MKM II GAME OVER

[AceMarksman]

unvote

waiting on Surye.

What's our next step?

I think our next step should be killing off the non-list player who has been drawing the most suspicion. If I'm not mistaken, that person is ortolan, right?

Mod edit
Visible Votecount

-ortolan (3): populartajo, Shadow Knight, AceMarksman
-Shinnen_no_Me (2): Riceballtail, Surye
-Shadow Knight (2): Moratorium, ortolan
--populartajo (1): zwetschenwasser
-Gorrad (1): Empking
-zwetschenwasser (1): Shinnen_no_Me

Not voting (7): killa seven, WeyounsLastClone, Cream147, Gorrad, caf19, semioldguy, qwints

With 17 alive it takes 9 real votes to lynch.

[zwetschenwasser]

Unvote; Vote: ortolan

Chop chop people!

[caf19]

Here's a question for Surye.

When the holder of a bob-omb dies, what happens to it?

a) it gets given to someone else and its trade count gets reset
b) it gets given to someone else and its trade count does not get reset
c) it gets used on someone else
d) it gets used on the person who dies
e) it disappears

Standard fare, raise your hand if you think this question is useless or gives scum too much info or whatever.

[WeyounsLastClone]

Standard fare, raise your hand if you think this question is useless or gives scum too much info or whatever.

If it gave too much info, then the damage is done already, so...

Anyway, I think there's already more than enough info given about our items to the mafia.

[zwetschenwasser]

This is exactly why these multiple choice questions are horrible.

[ortolan]

While this is the main focus of the game

there's not much else to do now

is there (although I will admit being busy has also impacted on my ability to contribute to this and other games).

Obv not scumhunting.
If I were a townie with no item descriptions, Ill be rereading the thread to evaluate reactions, thinlking who feels more town and such.
What does ortolan do?
Complot against the plan.
I think ortolan is a extremely healthy D1 lynch. I can go with shadowknight too.

1) When did I say I had no item descriptions?

2) I am scumhunting. I am voting scum (ShadowKnight), if you didn't notice.

3) What are your reasons for wanting me (or ShadowKnight???) lynched?

The implicat part evaluates people in a more "mafia" way. That means that we have to evaluate reactions to the current situations. With that part of the plan I think ort is very likely scum and that Mora is very likely town.

After all, we are playing mafia, right?

I'm sorry, I forgot that opposing a mass-claim is a 100% accurate scum-tell.

I think our next step should be killing off the non-list player who has been drawing the most suspicion. If I'm not mistaken, that person is ortolan, right?

*Yawn*

[ortolan]

I do have a bit of meta-info that pt has a habit of trying to break mechanics/ask for mass-claims in several games, so I'm not necessarily positing it as a scum-tell here. I am of the opinion that this whole exercise was quite a waste of time however. The idea of lynching from the non-claimed-items group relies on the assumption that firstly scum don't know the item descriptions, and secondly that the strongest town power-roles are more and not less likely to be able to buy items. Neither of these are wise to make at all.

[Lawrencelot]

Sorry, I was V/LA.

Surye has been prodded Thirsday and has not picked up his prod yet. Same for Shinnen. I will look for replacements for these people, and in the meanwhile give you guys a present.

Deadline! May 4th 2009.

[populartajo]

Not to be the voice of impending doom, but I have an inkling that poptajo is about to get modkilled for that revelation post earlier.

You want me to get modkilled, why?

[populartajo]

While this is the main focus of the game

there's not much else to do now

is there (although I will admit being busy has also impacted on my ability to contribute to this and other games).

Obv not scumhunting.
If I were a townie with no item descriptions, Ill be rereading the thread to evaluate reactions, thinlking who feels more town and such.
What does ortolan do?
Complot against the plan.
I think ortolan is a extremely healthy D1 lynch. I can go with shadowknight too.

1) When did I say I had no item descriptions?

2) I am scumhunting. I am voting scum (ShadowKnight), if you didn't notice.

3) What are your reasons for wanting me (or ShadowKnight???) lynched?

The implicat part evaluates people in a more "mafia" way. That means that we have to evaluate reactions to the current situations. With that part of the plan I think ort is very likely scum and that Mora is very likely town.

After all, we are playing mafia, right?

I'm sorry, I forgot that opposing a mass-claim is a 100% accurate scum-tell.

I think our next step should be killing off the non-list player who has been drawing the most suspicion. If I'm not mistaken, that person is ortolan, right?

*Yawn*

You are saying you have item descriptions?

[populartajo]

I do have a bit of meta-info that pt has a habit of trying to break mechanics/ask for mass-claims in several games, so I'm not necessarily positing it as a scum-tell here. I am of the opinion that this whole exercise was quite a waste of time however. The idea of lynching from the non-claimed-items group relies on the assumption that firstly scum don't know the item descriptions, and secondly that the strongest town power-roles are more and not less likely to be able to buy items. Neither of these are wise to make at all.

Fail.
Why do people think that this was a waste of time when we have TONS of reactions?
Ortolan, if you are town, I suggest you analyse these reactions Im telling you and come up with a good case other than OMGUS.

[populartajo]

This is also pretty clear. Either all scum have item descriptions or either they dont.

That means that if scum have item descriptions, that means that they are prob all in the I have item descriptions list or that they are prob all in the I dont have item descriptions list or I refuse to.

The fact that we have items that become useless when scum knows how they work, means that its more prob that scum DONT have item descriptions.

Therefore, its safe to assume that only Bowser's Army have item descriptions in their PMs. Which at the same time means, that people not in the Bowser's Army dont have item descriptions in their PMs.

Now,. ortolan lynch gogogogogogogo.

[Lawrencelot]

ZEEnon replaces Surye.
Looker replaces Shinnen_no_me.

Thanks guys.

[populartajo]

Zeenon and Surye, please tell us your first impressions of the game as soon as you can.

[AceMarksman]

ZEEnon and looker, why are you stalking me?

[Looker]

unvote

[Looker]

i guess i like your playstyle and how readable you are

[zwetschenwasser]

Not to be the voice of impending doom, but I have an inkling that poptajo is about to get modkilled for that revelation post earlier.

You want me to get modkilled, why?

Nice misrep.

[populartajo]

Not to be the voice of impending doom, but I have an inkling that poptajo is about to get modkilled for that revelation post earlier.

You want me to get modkilled, why?

Nice misrep.

No it isnt,
If you are town and if you thought I could get modkilled for that then you dont post that in the hopes of Law or scum not noticing it.

[zwetschenwasser]

Nope. You are scum. I want you lynched or modkilled, and I could not care less how or when.

[Looker]

@tajo- yeah, after rereading and paying close attentioni to ortolan, I'm gonna have to go with a

unvote, vote ortolan

He's made a lot of statements that just rub me the wrong way. Its nothing I can really articulate, but my gut feels good with this.

While this is the main focus of the game

there's not much else to do now

is there (although I will admit being busy has also impacted on my ability to contribute to this and other games).

Obv not scumhunting.
If I were a townie with no item descriptions, Ill be rereading the thread to evaluate reactions, thinlking who feels more town and such.
What does ortolan do?
Complot against the plan.
I think ortolan is a extremely healthy D1 lynch. I can go with shadowknight too.

1) When did I say I had no item descriptions?

2) I am scumhunting. I am voting scum (ShadowKnight), if you didn't notice.

3) What are your reasons for wanting me (or ShadowKnight???) lynched?

The implicat part evaluates people in a more "mafia" way. That means that we have to evaluate reactions to the current situations. With that part of the plan I think ort is very likely scum and that Mora is very likely town.

After all, we are playing mafia, right?

I'm sorry, I forgot that opposing a mass-claim is a 100% accurate scum-tell.

I think our next step should be killing off the non-list player who has been drawing the most suspicion. If I'm not mistaken, that person is ortolan, right?

*Yawn*

@tajo- yeah, after rereading and paying close attentioni to ortolan, I'm gonna have to go with a

unvote, vote ortolan

He's made a lot of statements that just rub me the wrong way. Its nothing I can really articulate, but my gut feels good with this.

Unvote
Vote: ShadowKnight

ShadowKnight is scum guys, we can lynch him now. That's my work done for today.

Alright, so there we have it. According to the posts of both of these individuals, one of these two is scum. Which is it? To try to balance things until we, or I, can come to a decision, I will

vote shadow knight

. Until then, I am open to suggestions, especially if they come from shadow knight or ortolan.

[populartajo]

Nope. You are scum. I want you lynched or modkilled, and I could not care less how or when.

Woah.
I am scum WHY?

[zwetschenwasser]

Because I think you're scum.

[populartajo]

Looker, why one of ortolan and Shadow is scum?

Also, did you reread all the game?

You have item descriptions in your PM?

[populartajo]

Because I think you're scum.

No, no.

Give me a reason.

Now.