Mini 859 - Cleansing of Falls Church - Over

[Sanjay]

EDIT: lurker to taunt.

[Sanjay]

You could taunt Looker though I guess?

[Shrinehme]

DRKitty already pointing to Idiotking... I'm all out.

... Well, Far_Cry last posted back in page five, and he's been posting elsewhere since then, but Peabody already has a long post waiting for him.

You have to share.

[Sanjay]

Well, if I convince brothernature to tell us who he thinks is the most suspicious, and you convince him to vote for someone, maybe...

I don't know. I thought I had an idea of how those two things could go together, but I guess I lost it.

[Shrinehme]

What are your thoughts on EtherealCookie?

[DeathRowKitty]

Well, Far_Cry last posted back in page five, and he's been posting elsewhere since then

I don't like that AT ALL. It seems to me like FC is too happy with what's going on in the game (EC being useless and attracting lots of votes) and doesn't want to jeopardize it by posting when he's the second highest wagon.

@BN
Great to know you're "observing."

@SJ
Sorry for talking to your lurker

[Far_Cry]

Mod

: Srry, I've gotten busy lately. I need to be replaced.

Srry guys, I'm just busy with school. Hopefully I will be able to play more when I have a break. Good luck guys

[BigBear]

I agree in the fact that EC is acting extremely useless (not scum hunting, joking around, and playing stupid). However, I can't wrap my finger on whether that is a scum tell or not.

Shrine writes this to you EC, and you respond with the next post. Is that all? You don't want to defend your case any more? Have you given up?

Aside from those two paragraphs above... no one really commented much on my last post... :/ so there wasn't much for me to rebuttal to... that I could see. I'm satisfied with my vote for the moment.

people to look out for however....

EC - obviously, not acting pro-town. Not really liking him that much. (somewhat a gut read.)
Far_Cry - Somewhat a gut read also. I feel that DRK had a really good post here, regarding the matter.


the rest, I have neutral/town reads on. I won't go into specifics.

[BigBear]

EBWOP: Also, kinda depressed that Far Cry is leaving.... that's gonna put a damper on the game...

[Kreriov]

DeathRowKitty - "

IdiotKing! Come out come out wherever you are!

"
"

Where you at?

", asks Sanjay and immediately the grammar police show up to administer a warning. The next time you get a ruler on the knuckles.
"

Who me?

", says brothernature, "

I am lurking, er, observing

".
Then out of nowhere in his best Cartman voice, Far_Cry says, "

Screw you guys, I'm going home.

"

Vote Count

BigBear (1) - Far_Cry
brothernature (1) - Sanjay
EtherealCookie (4) - Looker BigBear ConfidAnon nook
Far_Cry (3) - Peabody DeathRowKitty Shrinehme
Shrinehme (2) - IdiotKing EtherealCookie

Not Voting - brothernature

With 12 alive it take 7 to lynch.

Looking for a replacement for Far_Cry

[Idiotking]

My apologies for inactivity, folks, my week's been hell. I'll do a quick reread in a few hours and post my thoughts.

[Idiotking]

Thoughts:

I had no idea what was going on until page 6 or so, to be honest. I couldn't tell what was RVS, sarcasm, or serious. You folks make my brain hurt.

As for scumtells:

I think Far_Cry is an interesting case, jumpy. He seemed to get serious far before anyone else did, and reacted... oh, what's the term... negatively? Now that he's replacing out I feel somewhat sad, because now the replacement can't elaborate on what Far_Cry was thinking.

EC also annoys me like all hell. I think it's suspicious to withhold information and reasoning for one's actions (I hate gambits and anything that could be mistaken as such), which makes EC out to be a living, breathing scumtell.

Unvote

Vote EC

On the other hand I don't see BB's actions as suspicious. Anything to generate discussion is a good thing, and if he did really vote for a no-lynch to get us out of RVS, I applaud that, especially since without it we'd probably still be in RVS.

One other thought:
It's natural to assume there's a Godfather in games of Mafia. As far as I can remember I've never been in a game

without

one, so I can understand why folks would expect there to be one.

[DeathRowKitty]

Just so everyone knows, that's L-2.

@IK
Can you think of any non-mafia motivations for EC's actions? I'm just looking for a yes or a no (I asked you specifically because your experience playing with me makes you more likely to figure out what I'm implying).

I don't think EC is a bad lynch, but I would prefer to look in other directions right now. Of course, FC's replacing out puts a bit of a damper on that, but I'm keeping my vote on him until his replacement convinces me to take it off.

[Looker]

Slow day.

Mod, can we get a prod on Idiotking? He hasn't posted since October 1.

Oh and...

Did you (EC) just claim???

I'm not seing it, unless you mean that he claimed he was a townie.

*twiddles thumbs and waits for FC or EC to show up*

Hi.
You were expecting me?

Um, Mr. Cookie, we need to kill somebody. Who should it be

What are your thoughts on EtherealCookie?

My thoughts are that one of you smart people should figure out who needs a'killun.

Mod

: Srry, I've gotten busy lately. I need to be replaced.

Srry guys, I'm just busy with school. Hopefully I will be able to play more when I have a break. Good luck guys

Are we going to wait for his replacement before relieving someone of their life or shall we press on?

EBWOP: Also, kinda depressed that Far Cry is leaving.... that's gonna put a damper on the game...

Nothing heals hurt like hurtin' someone else. Let's lynch!

[Sanjay]

What are your thoughts on EtherealCookie?

I've read EtherealCookie's posts a couple of times and I really can't get much of a read on him. The first bunch of pages of this game have been steeped in irony and sarcasm, and that kind of playstyle makes EtherealCookie's posts hard to read.

I think he might have gotten worse since DeathRowKitty because he didn't like being called the most useless.

I wouldn't mind him as a day 1 lynch, but I'd rather lynch someone I have a scummy read on.

[Idiotking]

Just so everyone knows, that's L-2.

@IK
Can you think of any non-mafia motivations for EC's actions? I'm just looking for a yes or a no (I asked you specifically because your experience playing with me makes you more likely to figure out what I'm implying).

If it were an isolated incident, yes. But EC's taken it to the extremes, so I have to say a no, not from my experience. And I'm not really good at picking up on implications

[EtherealCookie]

Slow day.

Mod, can we get a prod on Idiotking? He hasn't posted since October 1.

Oh and...

Did you (EC) just claim???

I'm not seing it, unless you mean that he claimed he was a townie.

*twiddles thumbs and waits for FC or EC to show up*

Hi.
You were expecting me?

Um, Mr. Cookie, we need to kill somebody. Who should it be

I dono. Give me a few days to get a few reads on people.

[Idiotking]

Is there any particular reason why you're playing coy, EC, or do you just like annoying people?

[nook]

This is frustrating.

Right now the of the two best leads that we have on so far, one is being extremely random and annoying while the other is getting replaced. Both would have been good lynches for the town today IMO, but Far_Cry is getting replaced and to be fair we should give his replacement some time to settle in.

And of course theres EC, who doesn't seem to be playing to win at all, in that case he should be replaced with someone who is actually willing to play, either that or I have a wild speculation that he's a Jester out to get lynched as quickly as possible. Simply because of the assumption that everyone plays to win, and the only way he'll be able to win playing like this is if has the role of the jester. This could just be idle speculation, of course.

And, lurkers like BN don't help much. Stop lurking and get something in before we start shifting our attention on you.

I'mma gonna do a reread soon to try to find some more clues while Far_Cry is being replaced.

[Sanjay]

Wouldn't jesters be a bit uncommon in a normal game?

[nook]

Yes, I said it could be just idle speculation. Still I'm working on my stated assumption that everyone plays to win, so if he's not a jester he would be a good lynch anyway if we don't get any better cases. Even if he pro-town in character, he is not being pro-town in behaviour.

[Looker]

I

like

the way Cookie's playing. It's new and exciting and it puts the up-tights on edge, but that's just me...

[Sanjay]

I thought that was what you were here for, Looker.

[Kreriov]

"

I say there need to be a killin!

", shouts Looker.
Everyone gasps as he pulls on his hair and the entire top of his head pops off! Revealing an almost empty void!
"

Just pour some thoughts in here so I know who needs that killin!

"

Vote Count

BigBear (1) - ZazieR
brothernature (1) - Sanjay
EtherealCookie (5) - Looker BigBear ConfidAnon nook Idiotking
ZazieR (3) - Peabody DeathRowKitty Shrinehme
Shrinehme (1) - EtherealCookie

Not Voting - brothernature

With 12 alive it take 7 to lynch.

Looking for a replacement for Far_Cry. I have posted requesting one and sent out a couple of PMs, but is any of you knows someone, tell them to PM me!

[Kreriov]

Effective immediately, Far_Cray is replaced by

ZazieR

, a.k.a Super_Hot_Chick.