Two pages ago Elmo was surefire scum. Sup sheeple.
I never got an answer on whom a town/scum flip would reflect on from FL. Specifically, I want to know where you'd confirm anyone as
town
one way but scum another.
Stop two-directional scumhunting, I can't even begin to emphasize how bad of an idea it is to base double alignment breakdowns on two unknown and currently-unconfirmable alignments. If Elmo ever turns up scum,
then
someone can go ahead and accuse me of defending a scumbuddy. If he's every confirmed as town,
then
go for the "scum-defending-townie-idea," (
wait now
doesn't that seem damned-if-you-do/don't to anyone else?).
I'm not outright defending Elmo right now so much as making sure every single person on the lynch wagon has crystal clear motivations and isn't able to pawn off a possible town lynch as "well,
he was acting to anti-town and unhelpful and useless
." Anti-town behavior is not always inherently scummy behavior. While it's not beneficial to the town, I want our day 1 lynch to be for scumhunting, not purging alignment-neutral players.
The Gurgi-Elmo-Nuwen trio is such a load. Do you people even think before you guys post? Isn't my vote still on Gurgi; is one of you going to call that distancing/preparing an early bus?
Noticeable commentary holes that arise as I read:
Battousai on forbiddanlight, Goatrevolt, Nuwen, Patrick
Debonair Danny DiPietro on everyone except Zazie,
want stances on at least five other players
Goatrevolt on Patrick, TDC, forbiddanlight
Gurgi
spliced all alignments here
Patrick on SpyreX, TDC, kinda-Llamafluff (*
1)
SpyreX on Nuwen, TDC, no opinion on Elmo until
Zaz vs. Elmo decision arises
TDC on everyone except Zazie
Zazie on lololo
I don't find Zazie town or scummy at the moment. Lurking is null to me, especially when it's inactive. Everyone building a bloody case on Zaz should have called for his replacement ages ago to pull information out of the role slot, if gaining information is your goal. Pro-Zaz lynching screams opportunism and the wagon is a good place to hide on if most people in the thread are okay with lynching anti-town (but not-scummy) behavior.
Not going near that wagon with a ten foot poleaxe - I see pro-town incentive to lynch Zaz from the players in this game, just because most of them are frothing at 'scummy' behavior that's anti-town and vaguely scummy during the RVS.
Elmo's lurking is different. He's shrugged off most of the cases against him this game, rather than sycophantically picking up and commenting on cases to assuage suspicion. Adopting a "this is how I roll" attitude in public makes more sense from a town-ish perspective.
(still backreading)
So high, so low, so many things to know.
aim:gochat?roomname=ScumChat&Exchange=5