Mini 859 - Cleansing of Falls Church - Over

[Shrinehme]

Which posts made by you were NOT seriously intended?

Pre-Post 97 ware all not serious, and Post 97 was intended to be moderately lighthearted yet more serious-ish than my previous posts.

Unvote

[Kreriov]

Its a long weekend. Do not expect another vote count until Tuesday morning

Vote Count

BigBear (1) - ZazieR
brothernature (1) - Sanjay
EtherealCookie (4) - BigBear ConfidAnon nook Idiotking
ZazieR (2) - Peabody DeathRowKitty
Shrinehme (1) - EtherealCookie

Not Voting - brothernature, Looker, Shrinehme

With 12 alive it take 7 to lynch.

[DeathRowKitty]

Interesting state of affairs with FC the past few days:

He replaced out of this game when he was about to be lynched in his newbie game, after which he joined another newbie game. He then joined another newbie game. Net result: -1 game, a result he could have achieved by staying in this game instead of joining a new one. The fact that he chose to join a new one instead of sticking with this one

really

doesn't sit well with me.

[BigBear]

Interesting state of affairs with FC the past few days:

He replaced out of this game when he was about to be lynched in his newbie game, after which he joined another newbie game. He then joined another newbie game. Net result: -1 game, a result he could have achieved by staying in this game instead of joining a new one. The fact that he chose to join a new one instead of sticking with this one

really

doesn't sit well with me.

Links please, I'm rather lazy. If your investigative report turns out, that's rather interesting.

[Looker]

Cookie's new avatar is cool.

2thumbs up!

[Sanjay]

Hey, Looker, has everyone talked who you wanted to talk before you answered my question about what you thought about me calling your theory all dumb and stuff?

[DeathRowKitty]

@BigBear
A link to FC's posts

Here was FC's last post in his newbie game, made about a minute before he replaced out of this game. If you look at the previous few posts, they were just waiting for d3x to show up before they hammered him and ended the game.

I just realized he signed up for the newbie game September 23, which makes this not quite so bad. I don't feel like deleting what I already typed, so I put a strikethrough through it instead.

[Peabody]

Honestly, I was pretty serious from the very beginning. Post 43 was my first serious post.

Zaz, what is your take on the game so far? I think everyone is waiting for this question to be answered.

[Looker]

Hey, Looker, has everyone talked who you wanted to talk before you answered my question about what you thought about me calling your theory all dumb and stuff?

Okay, just throwing it out there, shoot it down if you want.

You get the most votes, the closest to a lynch, and then BigBear votes no lynch.
Far_Cry votes BigBear for wanting a no lynch.
You vote Far_Cry.

Shoot it down.

To be honest . . . . that's not that bad of a theory.

One thing holding me back: I've seen BigBear play as scum. He's competent, and voting No Lynch is horrible scum play.

No offense to Looker, but this is a terrible theory.

Firstly, it supposes that BigBear is stupid enough both to believe that the RVS wagon on Shrinehme is enough of a threat to his scumbuddy to take drastic action.

Secondly, it supposes that BigBear is stupid enough to believe voting no lynch would work. Sure, it could serve to distract from his scumbuddy, but I don't really see how distracting from your scumbuddy by heaping a bunch of suspicion on yourself is a good idea.

Thirdly, it supposes that scum are going to vote to help out their scumbuddies even in the random voting stage, when the threat of lynching is very low.

unvote: nook

vote: ConfidAnon

You were right. I hadn't taken into consideration that he was nowhere close to a lynch and pretty much everything else you said. I mean, I hadn't really thought that through...

But I have a question for you, since you bring this up. Do you think that Confid could be scum on Cookie's wagon?

[brothernature]

Umn. I'm not sure very many of my posts were all that serious. Was just messing around most the time. But anyway, like we've all asked 100 times now, we'd like to hear your opinions on everything so far. Since he hasn't posted since a while,

Vote: nook

to get some pressure going.

[Idiotking]

All of my posts post-return have been serious, I think.

[ZazieR]

Zaz, would you mind telling me which of my posts are ambiguous to you?

I don't actually consider Lynch All Name Butchers a reliable tactic and I didn't really think I caught all the scum in the random voting stage and I am not actually a flying pumpkin.

What posts from what players were giving you trouble exactly?

Will mention these when everybody has stated their non-serious posts.

[ZazieR]

Honestly, I was pretty serious from the very beginning. Post 43 was my first serious post.

Zaz, what is your take on the game so far? I think everyone is waiting for this question to be answered.

I can only answer this question when I'm fully done reading, so please wait.

[ZazieR]

And before I forget again >.<:
Brothernature, are you a fan of Higurashi (Your avatar)?

Thanks for ignoring this,

brothernature

.

[Sanjay]

Oh, I'm really glad SOMEONE is observing what is going on. I totally forgot!

What have you seen? Who is the scummiest to you right now?

Thanks for ignoring this,

brothernature

.

[ZazieR]

Oh, come on! He has ignored that question since Page 7. 1 page more doesn't hurt after all those pages of ignoring it. My question on the other hand is brand new

[Sanjay]

If Cookie isn't scum, I think he is promising lynch bait. And now that I look at it again, I don't especially like ConfidAnon's vote of EtherealCookie:

Looker is likely Godfather; Sanjay merely a Goon.

I don't know how he knows a godfather even exists. Honestly, half the posts in this thread aren't serious.

I don't like Far Cry's personal attacks, but I don't see anything scummy with him.

I'm just jumping on the Shrinehme bandwagon because I don't get good vibes from him.


Vote: Shrinehme

This vote does not seem protown at all. It practically screams bandwagon.

Unvote, Vote: EtherealCookie

Something about it just doesn't sit right to me. Maybe accusing a post that announces it is jumping on a bandwagon of bandwagoning seems too lazy or something.

And maybe it is trying to confuse anti-town actions with scummy actions.

FoS: ConfidAnon

I'm also a bit curious of this post by Peabody.

Peabody, at the end of this post you suggest a Far_Cry/EtherealCookie scum pair, while to me it doesn't look like you've provided any evidence for a connection between these players at all. What am I missing here?

To me it just looks like a whole lot of individual scumtells. Maybe you know one of them is scum and you are trying to set-up a mislynch in case said scumbuddy gets lynched, perhaps?

Please elaborate on why you thought at that point a Far_Cry/EtherealCookie pair was likely enough to mention.

FoS: Peabody

Looker, could you explain why you delayed answering my question? Given your answer, I see no reason why you had to wait for any of the people you wanted to wait for.

This is what you told me:

The answer to that question depends on further posts from BigBear, Far_Cry, Shrine, & Cookie; however, BigBear & Far_Cry have disappeared. I

will

answer your question, but I'd like for them to get back first. Will that be alright?

I really fail to see how it depended on those posts. Explain to me how your answer would have changed based on those peoples' responses. What were you thinking exactly?

I had taken your theory to be some kind of joke to try to get a rise out of people, but now that I find out you were seriously floating it, I think I'm gonna throw you a vote, for trying to create undue suspicion and for dodging my question for no good reason.

Unvote

Vote: Looker

[Sanjay]

Oh, come on! He has ignored that question since Page 7. 1 page more doesn't hurt after all those pages of ignoring it. My question on the other hand is brand new

Good point.

brothernature, please answer ZazieR's question and if you still have time enough after that could you get to mine?

[ZazieR]

Ok, done making notes. There might be more later on when everybody has stated which posts weren't serious.
Anyway, as some might know, my posts are always in 'spam'-style. For those who don't know what that means, you'll find out soon enough. My 'spam fest' starts now ^.^

P.S. Warning, you don't want to post during the 'spam fest'

[ZazieR]

Post 24 – Gut activated.

[ZazieR]

Post 31 – No

Looker

, it’s “Look at Looker”, “The Good-Lookin Looker” or “The Good-Looking Lookeress”. Not “Look”

[ZazieR]

Post 36 – Any reason why Nook over Looker,

Sanjay

?

[ZazieR]

Post 50 – Why would you hope so,

DRK

?

[ZazieR]

Post 62 - scummy, as

Confid

went from a semi-serious vote to a random vote.

[ZazieR]

Post 68 – If this wasn’t serious, then why did you ask this question,

Sanjay

?