The Werewolves of Millers Hollow (Game Over)

[Battle Mage]

So now I'm guessing BM is going to re-ask for a replacement.

i never un-asked.

BM

[Yosarian2]

This still seems odd to me though.

Night One: BarryLocke, DizzyIzzyB13

If the piper can only recruit one a night (and it looks that way, by the rest of Izzy's list), then why were there two dancers night 1?

[Jahudo]

Okay, then just vote for scummiest.

unvote;
Vote: MikeSC

[Starbuck]

Okay then.

Vote: Battle Mage

[Battle Mage]

Okay, then just vote for scummiest.

unvote;
Vote: MikeSC

can we run up one of the 2 original dancers plz?

Starbuck is being silly.

BM

[zwetschenwasser]

BM is gleeful that he's manipulating the town into thinking that he can't be scum just because he can't be the piper.

[NabakovNabakov]

This still seems odd to me though.

Night One: BarryLocke, DizzyIzzyB13

If the piper can only recruit one a night (and it looks that way, by the rest of Izzy's list), then why were there two dancers night 1?

No, it looks like two a night to me. The only abberation is on N2, but that just means the Piper probably tried to recruit someone who was killed or protected that night.

Recruits for each night:
N1: Izzy, Nab
N2: Juls, Fonz/Percy/somebody somehow protected that night
N3: Rock, Replacement
N4: BM, Ztife

[Starbuck]

Starbuck is being silly.

You keep thinking that bud.

[Battle Mage]

BM is gleeful that he's manipulating the town into thinking that he can't be scum just because he can't be the piper.

when i die, you could tell them i'm scum, just to improve the town's confidence, and to confuse the living hell out of the baddies. Just a thought.

BM

[Yosarian2]

BM is gleeful that he's manipulating the town into thinking that he can't be scum just because he can't be the piper.

when i die, you could tell them i'm scum, just to improve the town's confidence, and to confuse the living hell out of the baddies. Just a thought.

BM

BM, did someone just bet you that you couldn't make the scummiest post ever in a mafia game in 3 lines or less?

[Battle Mage]

BM is gleeful that he's manipulating the town into thinking that he can't be scum just because he can't be the piper.

when i die, you could tell them i'm scum, just to improve the town's confidence, and to confuse the living hell out of the baddies. Just a thought.

BM

BM, did someone just bet you that you couldn't make the scummiest post ever in a mafia game in 3 lines or less?

lol no. Do you think im scum then?

BM

[MikeSC6]

I don't think it would be helpful to town to lie about the result of a lynch at all (that goes without saying). I don't see how Battle Mage's posts would fit into a town play at all- especially this "I'm confirmed town because I've asked for a replacement" while still posting.

But we can be sure he's not the Piper. With six left not dancing, it's possible that tomorrow could be our last chance to lynch the Piper (taking deaths into account). Although by adding dancers the Piper's narrowing it down for us.

[Battle Mage]

I don't think it would be helpful to town to lie about the result of a lynch at all (that goes without saying). I don't see how Battle Mage's posts would fit into a town play at all- especially this "I'm confirmed town because I've asked for a replacement" while still posting.

But we can be sure he's not the Piper. With six left not dancing, it's possible that tomorrow could be our last chance to lynch the Piper (taking deaths into account). Although by adding dancers the Piper's narrowing it down for us.

ok, i'll bite. whats a Piper?

Btw, im not confirmed because i asked for replacement. im confirmed because i offered to be modkilled. i wouldnt do that as scum.

BM

[NabakovNabakov]

ok, i'll bite. whats a Piper?

This is inexcusable. Have you read

any

of the thread?

Btw, im not confirmed because i asked for replacement. im confirmed because i offered to be modkilled. i wouldnt do that as scum.

Do you realize what kind of precedent it would set if this kind of WIFOM logic were accepted and anybody offering to be modkilled was instantly confirmed as town? As I see it, asking to be modkilled is just an amplification of self-voting. Also, given the general level of disarray in this game and the fact that (at the time) there were three completely inactive players, your request to be modkilled was unlikely to be honored simply because you were around to post it. It was a meaningless gesture that you obviously haven't followed through on.

[MikeSC6]

Offering to be modkilled wouldn't help anyone from any side. I can't imagine there ever being a role in any game where the win condition was to be modkilled. It's definately not particularly pro-town.

And the Piper is the thing that we think is making people dance, because this game is based on a card game that has a Piper that does that.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

I doubt we could do much worse than a BM lynch. Even if he can't be the Piper, he's acting in a very, very scummy manner.

[Yosarian2]

Eh. He could be a dancing warewolf. (which is kind of a funny image. ) I don't really think it's all that likely (although the whole "i'm confirmed because I said mod should modkill lurkers" thing is just bad), but I'm not sure I can read BM at all; he had me fooled last game I was in with him until process of elimination set in.

[MafiaSSK]

Vote count

DizzyIzzyB13 (1):Battle Mage
MikeSC6 (1):Jahudo
Battle Mage (1):Starbuck

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Do you have a better candidate in mind?

[Battle Mage]

I doubt we could do much worse than a BM lynch. Even if he can't be the Piper, he's acting in a very, very scummy manner.

If i was scum, i just wouldnt be posting. Why should i draw attention to myself, when lurking my way through the game was such a successful strategy?

BM

[Battle Mage]

I doubt we could do much worse than a BM lynch.

i agree.

BM

[Battle Mage]

Offering to be modkilled wouldn't help anyone from any side. I can't imagine there ever being a role in any game where the win condition was to be modkilled. It's definately not particularly pro-town.

And the Piper is the thing that we think is making people dance, because this game is based on a card game that has a Piper that does that.

so is the Piper like a cult recruiter?

The fact is, i wouldnt offer to be modkilled as scum, because all i need to do to meet my win condition is to survive. I dont need to actually play, so id be quite happy not participating and just going on like that. But im happy to be modkilled, because i'm town, and i was as useful alive as i would be dead. So yeh, i wouldnt blame you guys for lynching me, based on my lack of following the game. But you cant really say im scummy.

BM

[Jahudo]

No access until Aug. 25, then back to limited access.

[Yosarian2]

Do you have a better candidate in mind?

Good question. Let me see...

[Yosarian2]

I think this is the current player list...I just took out THe Replacement (who died last night) and put Zwet in as replacement for Millar.

2) MikeSC6 (Male, 19)
4) DizzyIzzyB13 (Female, 17)
6) Zwet

millar13

Xtoxm

(Male, 18),

Village Idiot

7) Rockatansky

knox

(Female, 18)
8) zwetschenwasser (Male, 1)
9) Yosarian2 (Male, 28),

Mayor

10) Jahudo (Male, 73)
11) Gorrad (Female, 42)
12) NabakovNabakov

Barrylocke

(Male, 19)
17) Dramonic

Firestarter

(Male, 32)
19) Ztife (Female, 24)
20) Starbuck

KaiveranZONEACE

(Male, 21)
21) Battle Mage (Female, 19)