Ortolan's defense of Looker is also noted.ortolan wrote: I also disapprove of tajo attempting to redirect votes to another player as a result, solely because of their "lurking" (on day one).
Bad idea in my opinion. Scum will know that they hit you, so you keeping quiet about it only hides information from the town. You don't have to say anything more but saying that you were hit and lived last night doesn't seem like something you would have to keep quiet about. Who are you intending to keep that information quiet from exactly? Because scum would already know that they targeted you.Shadow Knight wrote:I plan to keep quiet about when I'm targetted the first time and what I gain (if anything) from it.
Sounds like role-fishing to me.Shadow Knight wrote:I doubt there is a similar role to mine as I'll be more than a little pissed that they didn't come forward and back me up sooner.
Not all of the fake claims from last game were elaborate. For reference last game they were: Dr. Mario, Shy Guy, Paper Mario, Rosalina, Baby Luigi and Bob-omb.populartajo wrote:When I said scum had elaborate claims I meant that usually scum dont claim a simple role like goomba in a bubble.
They did know that "Toad" was the vanilla of last game. From one of the Bowser PM's last game: "But because you are all disguised as a Toad, it might be better to pretend that you’re a Toad."populartajo wrote:A reason I thought why this claim could be legit is cuz I tought that the vanilla version of this game were Goombas. For reference, in the other game, scum had fakeclaims like Dr. Mario and at the beginning they didnt know that the Toads were the vanillas of the game.
No one should answer this.populartajo wrote:However, if Goombas arent the vanillas of the game, then who are the vanillas of this game?
Of course they were elaborate. They are not vanillas, they hint PRs.oldguy wrote:Not all of the fake claims from last game were elaborate. For reference last game they were: Dr. Mario, Shy Guy, Paper Mario, Rosalina, Baby Luigi and Bob-omb.
Yes, but this doesnt mean they could infer 100% that Toads were the vanillas of the game.oldguy wrote:They did know that "Toad" was the vanilla of last game. From one of the Bowser PM's last game: "But because you are all disguised as a Toad, it might be better to pretend that you’re a Toad."
Im evaluating this. One of the strategies to own scum in MKMI was to use the vanilla role as a way to semiconfirm people with the same vanilla role, kinda like we are using the item descriptions claim right now.oldguy wrote:No one should answer this.
AceMarksman wrote:Players without item descriptions can't use items either.
Gorrad wrote:...I confirm Ace's statement about not being able to use items (and our PMs saying as such)....
This coming from the only other three people who claim not to have item descriptions.Empking wrote:We can't use items.
Indeed. What was the question that qwints answered?Moratorium wrote:qwints wrote: The red shell costs 2 more coins than the green shell.Problem.Daybreak wrote: qwints, Yoshi (Mushroom Kingdom), killed Night 1.
Hi, Kast.Kast wrote:Hi all, I'm replacing Cream.
I read through the game prior to replacing in and I have a pro-town impression from Moratorium, Ortolan, and Semioldguy.
Cream didn't claim about items, I'm guessing part of it is because cream also cannot buy or use any items.
Also, Qwints has flipped mushroom kingdom, but Qwints is one of the players who had bowser's army items (or rather information on those items).
But SK was also mushroom kingdom but did not (or claimed to not) have bowser's army information.
We didn't have a night 0 (game started in Day 1 if I'm reading everything correctly), so possibly only some of Mushroom Kingdom had item descriptions and did not have a chance to share it?
I am going to comb through the thread really closely and make sure there was no way for him to somehow deduce this.Moratorium wrote:qwints wrote: The red shell costs 2 more coins than the green shell.Problem.Daybreak wrote: qwints, Yoshi (Mushroom Kingdom), killed Night 1.
He prob doesnt know it.Gorrad wrote:Vote: Sirdanilot
Why are you now in this game? Tell the truth or die.
Please do so. You are good on that.semioldguy wrote:I am going to comb through the thread really closely and make sure there was no way for him to somehow deduce this.Moratorium wrote:qwints wrote: The red shell costs 2 more coins than the green shell.Problem.Daybreak wrote: qwints, Yoshi (Mushroom Kingdom), killed Night 1.