Dichotomafia- Games Over

[NanookTheWolf]

So are we waiting on Tss?

[the silent speaker]

TSS was quite instrumental in getting votes for Wacky, since he provided the reasoning, yet he never once voted for Wacky on that day, and spent most of the day voting for myself (FD) with less reasoning than he had for Wacky.

Then wouldn't you be better served by looking at the people who 'followed' me -- i.e. Mgm? Who was third on that wagon, and second was scum Lulu muumuu, I might add. At any rate, I didn't even mention Wacky's name until

you

complained that he was as guilty-looking as you were, by my resoning, so why was I voting you and not him? Afterward I conceded that

you were right

and Wacky was suspicious, but (post 647) that none of my suspicions so far had been heavy ones. Complaining that I furnished the reasoning for a Wackywagon when I only did so after you yourself prodded me for not having done strikes me as a little ungrateful.

If you want me to claim, I can, and my claim will be confirmable, but I'd rather not paint a target on my back unless people really want me to.

[the silent speaker]

TSS was quite instrumental in getting votes for Wacky, since he provided the reasoning, yet he never once voted for Wacky on that day, and spent most of the day voting for myself (FD) with less reasoning than he had for Wacky.

Then wouldn't you be better served by looking at the people who 'followed' me -- i.e. Mgm? Who was third on that wagon, and second was scum Lulu muumuu, I might add. At any rate, I didn't even mention Wacky's name until

you

complained that he was as guilty-looking as you were, by my resoning, so why was I voting you and not him? Afterward I conceded that

you were right

and Wacky was suspicious, but (post 647) that none of my suspicions so far had been heavy ones. Complaining that I furnished the reasoning for a Wackywagon when I only did so after you yourself prodded me for not having done strikes me as a little ungrateful.

If you want me to claim, I can, and my claim will be confirmable, but I'd rather not paint a target on my back unless people really want me to.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Thank you for responding to that. Like I said, it was just what I noticed when I read. I didn't see my(FD's) post, and I'm glad that you pointed out MGM as well. I haven't gotten to read more yet, but I'll take all of that into consideration when I do.

[Mgm]

Fact 1: We're down two werewolves.
Fact 2: We had a non-werewolf kill last night.
Fact 3: We've got 3 confirmed innocents.

I don't see how a mass claim is such a bad thing at this point. We have only one scum to go (unless the shooter is an SK instead of a vig I assume him to be), in which case (s)he can help to get rid of the werewolf.

I'll be the first to admit that it's hard to confirm me, but if I have to die to let the town win, so be it. Just claim before today's lynch, so night actions can be optimized to get the remaining scum.

[NanookTheWolf]

How does everyone else feel about the mass claim?

Remind me who the 3 CONFIRMED innocents are. I'm to lazy atm to look back.

[Mgm]

those who are publicly uncertain:
Mastermind of Sin / FD
Mgm
the silent speaker
halfpint (Replacing silgado106)
NanookTheWolf

those who I consider cleared:
PeaceBringer - good by willows_weep
Save The Dragons - vig (almost certain)
ralphmerridew - Mason (not challenged by Talitha)

I'm not identifying anyone else in my mason lodge for now.

[Mastermind of Sin]

thanks Mgm, I had forgotten as well...

[Save The Dragons]

Personally I'd think it'd be more helpful for the town.

[Mastermind of Sin]

what would?

[Save The Dragons]

Mass claim.

[Mastermind of Sin]

ah, thanks for clarification

[Mgm]

The lack of participation is very disappointing. Say something, anything!
Let's talk about who should claim first if we finally got around to mass claiming.

[NanookTheWolf]

How about a confirmed gg pick the next person that they want to claim.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I can agree to that. Is there one person that is more confirmed than the others that can be selected for this? For example, an investigation can be fooled, masons can be scum, etc. Is there anyone who is cleared beyond this?

[Mgm]

I doubt the investigation can be fooled. The Werewolf GF is already dead.
So, the investigated player is most confirmed.

[Norinel]

Still replacing willows, prodding PeaceBringer, glaring vaguely at halfpint and ralphmerridew.

Not as quick, just as lazy

Vote Count

Mgm- 2 (the silent speaker, Save The Dragons)
the silent speaker- 1 (Mgm)

Not voting- everyone else

5 to lynch

[PeaceBringer]

I have been reading, mass claim should be helpful. We need something to talk about.

[Mastermind of Sin]

well, we won't get anywhere without our confirmed people posting...

[Mgm]

PB, since you're the most confirmed. In what order do you want the non-confirmed to claim?

[PeaceBringer]

Hmm so you want me to pick the order?

I actually like seeing who claims when and what is volunteered myself.

I usualy find that to be helpful. If I were to pick someone it would be one of halfpint or Nanook who have been both quiet.

[ralphmerridew]

I want to see Mgm claim first; he's been acting most suspicious to me.

[halfpint]

glaring vaguely at halfpint

I'm here. Sorry, busy week, and only keeping up with a few games.

PB -- So, is that a request for me to claim?

[Mgm]

I want to see Mgm claim first; he's been acting most suspicious to me.

Can you back this up with actual evidence? Like this it's a bit of an empty point.

[ralphmerridew]

I'll explain my reasons after you claim. But for now, since we know that masons are in the game (through Talitha's death), and she didn't challenge my claim yesterday, I believe I am the most cleared person in the village.