Monty Python Quest for the holy grail, GAME OVER!!!

[Dragon Slayer]

I remember a discussion a while ago about the possibility some roles that might seem evil actually being good, uncluding the Black Knight.

[Macros]

ok, i'll extend the deadline by 48 hours.

[mathcam]

Well I guess I'm at a loss. I still think Night Stalker is our best bet. I'm hesitant to bandwagon someone new at this point, simply because there might not be enough time to do so properly. *prepares to get head bit off* Is no lynch an option?

Cam

[Fishbulb]

Actually, I was already contemplating a No Lynch. I was trying to figure out if it would hurt the town in this position, but if we don't go after Night Stalker, then I doubt we'll have enough time to do anything else but a No Lynch.

[mathcam]

So we at least agree on "Night Stalker or no one". That's good.

Let's see. No lynch kind of sucks because lynching is our one collective tool for dealing with evil. what's the trade-off? We get some investigations...evil gets to take a life (or more). It's really hard to say. Personally, I'm leaning toward lynching Night Stalker, but I definitely seem to be in the minority of that opinion. I still can't get over the fear that he's had the ability to save up kills, or even if not, he's cleverly been not killing just so he could eventually make this claim.

Vote: Night Stalker

This'll change to a vote for no lynch if a bunch of people agree to this, but I don't really see it changing to anything other than that.

Cam

[God]

I think Night stalker is better than noone

vote Night Stalker

[Dragon Slayer]

I still don't know. Now I'm leaning more towards lynching him. I gotta think some more on this.

-DS

[korais666]

Somehow 4 evil killing groups seems unreasonable to me. I'm gonna hold my vote.

[bane221]

His explanation of his power seems to just be lacking... something. I know, hunches are far from facts, but it just feels like N.S. is leaving something major out to protect himself. I'll place my

Vote: Night Stalker

for now but I am quite open to thoughts on this.

[Saigon]

Somehow 4 evil killing groups seems unreasonable to me. I'm gonna hold my vote.

2 mafia groups and one SK with one substitute SK isn't exactly the same as 4 killing groups. Actually it would be more like having two 3 person mafia groups (I presume there are 3 french) and one 2 person mafia group.

[Fishbulb]

I'm torn. I think the town could benefit from keeping Night Stalker alive, but it's either that or No Lynch, and that wouldn't give us

any

information.

I guess bane221 has a point, it seems like something is missing from Night Stalker's claim, and it very well might be something that we wouldn't like.

Vote: Night Stalker

[Night Stalker]

Why is it that everytime I can't get online for a few days, people start bandwagoning me?

I'm not telling something? Well, then, ask away. I'll answer all questions.

What really gets me is that everyone admits that my lynch isn't based on any facts, but on "hunches" (very convienient for the mafia) and on the "we gotta lynch someone" theory. (Which I've never understood).

So, you're about to lynch a very powerful pro-town role, a role that can give the town an extra kill if necessary. That seems a lot worse then a no lynch, much less a last minute attempt to bandwagon someone more deserving.

[Night Stalker]

Come to think of it, if you want to lynch someone who's already role claimed, why not lynch Loose Cannon? He's been acting more suspiciously then I have, (see viewtopic.php?p=9715&highlight=#9715, for instance) including his stretching the truth to try to indict me in this bandwagon. With you buying his role claim, he's continued his scummy bandwagoning ways.

Too add to that, his role claim was a of less likely character (Concord) - and even if it was a true role claim, the town still looses an ordinary townie rather then one with abilities.

[Night Stalker]

Come to think of it, if you want to lynch someone who's already role claimed, why not lynch Loose Cannon? He's been acting more suspiciously then I have, (see viewtopic.php?p=9715&highlight=#9715, for instance) including his stretching the truth to try to indict me in this bandwagon. With you buying his role claim, he's continued his scummy bandwagoning ways.

Too add to that, his role claim was a of less likely character (Concord) - and even if it was a true role claim, the town still looses an ordinary townie rather then one with abilities.

Vote: Loose Cannon

[Night Stalker]

(and oops. Thought I hit stop quickly enough. Darn. No doubt LC will try to use that against me too.)

[Loose Cannon]

Come to think of it, if you want to lynch someone who's already role claimed, why not lynch Loose Cannon? He's been acting more suspiciously then I have, (see viewtopic.php?p=9715&highlight=#9715, for instance) including his stretching the truth to try to indict me in this bandwagon. With you buying his role claim, he's continued his scummy bandwagoning ways.

Too add to that, his role claim was a of less likely character (Concord) - and even if it was a true role claim, the town still looses an ordinary townie rather then one with abilities.

Vote: Loose Cannon

Spell my name right, its Concorde, not Concord.

You also forgot to put 'OMGUS' before your vote, but we all know that it's assumed.

[rite]

vote: Loose Cannon

Your cocky attitude is really starting to bug me.

[mathcam]

Cocky attitute notwithstanding, it's not really a reason for a vote, is it? In my mind, there's no way Concorde is evil. He might be lying about his role, but I personally feel it's definitely in the game and no one else has contradicted. I see absolutely no merits in going after Loose Cannon today.

Night Stalker, the "I have a powerful pro-town role and if you lynch me you'll lose it" argument just doesn't work. I'm not convinved you

are

pro-town, at least not to the extent that I would rather not lynch

anybody

than lynch you. We've already lost several good pro-twon roles, so most likely what's going to happen is that we wake up tomorrow and we have no new information and we're back in the same spot, but with two more people dead, and us

still

not knowing about whether your role is good or not. How is that good for us?

And, as a side note, just keep in mind that the worst thing we could possibly have happen is we try to jump bandwagons only to find the deadline happening when the votes are split 50/50 and we lose both.

Cam

[Macros]

8 Night Stalker (Massive, Orbiting, Loose CAnnon, Saigon, Mathcam, God, Bane221, Fishbulb)
1 Loose CAnnon (Rite)

[mathcam]

Ummm...isn't it 8 to lynch?

Cam

[Macros]

and thinking it was 9 to lynch the moderator realised his mistake, and a mob formed around night stalker.
"I'm the black knight, unconquerable!"
"hmm, maybe a hanging wont work, shall we quarter him?"
"chop his arms off, he'll not do too much damage thwen, die of blood lose"
"good idea"

Night stalker is strapped down, and an axe sharpened
~thunk~
one arm off
"its only a flesh wound!"
~thunk~
two arms off
"barely a scratch!"

Night falls deadline.... i'll give you till monday ngiht (10pm GMT) as weekends are poor net access for most

[Macros]

Koraiss666 lights up a cigarette, pleased with his night performance, and does a little jig as he dances down the road.
"and what are we zo 'appy about tonight eh?"
"i bedded mathcam, ensuring he could nit be attacked"
"oh, an i zuppose you tink you did a good job eh? judging by uor cigarette!"
"i suppose i think i did"
"well, i will tell you zis! you are pathetic! i have eard it said you are ze worst lay in ze land!"
"no! thats a lie"
"hahahaha ~whispers to compatriots~ "im tellinh 'im he is uselss in ze bed" - "You know you are usless!"
"maybe im not as good as i thought...........
wandering off with this weighing on his mind, korais666 falls down a convieniently located man hole
"oh? so you thought it as conveniently located eh? haw haw haw!"

Day break and finds our beloved Sir galahad the chaste dead.
many will mourn Korais666's death!

With 13 alive, its 7 to lynch!

[Werebear]

The two heads didn't kill, or the kill was prevented. As to yesterday's lynch, I realize the black knight still could turn out evil, like a mafia informant, or something... but I'm still not happy about his death.

Macros - please fix the first post, unless you wish Night Stalker to ignore his death...

[Orbiting]

Night Stalker isn't dead - he's the Black Knight. We just hacked all his bits off.

[Fishbulb]

"What are you gonna do, bleed on me?"

So, there

was

something more to the Black Knight role, then. Did you know that was going to happen, Night Stalker?