The Werewolves of Millers Hollow (Game Over)

[MafiaSSK]

Battle Mage just posted up further.

Mhm.Unless you specifically cancel a request for a replacement then you're still up for it.

[MikeSC6]

I'm actually still here! The day had ended when I got back.

I agree with having millar13 as executioner if we can- it's the only way we can be sure we'd get full and accurate information.

Vote for Executioner: millar13

[Starbuck]

So we are going to go with this plan? Voting someone who may not even get replaced as executioner?

[Battle Mage]

I thought BM left this game? Welcome back, I guess?

Vote for executioner: Gorrad

he seems town to me

I'm up for lynching all the flakers. Or MikeSC. Whichever.

Well, i got prodded by some night action overnight, and told that im still in the game until a replacement gets sorted. So i guess i'm still around. I'll once again say that, if made executioner, i will retract my replacement request. I wont reread, but i'll be around to tell you the results (which is effectively what the executioner is for). I've said i'm happy to be modkilled in the meantime, so you can regard me as confirmed town, and i'm not leaving the site any time soon.

Your call.

BM

[Yosarian2]

The only problem with your plan to vote for Millar13 is that I doubt anyone would want to replace in as a tree-stumped player, and replacement of him isn't necessary for the game to advance.

They don't have to read the game; they don't have to post any content. All they have to do is report on allignments. If we don't get any replacements the regular way, I'm all for advertising the role like that.

Basically, I'm just trying to make use of this resource (a confirmed townie, treestumped or no) that we've been neglecting the whole game.

If we are going to get a replacement for millar before the end of the day, and if he can be made executioner, I'd be in favor of that. I think there's a significant risk we won't get that replacement, though. And if he gets modkilled for lack of replacemetns, or just never ends up getting replaced, then he wouldn't even be able to choose a sucessor...

[MikeSC6]

Well, i got prodded by some night action overnight, and told that im still in the game until a replacement gets sorted. So i guess i'm still around. I'll once again say that, if made executioner, i will retract my replacement request. I wont reread, but i'll be around to tell you the results (which is effectively what the executioner is for). I've said i'm happy to be modkilled in the meantime, so you can regard me as confirmed town, and i'm not leaving the site any time soon.

How exactly does that mean we can regard you as confirmed town?

[Gorrad]

Vote for Executioner: Battle Mage

Has seemed town to me for a good while, and if he's an executioner and dies, he'll be out of the game all the sooner, which is a good deal for him.

[Yosarian2]

I'll once again say that, if made executioner, i will retract my replacement request. I wont reread, but i'll be around to tell you the results (which is effectively what the executioner is for).

I do have to say this rubs me the wrong way; it seems like he's saying he'll keep playing if we bribe him, so long as he's not expected to actually read or scumhunt or anything.

I don't want battle mage to replace out, and frankly we're going to have trouble finding enough replacements to keep this game going no matter what, but...eh.

[Battle Mage]

Well, i got prodded by some night action overnight, and told that im still in the game until a replacement gets sorted. So i guess i'm still around. I'll once again say that, if made executioner, i will retract my replacement request. I wont reread, but i'll be around to tell you the results (which is effectively what the executioner is for). I've said i'm happy to be modkilled in the meantime, so you can regard me as confirmed town, and i'm not leaving the site any time soon.

How exactly does that mean we can regard you as confirmed town?

I wouldnt allow myself to be modkilled as scum. Not when i could just lurk to victory. As town, i'm useless if im not participating, so i might aswell be dead.

And, seeing as there is some doubt over my usefulness, i'll sweeten the deal, just for you Yos.
If elected Executioner, i will reread yesterday.

BM

[Starbuck]

You shouldn't have to promise that you will re-read if you are elected Executioner. You should do that on your own since you are playing this game.

[Battle Mage]

You shouldn't have to promise that you will re-read if you are elected Executioner. You should do that on your own since you are playing this game.

I'm not.

Also,

Vote: Starbuck

You dont even look familiar to me.

BM

[Starbuck]

That's because I replaced in during your god-awful afk.

[Jahudo]

Actually since millar's last post was a month ago maybe he doesn't need a replacement. Just have the mod give him a prod when we need him.

Vote for Executioner: millar

[MikeSC6]

@Battle Mage: It seems to me like you'd want to cause some shenanigans with the role, whether town or not. If you're willing to be replaced out, yet still remain active on the site, there must be something in it for you in the Executioner role for it to make you stay active.

If you plan on telling the whole truth and nothing but the truth, I don't see what you'd get out of it.

I don't want to see you replaced, but if we elect you Executioner that means we won't know your role until the end of the game, as you'd be told your role on the lynch and nobody else.

[Battle Mage]

@Battle Mage: It seems to me like you'd want to cause some shenanigans with the role, whether town or not. If you're willing to be replaced out, yet still remain active on the site, there must be something in it for you in the Executioner role for it to make you stay active.

If you plan on telling the whole truth and nothing but the truth, I don't see what you'd get out of it.

I don't want to see you replaced, but if we elect you Executioner that means we won't know your role until the end of the game, as you'd be told your role on the lynch and nobody else.

I wouldnt cause shenanigans, id report accurately ofc. I wouldnt know enough about the game to do anything else. lol!

But srsly, there isnt really anything in it for me, except the power and responsibility. I've played a couple of these type of games, and never been elected anything decent. So, i guess its a case of me being inspired to actually help.

I realise my attitude is pretty shocking here, but i srsly have no time for a full reread, with so many other games atm.

I have nothing to gain with this role as scum- presumably anybody not in my scumgroup will be town. Knowing their role is of very little value. And i dont know enough of the game to use knowledge of roles to manipulate lynches.

More importantly, having this role in the hands of town can give us some idea of just HOW MUCH trouble we are in. lol

I'm vanilla btw.

BM

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Actually since millar's last post was a month ago maybe he doesn't need a replacement. Just have the mod give him a prod when we need him.

Vote for Executioner: millar

This makes no sense. We need the Executioner to be someone who is involved and up to date with the game in order that scum do not take advantage of any delay in getting information. I think Yos is the best option other than myself.

[Starbuck]

I definitely am against the millar and BM propositions.

[Gorrad]

I definitely am against the millar and BM propositions.

Why?

[Starbuck]

I definitely am against the millar and BM propositions.

Why?

BM seems very overexcited at the prospect of being Executioner after not being replaced for a very long time and if he becomes Executioner, he *promises* that he will catch up with the game. He shouldn't have to promise that, by signing up for the game, he should know what's going on and shouldn't use something like that in his campaign.

On Millar, what if he doesn't get replaced? I think it's rather flimsy to vote someone as Executioner when we don't know whether or not a replacement will be coming in.

[Jahudo]

Actually since millar's last post was a month ago maybe he doesn't need a replacement. Just have the mod give him a prod when we need him.

Vote for Executioner: millar

This makes no sense. We need the Executioner to be someone who is involved and up to date with the game in order that scum do not take advantage of any delay in getting information. I think Yos is the best option other than myself.

Anybody as executioner couldn't give us the information until the next day and we would all want to wait for the flip before lynching again.

The only advantage to giving it to a playing player is that they can use the flip information in a power role if they have one.

But giving scum this power is basically giving them the game.

[Starbuck]

That's why I'm concerned about BM. He seems very overexcited to be Executioner, and I'm getting a very scummy vibe from him.

[MikeSC6]

Shall we wait and see if millar gets replaced, or comes back posting? If he gets replaced, then it should certainly be millar. If he comes back- can we trust that he'd stay committed?

[NabakovNabakov]

The way I see it, it would be foolish to end this day without waiting for replacements anyway. If we start tomorrow without having replaced Millar n' the Flakers, we'll have bigger problems to deal with.

[Starbuck]

We need to stop waiting and pick an Executioner.

How about everyone make a list of the top 3 people they would want as Executioner (excluding yourself)?

I'll start:

Nabakov
Gorrad
Yosarian (if we absolutely have to, I really don't think he should be Executioner if he's already Mayor)

[Battle Mage]

That's why I'm concerned about BM. He seems very overexcited to be Executioner, and I'm getting a very scummy vibe from him.

then lynch me. *shrug*

But dont expect an easy job, given my status as confirmed-town and all. Anyway i'm really too busy to post here again. So, was nice playing with you all.

Mod: Please prod me if i become Executioner

BM