MKM II GAME OVER

[Kast]

@Gorrad-
There is a LOT of falling (or ability to fall) in most of the castles in most Mario Games.

A couple points I dislike about you claiming:
-You just made yourself a huge target for DK and WW if they are coin stealers in this game.
-You may have cut off the town's ability to reinforce and it was done very unnecessarily.

-"Buying" new players seems a bit anti-synergistic with not being able to buy/use items.

But I guess after your claims from before, it would be tough for you to just say, "Nvm, I don't want to share why I made him claim"

Mod edit
Visible Votecount

-zwetschenwasser (5): AceMarksman, caf19, Moratorium, Gorrad, populartajo
-populartajo (2): zwetschenwasser, ortolan
-Moratorium (1): Empking

Not voting (10): killa seven, Kast, ZEEnon, Riceballtail, Looker, sirdanilot, semioldguy, WeyounsLastClone

With 16 alive it takes 9 real votes to lynch.

[sirdanilot]

I'm bowser's army.

Gorrad why did you just out yourself. Why would anyone be able to summon a scum player. In fact the whole jump in deal seems quite stupid to me.

Why is zwet being lynched. So far he doesn't stand out to me? tbh it looks like you are just lynching him for the sake of lynching zwetschenwasserchsadfasdflk. Other than his username there seems to be little to no base for this.

For the sake of contributing, poptajo seems suspicious to me (as of page 12).

fos poptajo

. I can't really explain why very well now. Combination of a strong gut feeling I haven't felt in a while, the massclaim debacle, the items thing, now the zwet claim proposal. The latter may become weaker when I learn the reasons for zwet suspicion.

Do you guys want to stay updated like this while I read? I felt it might be helpful.

[Gorrad]

Yes, but not falling into. I suppose the game could be played in the basement or something...

But yeah, I couldn't really not claim after all the pressure.

[sirdanilot]

-"Buying" new players seems a bit anti-synergistic with not being able to buy/use items.

? this makes perfect sense to me? can't buy items, instead can buy players?

[Moratorium]

Why is zwet being lynched. So far he doesn't stand out to me? tbh it looks like you are just lynching him for the sake of lynching zwetschenwasserchsadfasdflk. Other than his username there seems to be little to no base for this.

You claimed Wario!

Amongst other reasons.

[Moratorium]

Do you guys want to stay updated like this while I read? I felt it might be helpful.

Yes please, I'd like to see your progression of thought.

[sirdanilot]

Yes, but not falling into. I suppose the game could be played in the basement or something...

? stop uttering nonsense. jumping is a key element in mario games. anyway the 'fits with jumping in' part was not part of the mod's flavor, it was my speculation of why the mod told me something like 'the ground came closer and closer'

back to read

[Moratorium]

and btw, @ortolan

...so you're not Mushroom Kingdom?

This post made me laugh pretty hard. You are hereby awarded one shiny medal for attempting to befuddle the new guy into a scum confession right out of the gate.

[sirdanilot]

I now have some town reads as well which I think I shouldn't reveal as well as that paradoxically ortolan is quite scummy too (from my read, not from the dumb 'are you not mk' question) im at page 14

[Kast]

Why is zwet being lynched. So far he doesn't stand out to me? tbh it looks like you are just lynching him for the sake of lynching zwetschenwasserchsadfasdflk. Other than his username there seems to be little to no base for this.

-It's not his username. It's his playstyle. He posts erratically, and what he does post tend to make little to no sense. He votes erratically as well, often abandoning everything he has said previously and latching on to the latest argument that someone posted.

He does this in many games as both town and scum.

-Yes, please keep us updated with your thoughts as you read.

@Anti-synergistic claim-
He has claimed a role that needs a lot of coins. Either he can collect them himself or needs players to trust him and send him coins. Either way, it is a role that, by design, wants to accumulate coins, but has no recourse to use those coins until he collects a very large number. That is anti-synergistic.

I separated that one off because synergy is not necessary in every role. Some roles are more anti-synergistic for game balance purposes. Also, I believe his role claim for reason stated previously.

[Lawrencelot]

I am V/LA this weekend

[AceMarksman]

I'm not liking sirdanilot at all right now.

[sirdanilot]

-It's not his username. It's his playstyle. He posts erratically, and what he does post tend to make little to no sense. He votes erratically as well, often abandoning everything he has said previously and latching on to the latest argument that someone posted.

He does this in many games as both town and scum.

Hence why there's no way we should lynch him. It's just too easy. Find some tells that are very specific that point to him being scum.

Although his play style may be 'erratic', it doesn't come off as scummy to me.

AceMarksman - why is that? Explain please.

[Moratorium]

You're at page 14, why are you saying "there's no way we should lynch him"? You don't even know the whole story yet?

[AceMarksman]

Thank you, mora.
@sir: It doesn't seem like you're reading as fast as you can, and you're drawing conclusions from the first 1/4 of the game.

[AceMarksman]

Mod, note my sig. I'll try to post some, but I'll be rather inundated

[populartajo]

Im not sure if zwet is scum or town.

I want him either to

a) claim so we decide if its belieavable or not and start talking about better things.

b) start making sense

Zwet, your choice.

[zwetschenwasser]

I'm a buzzy beetle! I have a shell that I think protects me from nightkills (from fire, to be specific). Now let's lynch poptajo for his unjustified OMGUS on me.

[Moratorium]

I have a shell that

I think

protects me from nightkills

Please explain.

[AceMarksman]

If I weren't already voting for zwet, I would now. He pretty much copied and pasted that from the supermario wiki page on buzzy beetles here. If you look at your PM, you will see the stark differences. Also, note where he says that he "thinks" that protects him from nightkills. I know at least that in my role PM, it specifically outlines what immunities I do and do not have.

[Riceballtail]

Confirm vote: popthetaco

/facepalm.
now why?

Why the appeal to emotion Tajo?

This is not appeaal to emotion.

Could you share what you think of everyone?

This is very clearly appeal to emotion. It's dripping with emotion from when you submerged in the emotional vat of glutenous emotion.

No excuses, say it.

[semioldguy]

I'm a buzzy beetle! I have a shell that I think protects me from nightkills (from fire, to be specific). Now let's lynch poptajo for his unjustified OMGUS on me.

I don't believe this claim because (1) why would you only

think

that you are protected from fire? and (2) I don't think a buzzy beetle has any arms with which to use items, which you have claimed to be able to use.

[AceMarksman]

FoS: riceballtail

Actual contributions please (like responding to the post directly previous to yours).

[caf19]

I have a shell that

I think

protects me from nightkills

Please explain.

This.

[populartajo]

I have a shell that

I think

protects me from nightkills

Please explain.

This.

qft