The Werewolves of Millers Hollow (Game Over)

[Jahudo]

I asked for a Pepper prod near the top of this page.

Percy, by thinking you were putting Dr. Pepper to L-1, were you ready to hear him claim?

[zwetschenwasser]

I want a claim.

[Percy]

Oh yes, I was expecting him (and wanted him) to claim in his next post.

[Kaiveran]

Yheah, that's what I thought the plan was. Of course, he's messed things up pretty bad for himself already. There is a possibility that it could be a Lyncher situation.

Where's the host?

[DizzyIzzyB13]

The mod hasn't posted anywhere in, like, a week.

[dingoatemybaby]

Anyone try to prod the mod?

[Jahudo]

I just sent him a PM.

[Firestarter]

Guys, apologies for not getting a post down in the last few days, after a heavy week of work, Ive a backlog to get through, and cannot find the time to give thoughts in any of the games Im in at present.

Come the weekend however, Im free, and I promise to offer input to this game..

[zwetschenwasser]

*twiddles thumbs*

[Haschel Cedricson]

Sorry, I haven't had a chance to check the site the last few days.

Vote count now.

[Haschel Cedricson]

(5)Dr Pepper: dingoatemybaby, Jahudo, Kaiveran, zwetschenwasser, Percy
(2)dingoatemybaby: Dr Pepper, Yosarian2
(1)Mufasa: Firestarter,
(1)Kaiveran:
(0)zwetschenwasser:
MikeSC6
Barrylocke
Percy:
Yosarian2
Firestarter
Jahudo

Not Voting: Mufasa, Barrylocke, MikeSC6

With 12 votes in play it takes 7 to lynch.

No luck on a replacement for Barrylocke. I don't know what the caterina thing was. Sending prods to people who need them.

[Yosarian2]

Reread the discussion and dingo's scumminess should stick out like a sore thumb.

Zwet: (I assume you mean "pepper" and not "dingo" here, right?) Could you be a little more specific about why you think pepper looks scummy?

[Mufasa]

vote dr pepper

Its your time to go

[MikeSC6]

Dr Pepper's at L-1 right now- should we wait, see if he's still playing, and if not quiz his replacement? Though I'm not sure how a replacement could defend things that have been said by a predecessor.

I'm tempted to put my vote back on Mufasa, and not bother with the "lynch him tomorrow" plan. We should only go along with the plans of townies, and I really don't think Mufasa's a townie. But then would he give an honest plan if he was scum, and knew we were on to him? Ah, WIFOM.

[Dr Pepper]

I am still here even though I quit for all intents and purposes a while ago.

The multiple day two replacements, rampant lurking, and inability to understand even the simplest of arguements have ruined this game for me. The only reason I even bothered posting is to save the time it would normally take to replace me.

No offense Firestarter, but your last four or five posts have been "Sorry guys, will post later." Based on your track record so far today, I am hestitant to accept any more excuses.

No, I am not going to claim.

So any scumone wanna drop the hammer on me?

[Dr Pepper]

Actually, I'll solve this right now.

unvote

vote Dr Pepper

[dingoatemybaby]

Gah. If Pepper is townie, that is extremely bad play. I guess it is bad play for anything but a Jester.

But Pepper is right about Firestarter. He is closing in on 3 weeks of promises to post in the near future.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

So, since that appears to be the end of the day, does anyone feel like writing a summary for all those players who were barred from participating today so that we can limit the flake out rate?

[Yosarian2]

So, since that appears to be the end of the day, does anyone feel like writing a summary for all those players who were barred from participating today so that we can limit the flake out rate?

I would, but I honestly have absolutly no idea why we lynched Pepper today, and no one seemed interested in explaining their votes to me. I was *here*, and I don't understand what happened.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

That's some fine work there, guys.

[dingoatemybaby]

I would, but I honestly have absolutly no idea why we lynched Pepper today, and no one seemed interested in explaining their votes to me. I was *here*, and I don't understand what happened.

I get that you don't agree with the reasoning, but I feel like it was explained ad nauseum.

[zwetschenwasser]

WTF???

[Jahudo]

I would, but I honestly have absolutly no idea why we lynched Pepper today, and no one seemed interested in explaining their votes to me. I was *here*, and I don't understand what happened.

Misrepresenting dingo in order to assume suspicion. It is plainly there but perhaps not intentional (that's the matter of opinion).

I'd say Mufasa looked opportunistic in his vote but he's already volunteered to be tomorrow's lynch so that's a good place to start when we have all the players back.

If anyone had thought or does think that the circumstances of dingo vs Pepper debate make it very likely that one or the other is scum and very unlikely that they are both town, then that's probably a debate for tomorrow too. I don't see it that way personally but I think even dingo and Pepper were proposing that.

[Yosarian2]

I would, but I honestly have absolutly no idea why we lynched Pepper today, and no one seemed interested in explaining their votes to me. I was *here*, and I don't understand what happened.

I get that you don't agree with the reasoning, but I feel like it was explained ad nauseum.

Well, fair enough; you gave a reason, you thought he was misrepresenting you, although he really wasn't. I don't think anyone else gave any kind of reason for voting him, though, as far as I can tell.

I donno. We'll see what happens when he flips, I guess.

[dingoatemybaby]

Well, fair enough; you gave a reason, you thought he was misrepresenting you, although he really wasn't. I don't think anyone else gave any kind of reason for voting him, though, as far as I can tell.

I think just about everyone explained that they believed Pepper to be misrepresenting, and gave references of some sort to support it.

For example

As for Dr. Pepper, his repeated misreps are convincing; post 782 and 787 are good examples. Page 32 in general sold me.

@Mike: Alot of it comes in posts after those that you PbPa'ed. Take Dr. Pepper's post 716 for instance, where he said:

dingo earned my FoS for his repeated critisms of Percy's vote plan. His opinion was made known. It was responded to by myself repeatedly and Yos in post 649. dingo keeps pushing for Percy to change the vote style only because someone might be scumiier. I have repeatedly asked dingo to provide a better target and he hasnt. dingo is trying to get a vote changed without providing a solid reason. I find these actions of his to be either misleading or paranoid.

He's taken the initial inference that dingo

wanted

to change Percy's vote, to a recollection that dingo

actually tried

to get a vote changed. This is a misrepresentation that attempts to boost Dr. Pepper's case but cannot be proven by what dingo said in 643 and other posts.

Percy had a long analysis of the issue. I think only zwet and Mufasa didn't say much. But do they ever?