The Werewolves of Millers Hollow (Game Over)

[zwetschenwasser]

I shall.

[MikeSC6]

Just in case my millar vote didn't pass over-

Unvote: millar

Vote: Zwet

[zwetschenwasser]

Uh... I'm confirmed town. Why are you voting me?

[MikeSC6]

Oops, I meant for Executioner-

Unvote

Vote for Executioner: Zwet

[zwetschenwasser]

This game is stalling.

[MafiaSSK]

Yup and only Gorrad and Jahudo needed prodding. However, the deadline rules still apply,meaning September 4th+x is the deadline.

[NabakovNabakov]

Well, we could try to actually hunt scum/piper.

As I said a few pages back, unless we're being mercilessly WIFOMd, the Piper is somebody who was inactive last night (Millar (now zwet); ztife; Rockatansky; BM)

Zwet is confirmed town, and Rockatansky is already a dancer, so that makes the two probable pipers Ztife and BM, both of whom have bizzarely volunteered themselves for a position it's obvious they didn't deserve. (go figure)

I will

Vote: Battle Mage

. His saying he got "prodded by some night action overnight" in iso 100 makes me think he might be our man.

[Starbuck]

I really don't know the actual game that well. What does the Piper do and why would BM be the best choice if he's the Piper?

[NabakovNabakov]

The Piper can pick 1 (?) player per night to play his pipe for and send into a trance-dance. If he can get all living players dancing, he wins.

I suspect the Piper was inactive last nigt because each player who is dancing (I am one of them) gets a list of who else is dancing at the end of each night, and no new people were added to the list last night.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

NabakovNabakov makes a good point. The same four people were dancing on both nights 3 and 4. So, unless NabakovNabakov is the Piper (since he was the other person dancing on night one), it's someone who submitted no action last night, or was blocked, which I don't believe is a possibility (though I could be wrong). Battle Mage seems scummy enough thqat he's as good a pick as any.

vote: Battle Mage

[zwetschenwasser]

Is the piper the only remaining anti-town person in the game?

[Jahudo]

Vote for executioner: zwets

[DizzyIzzyB13]

We've only caught one werewolf, so I doubt it. But, the Piper is anti-town, and killing something anti-town is always a good thing. Besides, the longer it goes on, the closer the Piper gets to winning..

[Gorrad]

Sorry, haven't really been focusing on this game. I don't remember Zwet being confirmed, but I'll take y'all's word for it.

VfE: Zwet

[MikeSC6]

Good call on Battle Mage, he's claimed vanilla townie and tried to get the high profile Executioner role, which I don't think a pro-town power role would risk.

And there are definately more anti-town roles, as someone died during the night. I can't imagine we'd have two Witches/vigilantes. It's possible that the Piper targeted The Replacement- and he didn't get added to the list because he was dead, but hasn't the Piper been adding two to the list each night? Although it could be that having a new dancer killed in the night disrupts the whole process.

Anyway, I agree with Battle Mage, I really don't think he's town (let alone "confirmed town").

Vote: Battle Mage

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Sorry, haven't really been focusing on this game. I don't remember Zwet being confirmed, but I'll take y'all's word for it.

VfE: Zwet

Zwet replaced back in, taking Millar's place as the tree-stumped village idiot, so he's confirmed as a townie.

[zwetschenwasser]

I want to vote battle mage...

[Battle Mage]

Well, we could try to actually hunt scum/piper.

As I said a few pages back, unless we're being mercilessly WIFOMd, the Piper is somebody who was inactive last night (Millar (now zwet); ztife; Rockatansky; BM)

Zwet is confirmed town, and Rockatansky is already a dancer, so that makes the two probable pipers Ztife and BM, both of whom have bizzarely volunteered themselves for a position it's obvious they didn't deserve. (go figure)

I will

Vote: Battle Mage

. His saying he got "prodded by some night action overnight" in iso 100 makes me think he might be our man.

I was dancing last night. For the first time. You were there too.

BM

[Battle Mage]

NabakovNabakov makes a good point. The same four people were dancing on both nights 3 and 4. So, unless NabakovNabakov is the Piper (since he was the other person dancing on night one), it's someone who submitted no action last night, or was blocked, which I don't believe is a possibility (though I could be wrong). Battle Mage seems scummy enough thqat he's as good a pick as any.

vote: Battle Mage

How can i be the Piper if i only started dancing last night? :S

BM

[Battle Mage]

Well, we could try to actually hunt scum/piper.

As I said a few pages back, unless we're being mercilessly WIFOMd, the Piper is somebody who was inactive last night (Millar (now zwet); ztife; Rockatansky; BM)

Zwet is confirmed town, and Rockatansky is already a dancer, so that makes the two probable pipers Ztife and BM, both of whom have bizzarely volunteered themselves for a position it's obvious they didn't deserve. (go figure)

I will

Vote: Battle Mage

. His saying he got "prodded by some night action overnight" in iso 100 makes me think he might be our man.

Haha, 2 things.

1. Who are you to judge who "deserves" a position? The executioner doesnt need to be someone who has played well, it needs to be someone who is protown. I fit the role perfectly.
2. Do you really think that I, as scum, would claim to have been prodded by a night-action, if that night actions implicated me as scum?

This is almost as funny as it is unnerving.

BM

[Battle Mage]

Btw, i'm going to full claim, in case the dancers are scum:

NabNab
DizzyIzzy
Rockatansky
Ztife

I think thats them. Will check my PM.

BM

[Starbuck]

As someone who hasn't been around much, you seem to be very defensive.

[NabakovNabakov]

Well, we could try to actually hunt scum/piper.

As I said a few pages back, unless we're being mercilessly WIFOMd, the Piper is somebody who was inactive last night (Millar (now zwet); ztife; Rockatansky; BM)

Zwet is confirmed town, and Rockatansky is already a dancer, so that makes the two probable pipers Ztife and BM, both of whom have bizzarely volunteered themselves for a position it's obvious they didn't deserve. (go figure)

I will

Vote: Battle Mage

. His saying he got "prodded by some night action overnight" in iso 100 makes me think he might be our man.

Haha, 2 things.

1. Who are you to judge who "deserves" a position? The executioner doesnt need to be someone who has played well, it needs to be someone who is protown. I fit the role perfectly.
2. Do you really think that I, as scum, would claim to have been prodded by a night-action, if that night actions implicated me as scum?

This is almost as funny as it is unnerving.

BM

1) Why guess on the townieness of a player when we have a confirmed townie at our disposal? You didn't deserve the position because you were very clearly pre-empted by Millar/Zwet.
2) WIFOM. Also, with the amount of attention you've been paying to this game, I wouldn't be surprised.

My PM does NOT say you were dancing last night (what about you, Izzy?). Potentially a mod error, so I'll see if I can get confirmation.

[Battle Mage]

As someone who hasn't been around much, you seem to be very defensive.

alright Mr. Snidey. You go back in your box now, good good.

BM

[Battle Mage]

Well, we could try to actually hunt scum/piper.

As I said a few pages back, unless we're being mercilessly WIFOMd, the Piper is somebody who was inactive last night (Millar (now zwet); ztife; Rockatansky; BM)

Zwet is confirmed town, and Rockatansky is already a dancer, so that makes the two probable pipers Ztife and BM, both of whom have bizzarely volunteered themselves for a position it's obvious they didn't deserve. (go figure)

I will

Vote: Battle Mage

. His saying he got "prodded by some night action overnight" in iso 100 makes me think he might be our man.

Haha, 2 things.

1. Who are you to judge who "deserves" a position? The executioner doesnt need to be someone who has played well, it needs to be someone who is protown. I fit the role perfectly.
2. Do you really think that I, as scum, would claim to have been prodded by a night-action, if that night actions implicated me as scum?

This is almost as funny as it is unnerving.

BM

1) Why guess on the townieness of a player when we have a confirmed townie at our disposal? You didn't deserve the position because you were very clearly pre-empted by Millar/Zwet.
2) WIFOM. Also, with the amount of attention you've been paying to this game, I wouldn't be surprised.

My PM does NOT say you were dancing last night (what about you, Izzy?). Potentially a mod error, so I'll see if I can get confirmation.

Haha, why do i find it hilariously strange that im being called scum for dancing, by...the other people who were dancing?

BM