Two things about shinnen to remember:
1) He was one of the first to declare Bowser's Army the town.
Post 118
Shinnen_no_Me wrote:Because claiming Mario is likely claiming scum. Why would anyone try to claim scum? For me, is that he doesn't know that.
2) He flipped on the item claiming idea:
Post 203
Shinnen_no_Me wrote:The item idea seems good. However, there are some points we should consider it first. Wouldn't doing that give more information to the already-informed minority? And, what about players like Ace (not that I fully believe him, but that's a possibility) that don't know about the items? Or the third party players? Also, what gives us the security that the mafia doesn't know how our items operate?
I want us to consider these, and others I haven't pointed out, issues about the item claim, because we might end up giving more aid than problems to scum.
Post 249
Shinnen_no_Me wrote:Now that I think about this, I find it to be a not so good idea. If we assume as true that some roles can't buy items, we will assume that the ones that can are more powerful. By claiming who can and who can't, we're just giving the mafia a pretty good list of who they should kill at nights. Sorry, but I'm not finding that a very smart thing to do.
I don't think these posts point to scum. After all, our pm's didn't explicitly tell us that BA's was the majority. I doubt scum would be that eager to put that information out there. Furthermore, his response to the item claiming feels townie and reasonable.
Also, I think ortolan has been more honest in his intentions than ShadowKnight.
Since apparently, one of them must be scum:
unvote, vote Shadowknight
