Dichotomafia- Games Over

[Coron]

I think W_W is a cop for the village, and Nanook a roleblocker in the town.

A vote count would be good.

This combined with the fact that, as others have said std is acting differently in the two games might actually make std a better lynch.

unvote vote: STD

I'd say that our scum is somewhere in this group(all of it)
Save The Dragons
Mastermind of Sin (Replacing Flying Dutchman)
Mgm
Fuldu
willows_weep
Fishbulb
ralphmerridew

vote: MoS

He help lynch both tally and MMCL and is on this list, the other one that did that was StD. He is my second choice.

In addition to your reaction when I pointed out 3 prime suspects.

[Fuldu]

It's not that it's a creative claim, STD. It's that it's a

bad

creative claim. That's a lot of effort to go to to create a complicated role that just ends up being a one-shot doc. And while my "is there another role in the village" plan hasn't been as informative as I had hoped, it hasn't been completely uninformative, either.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I don't see anything else to do except switch my vote at this time, but I'm hesitant to do so until all the players are here.

[Save The Dragons]

Ok thank you. And thanks for picking up the discussion. If you're going to kill me, do it right.

And I'm not suicidal, Coron.

[Mgm]

It's not that it's a creative claim, STD. It's that it's a

bad

creative claim. That's a lot of effort to go to to create a complicated role that just ends up being a one-shot doc. And while my "is there another role in the village" plan hasn't been as informative as I had hoped, it hasn't been completely uninformative, either.

Yeah, that's why I'm leaning towards voting STD atm, but I'm not sure whether I'd be the one to end the day. Can we have a vote count first?

[Coron]

Fuldu, you need to unvote before you vote again.

[Fuldu]

Ah, right you are.

unvote: Coron; vote: Save The Dragons

[Coron]

Alright, Coron has 1 vote STD has 5 I believe.

[Mgm]

Unvote; Vote: STD

[Norinel]

Fuldu, you need to unvote before you vote again.

I consider unvotes preferred but not necessary. Mgm wasn't voting, though.

End of Day Vote Count

Save The Dragons- 6 (ralphmerridew, Coron, Fishbulb, PeaceBringer, Fuldu, Mgm)
Coron- 1 (Mastermind of Sin)

Not voting (3)- KingEnigma, Save The Dragons, willows_weep

6 to lynch.

I'd considered suspension in light of recent access difficulties, but everyone's had plenty of time to send choices.

Town Day 4/Village Night 4

After the townsfolk one by one decide on a victim, another endless-seeming day is punctuated by the lynching of Save The Dragons. Somehow, their posthumous investigation of his motives leads to the house of Nanook; he seems to be guilty of far greater crimes than the thievery he'd claimed.

Save The Dragons (Mafia) - lynched Day 4 by the Town

It is now Night 5 in the Town, send choices by the end of the Village's Day.

The village gathers to find, for once, two of their number missing. The first is Talitha, who is found in many pieces, including her membership card to The Incredibly Secret Village Mason Lodge.

Talitha (Mason) - mauled Night 4 in the Village

The second is SpeedyKQ, who is found shot in a decidedly non-werewolflike fashion. Unfortunately, he could save others but not himself.

SpedyKQ (Healer)- shot Night 4 in the Village

It is now Day 4 in the Village, 5 to lynch.

(Healer is Doctor.)

[Mgm]

Shot in a werewolf village?

I guess there's a vig around, but I'm at loss as to why they'd shoot the doc.

[NanookTheWolf]

I don't think that the vig knew that SpeedKQ was the doc .. maybe suspected him of being mafia?

[Mgm]

Of course, it could a SK too.

Funny how you're still alive with such a name. On the other hand, I expect that probably caused you to be investiagted early on. (Just like DP in Dragon Phoenix Mafia on the GL)

I'll

Vote: Flying Dutchman

He doesn't add anything substantial on day 1, except for a random vote and then, in post #427 he agrees with Tally that a random wagon is the best way to go. Why didn't he even try to discuss and find scum before he agreed to go random?

[NanookTheWolf]

Funny how you're still alive with such a name. On the other hand, I expect that probably caused you to be investiagted early on.

Is this relayed at me?

Also, I don't know if the Flying Dutchman vote is all that profitable, as he left the site a while ago. Posted in the GL that he is on hiatus I believe.

[NanookTheWolf]

Posted in the

GD

he is on hiatus I believe.

The part in bold is the correction to my last post .. GD standing for General Discussion of course.

[NanookTheWolf]

Alright, I found the thread .. It's the same one that I used to announce my departure from scum, didn't excpect to be back so soon though.

Flying Dutchman's Retirement

I know that this has been hard to come by in this game, but maybe a replacement is needed.

[Mgm]

Funny how you're still alive with such a name. On the other hand, I expect that probably caused you to be investiagted early on.

Is this relayed at me?

It is, a link between wolves and werewolves is easily made. But as I said, I doubt you'd survive being a wolf for very long, so I'm fairly certain you're not.

[Norinel]

Mastermind of Sin replaced Flying Dutchman a while back.

[Save The Dragons]

Ah man, I was in mid post when my internet failed, and then I completely forgot.

Let me recap some events you people seem to be forgetting.

Yesterday, in village, I claimed vig. Last night (village's POV) I said I'd kill Speedy in Town. Yep, I fricked that up. But no mystery SK or mystery vig.

Oh yeah, and ROCK ON TOWN MAFIA! 8)

[ralphmerridew]

those who are publicly uncertain:
Mastermind of Sin / FD
Mgm
the silent speaker
halfpint (Replacing silgado106)
NanookTheWolf

those who I consider cleared:
PeaceBringer - good by willows_weep
Save The Dragons - vig (almost certain)
ralphmerridew - Mason (not challenged by Talitha)

I'm not identifying anyone else in my mason lodge for now.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Mgm, I'll reread and try to answer your questions if possible, although I don't know Flying Dutchman well enough to know why he would've acted any particular way.

[Mgm]

Mastermind of Sin replaced Flying Dutchman a while back.

In that case,

unvote

. I can't hold MOS accountable for what FD did.
Norinel, could you please update the front post and remove FD from it?

[the silent speaker]

Halfpint just replaced in; it wouldn't be cricket to lynch her for her pains. Mgm tried to get STD to give out flavor text yesterday, which is unlikely to help catch someone in a lie (since my lack of flavor text does not mean that you also have none) but might be useful as public information for a maf who wants to make his claim look good. Since it's between him, MOS and Nanook today, from my standpoint,

vote: Mgm

and let's see what happens.

[Mgm]

Halfpint just replaced in; it wouldn't be cricket to lynch her for her pains. Mgm tried to get STD to give out flavor text yesterday, which is unlikely to help catch someone in a lie (since my lack of flavor text does not mean that you also have none) but might be useful as public information for a maf who wants to make his claim look good.

We lynched scum didn't we? I can't see how outing a fake claim can be a bad thing.

Since it's between him, MOS and Nanook today, from my standpoint,

vote: Mgm

and let's see what happens.

You'll have to explain that one. Why are you disregarding everyone else?

[Mgm]

those who are publicly uncertain:
Mastermind of Sin / FD
Mgm
the silent speaker
halfpint (Replacing silgado106)
NanookTheWolf

those who I consider cleared:
PeaceBringer - good by willows_weep
Save The Dragons - vig (almost certain)
ralphmerridew - Mason (not challenged by Talitha)

I'm not identifying anyone else in my mason lodge for now.

I think that we could win the game on this end with a few well-placed claims. I think we only need one more wolf who was associated with Coron and Fishbulb, and according to ralphmerridew we've got 5 suspects left (though I'm not sure how STD killing Speedy clears him/her of being an SK)

I know I'm innocent and I believe Nanook is too. And if those assumptions are correct that would leave us with 3 suspects (MOS, halfpint and TSS).

I'm pretty sure it would help the town if any other masons came out to shorten the suspect list and I'd also be happy to claim myself if required.