Elmo wrote:TDC, I think you can comment on whether you agree with my conclusions without knowing the reasoning behind them. Not undeserving would simply mean that you thought it wasn't unreasonable for me to conclude what I did. Incorrect would mean, I suppose, that if you were in my place, you'd come to a different conclusion. I don't think you really answered either.
...
Again, how would I EVER come to the conclusion that everyone but me is town? How could I possibly agree? That just makes no sense whatsoever.
I don't know what the point of this is either. It might be the case that even scum is doing a better job than me, but you're apparently not willing to tell me how so.
What bias do you have looking at your own play?
Uh, the bias that it's.. me?
Believe it or not, but I can't actually step out of my shoes and go "Oh, let's look how this TDC dude is doing".
I mean let's say I, all on my own, mislynched someone. Would I be aware that that could make me suspicious? Sure.
Would I be able to read what I wrote leading to the lynch without thinking "This lynch is justified"? Would I suddenly think "Man, this TDC dude is so scum!" Hell, no.
In the same vein, I can realize I wasn't the most productive player D1 (D2 arguable, has seen the whole town drop near my level..). But I will never come to the conclusion that I'm less town than anyone else.
Why exactly would your "towniness shine through"?
As in, when reading my posts, people might notice I'm town. I would hope that this happens. I'm not saying that I'm obv-town or anything like that.
What do you mean by "a weak line of scumhunting", and why's that bad?
It is the weakest possible attack (well, arguably, it isn't even an attack) you could possible raise. Perhaps you're trying to do something although you don't have anything, perhaps you're just tryting to look like you do something. I don't know.
