Stars Aligned - GAME OVER

[chenhsi]

Should have picked Taboo: Reskit the last night.
Because when i get bloody tonight (Zomg), My res kit is destroyed.

So why don't you pick it tonight then?

[Furpants_Tom]

I am voting chenhsi because I think he is the most likely player to flip scum.

See, that I can respect. If that's the case for everyone voting chenhsi, then it's a sensible play.

@nhammen - if I had to pick a top 3, it would be:
1. Deathnote (obvscum, could be either cult or killer)
2. Datadanne (Probably already a murderer, or means to be after tonight)
3. Kise (Active lurker to the max)

Chenhsi, whatever Erik said about him, has been actively participating and adding useful input to virtually every conversation. I'm not sure the town benefits by removing him before we remove Deathnote.

[Percy]

Vote Count

chenhsi - 6 (semioldguy, Cass, nhammen, ZykeZero, Pablo_Molinero, DeathNote)

DeathNote - 1 (Furpants_Tom)
James Bond - 1 (Kise)
Cass - 1 (Sarag)
dramonic - 1 (Sajin)
Jebus - 1 (Magua)

Not Voting - 8 (chenhsi, Datadanne, dramonic, JamesBond, ryan2754, Jebus, sykedoc, SlySly)

Deadline

:

Midday on Saturday the 19th of September AEST (9pm Friday 18th site time)

.

V/LA

: semioldguy

Requested Replacement

: sykedoc, JamesBond.

Deadline is in

four days.

With 19 alive it takes 10 to lynch.

[chenhsi]

Chenhsi, whatever Erik said about him, has been actively participating and adding useful input to virtually every conversation.

It wasn't that Erik said anything about me. It was that I misread what Data said, so it looked like I knew that Erik was going to flip scum before he did.

Specifically, Data said that he was going to stalk me

if Erik flipped scum

, and I didn't notice the bolded part, and so D2 I thought that Data stalked me.

I think that I got confused about something else that made me look scummy, but I can't think of it.

[dramonic]

oh look, I'm not voting

Vote: Chenhsi

[SlySly]

Post 1158 took the words right out of my mouth.

vote:DeathNote

[Furpants_Tom]

Specifically, Data said that he was going to stalk me

if Erik flipped scum

, and I didn't notice the bolded part, and so D2 I thought that Data stalked me.

Oh, well that was a bit dumb. I still think Deathnote going is more important, but I get the bandwagon at least.

Carry on, town! Let's finish this off, if no-one else is going to make useful comments.

[SlySly]

1165 solidifies the 1158 line of reasoning. Let's avoid the WIFOM wagon that letting DN live will create.

[Kise]

@Furpants - Could you make a top 5, please? I have a follow up question for you. (listing #'s 4 & 5 alone is cool)

*TWITCH*

[chenhsi]

That makes sense:

vote: DeathNote

[Sarag]

I totally agree with Tom's argument. I think I missed this point because I haven't been so sure DN is scum (I can only flatter myself and believe I would have noticed otherwise). I saw that people were keen to off him anyway and since it was being done with a night kill, it didn't seem like there was a lot I could do about it (even ressing DN would lead to a worse situation for town).

But yeah, if you do think DN is scum and should die, you should be voting for him, Tom has made that very clear.

Until now, I've sort of been thinking that the decision about DN's scumminess had been decided for me, but now we have a good reason to consider him for the lynch again, I have re-read and factored him back into my lists. I still think it's possible he's newbie town, sulking about being targeted, but there is a distinct possibility that he is cult or murderer (especially as the day goes on, he's had a chance to cool off, is sounding more rational in his posts but still isn't being very pro-town). So yeah, I think he's probably the best lynch for today, better than chenhsi, or Cass.

Unvote. Vote: DeathNote.

[Pablo Molinero]

I differ to people smarter than myself in this little logic game.

unvote, vote: DeathNote

[chenhsi]

I really don't like the current mindless bandwagoning...

[DeathNote]

Voting for me again? Lets see if we all follow through.

[Furpants_Tom]

@Kise I guess that's fair, since I did put you in my first list.

4. Ryan2754 - He was a bit noisy early yesterday, but has gone to ground today. However, as far as I can tell he hasn't been prodded, so there's some kind of reasponse from his account. Furthermore, the name just stinks of alt account, and I distrust that. However, he's not popping up the active lurk red flags the same way you are, Kise.

5. Pablo_Molinero - I know it's rude, since he did just rock up and vote about 10 minutes ago, but I remember him being a lot more vocal last time I was in a game with him. Bouncing between bandwagons is more likely inattentive town than scum, but it just seems off for some reason.

[nhammen]

Chenhsi, whatever Erik said about him, has been actively participating and adding useful input to virtually every conversation.

It wasn't that Erik said anything about me. It was that I misread what Data said, so it looked like I knew that Erik was going to flip scum before he did.

Specifically, Data said that he was going to stalk me

if Erik flipped scum

, and I didn't notice the bolded part, and so D2 I thought that Data stalked me.

I think that I got confused about something else that made me look scummy, but I can't think of it.

It wasn't just that. It was also the way you sided with EtR during the EtR vs Zwet stuff.

I really don't like the current mindless bandwagoning...

*twitch* Agree.

[Kise]

Alright

*twitch*

I was just going to ask for your opinion on ryan, but you just did so.

Yeah, I'm lurking. I don't care to discuss mechanics like everyone else, so activity posts come here and there. I'm super-sold on JamesBond being scum based on his inquiring to those players who voted/suspected Erik, and also Erik's concern for him to be prodded.

*twitching is a bitch*

[Furpants_Tom]

I really don't like the current mindless bandwagoning...

*twitch* Agree.

Oh come on, that's a ridiculous, kneejerk response to what's actually happening. I have argued for two pages on this topic, Sly-sly has clearly stated his case and what he agrees with, Sarag has added useful analysis about DN's behaviour, only Pablo and chenhsi are freeriding on this one - and one of them has the affrontery to complain about it at the same time.

Instead of mouthing useless, site-standard platitudes to make yourself sound wisely sceptical, how about a spot of scum-hunting, chums?

[chenhsi]

Oh yeah, that. I didn't see why EtR was scummy, and I still don't. Not sure how you experts managed to read him.

[Furpants_Tom]

Alright

*twitch*

I was just going to ask for your opinion on ryan, but you just did so.

Yeah, I'm lurking. I don't care to discuss mechanics like everyone else, so activity posts come here and there. I'm super-sold on JamesBond being scum based on his inquiring to those players who voted/suspected Erik, and also Erik's concern for him to be prodded.

*twitching is a bitch*

That's fair enough if that's how you want to play it, but it doesn't reduce the suspiciousness. I would have put JamesBond and Jebus on the list for inactivity, but I'm curious to see what their new players do before I judge.

[Datadanne]

Vote: Furpants_Tom

Just what the hell are you doing?!
Creating mindless wagons, Buddying to chensi, Having shit logic, aso...

2. Datadanne (Probably already a murderer, or means to be after tonight)

Why?

1. Deathnote (obvscum, could be either cult or killer)

I don´t know about that, I think he´s just useless town.

Oh yeah, that. I didn't see why EtR was scummy, and I still don't. Not sure how you experts managed to read him.

*Laugh*
You are so scum

[Furpants_Tom]

2. Datadanne (Probably already a murderer, or means to be after tonight)

Why?

1. Deathnote (obvscum, could be either cult or killer)

I don´t know about that, I think he´s just useless town.

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaand Datadanne makes it to No. 1 - with a bullet!

You want to "vig" someone you think is town, and you honestly, in all seriousness, ask me why I think you're probably a murderer?

[Kise]

Weren't Data & zwet being linked D1? *twitch*

[SlySly]

I really don't like the current mindless bandwagoning...

Mindless? Try this on for size...

---------------------

vote: DeathNote

Votes himself.

------------------------

Ok... so... I am acting scummy. Hmm....

Unvote

Vote: DeatNote

Reaffirms the vote on himself.

------------------------

I obviously can't vote Mastin so I will vote for scum who, at the moment, seems to be me.

Explains his vote on himself is because he seems scummy.

------------------------

BTW if we are worried that Zwet will be killed, then I can res him so that we can be sure he gets the grave robbing done.

Offers to protect Zwet(KoC claimed scum). Zwet is not confirmed, but has been accused by self-proclaimed, mod-killed Cult-turned-murderer.

------------------------

Also, I just realized my current votee has been replaced and I was only voting him for

inactivity

/possible-newbishness, so unvote]

I despise that so much. Inactivity my butt! I try to post and it just makes me look guitly. If I could vote again and not get critized for it, it would be Mastin, but I won't. Instead I will remain

inactive

again.

EtR(confirmed scum) backs off his vote on DN and DN attempts to distance from EtR(confirmed scum).

------------------------

Yes I have claimed to have res kit but that does not mean I used it.

Just to help everyone latter on, in case I get vigged or voted off soon, I used res on Exalt last night.

Contradict much? LAL

------------------------

I will not be resing anyone tonight and hope that scum will res me to keep me alive. I am all about self preservation. If you want to lynch me tomorrow, then go for it.

I want to lynch you today.

------------------------

Then there are the two posts of Fur's that I already pointed out that state points I wanted to make earlier but I can't discuss someone that would be required to discuss to make those points. I didn't bother pointing out the several appeals to emotion DN has made in this game.

[Sarag]

I don´t know about that, I think he´s just useless town.

Policy vig = bad.