#1: A treatise on arguing in the game of mafia:

[Vi]

A++, would read again, would link to.

[Vi]

On line with the cow, I've been accused of asking too many questions before, and I've heard it called a scumtell but I've never quite understood why.

Clearly everything I do is a Town-tell - if not, you need to adjust your concept of the game

One of the most common pitfalls in Mafia is trying to convince scum they are scum. I'm very glad you made mention of that here.

Also, I agree with Yos2. Very much so.

[Vi]

One of the most common pitfalls in Mafia is trying to convince scum they are scum.

I've had that work before.

In my first game (as Town) I almost convinced myself I was scum

[Vi]

My own subjective opinion is

excellent

for figuring out people's alignment. It's pretty horrible at convincing anyone else, but I can live with being Cassandra.

I share this sentiment.
There is no "I" in Team (or Town) (or Vi) but there definitely

is

one in "Vig".