@Gorrad-
You suspected him and set a trap, when the trap fails, you ignore it and decide he is scummy anyway. Confirmation bias.
@Sirdanilot-
Tajo's right, you avoided answering that question. What faction are you part of?
@Mora-
It would help oh so much if you could link to those posts you took the trouble to reference us to.
Also, to clarify, the 4/17 that I listed were just pulled from Tajo's list at the end of the day. Your list makes more sense in context of when Qwint's actually made his comment. It doesn't change my thought that Qwint's comment does not necessarily mean that the distribution of non-MK players within those 4 players is significantly higher than any other random sample of 4 players.
@Catching SK-
I think the claiming indirectly led to SK's lynch. The deciding factor really seems to be Ace's questioning about item buying and item usage. He had some pressure already from Ort's scum hunting, but I think that catch by Ace was what tipped things over (indirect result of the item claiming).
I think Semioldguy's speculation makes a lot of sense and answers the SK question pretty well. SK very likely had access to BA item information and probably had no limitations on item usage. He was probably being honest that he can't buy BA items but that would be because he is MK and not BA.
I'd hazard a guess that nobody on MK or any non BA faction can buy BA items since trading would essentially mean any player within that faction has access to those items.
@Ace-
The item claiming plan was no more "sound" on Day 1 than it is today. The very risk that has now been confirmed was raised more than once. There were other objections as well. The town decided to push ahead with the plan despite it's risks.
@Ort's question about Tajo-
That said, I think Tajo's persistence and posts reflect an earnest (mistaken) belief that his plan was "game-breaking". This attitude makes him look pro-town.
Actually, to be more clear, I think Tajo seemed genuinely convinced that his plan would help him, and I don't think it was aimed at helping the MK
.
I don't like that he tried backing out of SK's lynch at end of day, however, I don't think anything he said at that point had any chance of actually protecting SK. It looks like distancing but no intent to save (also no danger of no lynch).
The speculation that Tajo may be a third party player actually fits better considering this. In the previous game, the third parties were concerned with collecting coins. The item claiming plan aids that objective by narrowing down players who are more likely to have coins/able to purchase items.
@Zwet lynch-
Zwet is random, and I find I mostly ignore him (and he mostly ignores me). He's looking to get reactions out of people.
If he looks like he is actively harming the town, I would be actively in favor of his lynch. Fortunately, everyone realizes that he makes no sense and nobody is about to be swayed by his craplogic. Atm, I think the greatest disservice he is doing is distracting players from trying to actually scumhunt and/or pressure the lurkers to post and/or get prodded/replaced.
If he starts using his vote in an anti-town manner (ie. placing people at L-1 without warning, hammering or attempting to hammer) or if someone finds something actually scummy about him, I could see a Zwet lynch being appropriate.
To be clear, I am not opposed to Zwet's lynch but I think we should focus elsewhere until/unless Zwet does something more significant that being stupid/random.
