The Werewolves of Millers Hollow (Game Over)

[Yosarian2]

Therefore, the

only

way dramonic's plan will do what it is supposed to do is if the lover's non-voting clause is enforced in some way that is publically noticable but not a modkill.

Well, or it works if everyone else goes along with the plan and the lovers simply refuse (or are unable) to do go along with the plan (or else they fake it and just don't vote each other and hope no one notices).

Honestly, if we knew the lovers were guarenteed to be anti-town, I wouldn't mind doing that as a test. As it is, though, if there are lovers, they're probably pro-town, plus (if draconic is right) there is already a pro-town "cupid" who knows who they are.

[MafiaSSK]

Prodding Gorrad,Izzy,Starbuck, and MikeSC6.

[Starbuck]

I haven't posted because there is jack shit going on. We're at the same place we were.

[Gorrad]

I haven't posted because there is jack shit going on. We're at the same place we were.

Bingo.

[Yosarian2]

I haven't posted because there is jack shit going on. We're at the same place we were.

Jack shit is going on because you (plural) are not posting.

[Jahudo]

@Starbuck: What, there's no way to find scum in days 1-3? Because stuff happened back then and you still haven't commented on it. (and some other replacements too)

[Yosarian2]

I'd totally be in favor of lynching a luker here. I think the odds are very high tht we've got some lurkerscum in this game.

[dramonic]

considering we have like, 70% of the group being lurkers, no shit sherlock XD

[dramonic]

on-topic: Who do you propose?

Vote: Zwet

in case it wasn't already clear.

[Starbuck]

@Starbuck: What, there's no way to find scum in days 1-3? Because stuff happened back then and you still haven't commented on it. (and some other replacements too)

I have read through it, if there's something you need me to comment on, please bring it up.

[Gorrad]

on-topic: Who do you propose?

Vote: Zwet

in case it wasn't already clear.

Hey Dramonic, could you conceivably choose an easier lynch target?

[dramonic]

Care to explain what you mean by that Gorrad?

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Why haven't we lynched Dramonic yet? He's far too desperate to avoid being lynched to let him off the hook.

[Starbuck]

Why haven't we lynched Dramonic yet? He's far too desperate to avoid being lynched to let him off the hook.

That's been my question.

[Gorrad]

Care to explain what you mean by that Gorrad?

Simple. Zwet is, by definition, an easy lynch. He could be playing like a pro and have nailed three scum in a row and STILL be lynched for virtue of being himself.

[dramonic]

Last time I checked, you were also all for lynching him and if you look I've been voting him since july 2nd, it's not like it's anything new.

His playstyle is a nuisance at best.

[Jahudo]

A lynch with 13 alive takes 7 players and only 8 players are currently active, which explains why a lynch is not likely to happen until we get our replacements.

Also, if we lynch before people are found, we could go into dissatisfaction with a potentially underpowered townie presence.

Actives:

MikeSC6
DizzyIzzyB13
Yosarian2
Jahudo
Gorrad
NabakovNabakov
Starbuck
Dramonic

V/LA

zwetschenwasser

In need of replacement:

Ztife
Battle Mage
The Replacement
Rockatansky

[Gorrad]

Last time I checked, you were also all for lynching him and if you look I've been voting him since july 2nd, it's not like it's anything new.

His playstyle is a nuisance at best.

I'm all for lynching YOU. He's acceptable.

[dramonic]

Zwet is a constant scummy vibe. No matter what. My policy towards him is simple:
If he dies and is scum: Yay! Dead scum.
If he dies and is town: Yay! Dead zwet.

Zwet, so you know, I hold you as a person with the utmost respect. It's you as a player I want to kill.

[Gorrad]

Mhmm. Which is why I said he's an easy lynch, and an acceptable one. He's not my first choice by a long shot.

[dramonic]

mkay, and that's me because...?

All I did was try to hunt out the lover because I'm sure they'll cause the town problem later on <<

[The Replacement]

Surprised I am still in this game with such a long absence from the site. I'll stick around to keep from having to look for more replacements. Will catch up in the meantime before too long.

[The Replacement]

You can like your case on Mike, but maybe others don't and they aren't required to. You seem to think that it should be your way or no way.

Players don't have to agree with my case on Mike, even if I think they should, but I don't think they should ignore more current events which is what it looks like is happening to me (or you who have pretty much not commented on practically the entire game thus far). If you have an old case that you like you should be able to explain why it is still relevant and preferable to more recent happenings, keeping the town up to date with your current thoughts and why you agree/disagree with what others are saying.

FoS: Starbuck

[The Replacement]

I also don't think we should be trying to out lovers.

[Starbuck]

I said earlier, if you have something that you need me to comment on, please bring it up. Link me to the post, quote it. I'm not going to go on a wild goose chase for you.