Did we even have any succesful scum lynches in the town? See who stayed away from those.

If you know the best way to find scum, then why are random voting

me

? From the way that sounds, you haven't attempted any of that yourself, but yet you're telling Coron to do it.

[Fuldu]

Coron, your list basically boils down to "I don't think KingEnigma or PeaceBringer is scum," and it appears that your only reason for that is that they attacked Nanook in the first couple days instead of going after MMCL or Talitha. It's not a terrible argument, but neither is it a great one. Scum attack one another all the time, and the early days are often the best time to do it. But the way you've chosen to frame it ('these people might be scum' as versus 'these people seem relatively innocent'), especially when your actual argument is based on which people have exhibited innocent behavior, seems scummy to me.

vote: Coron

[PeaceBringer]

Coron, your list basically boils down to "I don't think KingEnigma or PeaceBringer is scum," and it appears that your only reason for that is that they attacked Nanook in the first couple days instead of going after MMCL or Talitha. It's not a terrible argument, but neither is it a great one. Scum attack one another all the time, and the early days are often the best time to do it. But the way you've chosen to frame it ('these people might be scum' as versus 'these people seem relatively innocent'), especially when your actual argument is based on which people have exhibited innocent behavior, seems scummy to me.

vote: Coron

Hmm, I

haven't liked your play in this game, this statement a prime example. unvote, Vote Fuldu