Zazie, I've read your explanation for your posting style and I think it's just, well, wrong. It is
a lot harder
for me to follow the thread if every single different thought you have has its own post. That's why people don't do that usually.
Anyway I'm not going to argue with you about it, but I do wish you would just post normally. I like most of what you're saying, it just gives me a bit of a headache to read it all split up like this.
Exalt, I think I don't really understand what you're saying. You've said you're not suggesting a policy lynch on Sho for his posting style, but that you
would
vote for him if he kept posting like that. I guess I don't understand the fundamental difference between pushing a policy lynch now, and suggesting you'll push one later. Both are suggesting that someone should be lynched for
the way that they post
rather than
because they are likely to be scum
. I think we should lynch people we think are likely to be scum, and I don't see how someone choosing to post in a certain way (in this and another game) makes it more likely that they are scum.
Do you think Sho posting this way makes him more likely to be scum, or are you saying this style of posting could be so anti-town it should be dealt with by a lynch even if it doesn't make him likely scum, or that it's impossible to determine the scumminess of someone posting that way? Or something else?
In answer to your question, I'm going to be ignoring his way of phrasing things and examining what he actually says and seeing if it is scummy. I don't see why his using "zetta" instead of "very" means that we can't attempt to deduce his alignment in the same way as we would with any other player.
Kise, I'm afraid I still don't understand your 'trap'. You did something scummy. I pointed it out. Now what? You're using a lot of pejorative phrases such as 'nitpicking' and 'taking the moral high ground' to describe my behavior, when all I've done is point out a scummy thing you did and vote you for it. Do you have a problem with me pointing out scummy behavior? Why?
itacv2, you've justified your vote on DDD, but I'd like to hear any comments you have on other players. Townies do tunnel, but scum can pretend to tunnel to avoid interacting with too many players.
Raivann, there's really no need to be sarcastic. I didn't complain that you agreed with me, I complained that you said you were agreeing with me when you were not.
Why does Exalt's removal of his vote come off as 'trying too hard to appear townie'? Do you have any other comments at all on the game?
