Dichotomafia- Games Over

[Mastermind of Sin]

except you could be an evil mason...that's why I asked my question earlier.

[Mgm]

Is anyone planning to say something? We just went more than 24 hours without a single post!

PB -- So, is that a request for me to claim?

If I were to pick someone it would be one of halfpint or Nanook who have been both quiet.

Looks like a request to me.

[the silent speaker]

How come you're not claiming, Mgm? You're the one who's been pushing for a mass claim, you're the one with the most votes, yet you haven't tried to claim yourself...

[Mgm]

Because the confirmed innocent Peacebringer wants someone else to claim first. A mass claim is only useful if you let the scum claim first so they have to make up a lie quickly. If you like, I'll claim right after halfpint does.

I already said you could lynch me after a mass claim if you don't believe me, which I'm sure you won't. What else could you want?

[PeaceBringer]

halfpint, if you would be so kind. If we are going to mass claim, might as well start with those not yet under pressure and put them under pressure. At least this is my thinking.

[Mgm]

How come you're not claiming, Mgm? You're the one who's been pushing for a mass claim, you're the one with the most votes, yet you haven't tried to claim yourself...

Yeah, I know you and STD are voting me and ralphmerridew has voiced suspicions, but I've yet to see any solid reasoning to suggest I'm even remotely scummy.

Halfpint just replaced in; it wouldn't be cricket to lynch her for her pains. Mgm tried to get STD to give out flavor text yesterday, which is unlikely to help catch someone in a lie (since my lack of flavor text does not mean that you also have none) but might be useful as public information for a maf who wants to make his claim look good. Since it's between him, MOS and Nanook today, from my standpoint, vote: Mgm and let's see what happens.

Besides, you're voting me based on something I did in the town... Do you have anything village-related you want to use as evidence?

[the silent speaker]

Besides, you're voting me based on something I did in the town.

Say what?

[Mgm]

Me asking flavour text of STD was yester-game-day in the town before his lynch to determine if he was scum. Can't remember doing so in the village, but then again than was somewhat longer ago.

[Save The Dragons]

You did. I remember.

[halfpint]

halfpint, if you would be so kind. If we are going to mass claim, might as well start with those not yet under pressure and put them under pressure. At least this is my thinking.

That's fine PB. I am possessing someone (something?) named Wolfsbane, which basically means that I can't be killed by werewolves (well, that is until the village is outnumbered by werewolves). That's it. I am pro-village.

I personally would like to hear more from Mgm. He is the one that acting most suspciously (to me), although I don't have time right now to put all of my thoughts together. I would like to hear him claim.

[Mgm]

This is really frustrating. I still can't see how asking for flavour text is scummy when I'm trying to make scum trip up. But now that the majority of the town wants a claim, I guess it's the best thing to do, besides I promised.

I'm a simple villager. Nothing more, nothing less. Since there's nothing confirmable about it, I understand it if you want to lynch me. Please, look at other villager claimers with the same suspicion as you did to me. I'm sure there's innocents in there, but I also think scum will try to claim villager.

Now could you guys please put your suspicions of me into words?

I'd like to hear from TSS next, unless PeaceBringer disagrees.

[Save The Dragons]

Unvote

I actually don't remember why I thought you were scummy, and I personally would like to hear the rest of the claims.

For the record, I never thought asking for flavor was scummy, I just remembered that you did.

[Mgm]

For the record, I never thought asking for flavor was scummy, I just remembered that you did.

That was directed at TSS, not you.

[the silent speaker]

Your post 877 was

village

day 3, Mgm. Reproduced in full:

STD: What is the flavoured role name of a vig in this game?

My claim: mason with ralph.

[the silent speaker]

Double post to say: Passover is coming up, so my access for a bit over a week will be sporadic (hopefully not nonexisistent, though).

[NanookTheWolf]

Alright, I'll claim since I doesn't seem that there are very many options left here ..

I am the seer. Pretty much the same idea as being a cop, I get either a werewolf or not a werewolf result. Problem is though that when I received my role, it stated that my sanity is unknown.

Night 1 - Talitha is not a werewolf
Night 2 - Wasn't playing at the time
Night 3 - Wasn't playing at the time
Night 4 - SavetheDragons is not a werewolf

That's basically the jist of it.

[ralphmerridew]

And I will confirm that TSS is the last mason.

[Mgm]

I'll explain my reasons after you claim. But for now, since we know that masons are in the game (through Talitha's death), and she didn't challenge my claim yesterday, I believe I am the most cleared person in the village.

So, I've claimed now. What are your reasons for suspecting me?
Who hasn't claimed yet?

[Norinel]

The mod bumping the game is bad.

Vote Count

Mgm- 1 (the silent speaker)
the silent speaker- 1 (Mgm)

Not voting- everyone else

5 to lynch

[Mgm]

Unvote:TSS

There's no use in voting a confirmed mason.

Who hasn't claimed yet?

[Mgm]

Vote: Mastermind of Sin

for being the only person who hasn't claimed yet.

The lack of discussion is horrible. Maybe a list of claims will help to get discussion going again.

List of claims:

Mgm - claimed simple villager
PeaceBringer - confirmed innocent by Willows_weep (with Wolf GF now dead - confirming innocence).
SaveTheDragons - claimed vigilante. (confirmed by Nanook)
ralphmerridew, TSS and Talitha (deceased) - masons confirmed by each other.
halfpint - claimed night kill immunity because of wolfsbane.

Apart from not knowning MOS's role, I find halfpint suspicious.

I did think about Nanook too. We already had a cop-type die earlier and Nanook's claim didn't provide anything we didn't already know. His claim also misses results for 2 nights
(To check: Did he post in V/LA for nights 2 and 3? Was he replaced?)
But since we have two docs, having 2 cops makes sense.

As for halfpint, with all the power roles, I just can't see immunity happen. It would make things too imbalanced. Two cops (willows_weep and Nanook) and two docs (SpeedyKQ and Wacky) gives a town plenty of power. A villager with night kill immunity just doesn't fit.

MAJOR FOS:halfpint

[Norinel]

The mod bumping the game, with only one player posting in almost a week, is very bad.

Deadline: 7 days from this post

. Hoping this will pull people out of the woodwork, not enough time to send out prods in the next day or two.

[the silent speaker]

We're idiots, people.

We have lynches to give.

With one wolf left, we can spare three lynches. With two wolves left, going by the claims they have to be among Mgm, MOS and halfpint, so only one lynch will need to be spared in any case. I'm willing to go for MOS today, Mgm tomorrow and halfpint the day after, if necessary.

Unvote: Mgm, vote: MOS

.

Nanook:

if MOS turns up scum and the game's not over, investigate Mgm tonight, and tomorrow we'll know for sure who to lynch. I think this lynch order guarantees us the win.

[Norinel]

Prodding everyone alive in the Village except tss and Mgm.

[ralphmerridew]

In defense of Nanook, the town also had two cops. (Did willows_weep give her other investigation (but we can get that from her in the town)? It's also possible that she was naive / insane, in which would put PB at a less confirmed status.)

I'll augment TSS's suggestion: today we lynch MoS; tonight Nanook checks MGM and STD kills halfpint.