Mini 859 - Cleansing of Falls Church - Over

[ZazieR]

Get your own looker to taunt, Shrinehme. This one is mine.

As we say here: ‘Samen delen, samen spelen’ My grandmother would have slapped you if she’d have known that you weren’t doing this

[ZazieR]

IK

– What do you define as ‘gambit’?

[ZazieR]

Post 193 – Jester? Why bring this up?

[ZazieR]

Here ^.^ Will read this game one of these days. I'm learning how irritating a sore throat can be ._.

what does that have to do with typing >.<

Nothing. But I was very irritated that I almost had no voice >.<

[ZazieR]

@ZazieR
What do you think of your predecessor's play?

Tried to direct the town into scumhunting, but due to try this in an aggressive way, he failed. So good intentions, but did it in the wrong way.

[ZazieR]

Bringing up the idea of a jester, is actually scummy

Why?

-Good way to lynch a player who says stupid things.
-Jester discussion is a distraction from scumhunting, which is good for scum.

[ZazieR]

Also checking in. Sorry. Playing in another game with an alt at the moment and haven't had time to check up lately. And maybe he meant to say sj, for Sanjay, Sanjay? And yes. Hearing Zaz's take on things would be most helpful.

You lurk and instead of giving your own intake, you ask for the opinion of the new guy? What’s up with that,

brothernature

?

[ZazieR]

Post 250 – Why the unvote,

Shrine

?

[ZazieR]

Umn. I'm not sure very many of my posts were all that serious. Was just messing around most the time. But anyway, like we've all asked 100 times now, we'd like to hear your opinions on everything so far. Since he hasn't posted since a while,

Vote: nook

to get some pressure going.

At least he has posted content, something you haven't done since a while. How come?

[ZazieR]

Looker

– How come you wanted to hear from 4 players before answering a question from Sanjay? The same regarding a question from Peabody at which you stated you wanted to hear from Shrine first. And even after he posted, no answer. Please explain.

[ZazieR]

So my list:

scummy

-shrineme
-brothernature
-nook
-confid
-(Bear)

neutral

-IK
-Peabody
-(Bear)

leaning town

-Looker
-EC

Town

-Sanjay
-DRK

[ZazieR]

And with that, I'm done and fully caught up ^.^

Vote brothernature

[Sanjay]

Post 36 – Any reason why Nook over Looker,

Sanjay

?

Yes, actually.

I had just read a game with Looker and he seemed like a player that was probably not liable to drastically overreact during the random voting stage. I hadn't ready any such games with nook so I thought the vote would be better placed on him to see if he might do something interesting.

Post 68 – If this wasn’t serious, then why did you ask this question,

Sanjay

?

They hadn't done anything and I figured they wouldn't ignore their names in big bold letters.

Post 88 –

Sanjay

, why did you ask the question about the RVS?

I've heard some people say eagerness to get out of the RVS was a scumtell. I don't know if I necessarily buy it as a scumtell, but I thought it was worth asking about, especially because it didn't seem like Far_Cry had a lot to move out of the RVS with.

Post 116 – First, lots of assumptions to destroy a theory. Secondly, why did you vote Confid over Looker,

Sanjay

? Don’t like it that it’s based upon disagreement.

Was that supposed to read "lots of assumptions

do

destroy a theory" or something? Because those assumptions are ones you have to make to support the theory, not destroy it. And I think all of those assumptions are pretty hard to believe.

I voted for Confid over Looker because I thought Looker was joking.

Post 166 – What was the reason behind this vote,

Sanjay

?

I wasn't feeling that enthusiastic about my ConfidAnon vote so I figured I'd move it, and I wasn't getting exceptionally strong reads from anyone, and I thought it'd be nice to hear from brothernature.

[DeathRowKitty]

2 straight pages of posts?!

Post 50 – Why would you hope so, DRK?

That was basically in place of saying "ok" or something similar. I would hope he wouldn't OMGUS against a random vote for one of his real votes because...well...that would just be really stupid.

Why did you point out the bolded?

It was almost as if FC was trying to get in a low blow on half the game. We were more or less in the RVS, FC made one serious post, and immediately accuses 3 players by name (and others namelessly in parentheses) of not doing anything. What exactly was he expecting out of the RVS?

Can you rephrase the quoted part of FC?
Also, why didn’t you question Shrine further on his ‘scum-slip’?

1. Do you mean what I said about what I quoted from FC? If so, I didn't like how he said "might be" in his first sentence and then "possible" in his next two sentences. Basically, to me it just screams "Maybe not, but it could be if you squint your eyes hard enough!"
2. There really wasn't anything to question him about.
Possible Conversation:
-Hey shrine, how do you know you're not aligned with BB?
-I don't.
-Why did you say that then?
-[INSERT REASON/EXCUSE HERE]

The reason/excuse would probably either be "I think BB is scum" or "typo on my part" or something to that effect and wouldn't tell us much.

I personally think it's better not to stagger your arguments against someone and to present them in bulk later. Small things like this tend not to be effective alone, but if shrine acts scummy later, it could be important evidence as part of a larger case.

Why did you ask about Peabody?

I was playing around with the idea of EC being jester and wanted to see how EC would respond when asked about a player who hadn't done much suspicous and really didn't stand out.

unvote

[Sanjay]

And with that, I'm done and fully caught up ^.^

Vote brothernature

Don't think I am ignoring your grandmother's wisdom, but why aren't you voting for the person on top of your scumlist?

[Sanjay]

Also, thanks, Zazie, for giving this game a much needed kick in the pants.

[ZazieR]

And with that, I'm done and fully caught up ^.^

Vote brothernature

Don't think I am ignoring your grandmother's wisdom, but why aren't you voting for the person on top of your scumlist?

brothernature is on top. The list isn't ordered from most to less in the groups.

[ZazieR]

Also, thanks, Zazie, for giving this game a much needed kick in the pants.

It seems I do that in most games
Will respond to the two bigger posts tomorrow.

[Sanjay]

Cool. I'm also still curious about why you asked people about how serious they were.

Apparently I was wrong about Looker and his theory, but for the most part I thought stuff was pretty clear.

[Shrinehme]

Post 97 – So the reason behind your vote is? (

Shrine

)

Far_Cry's insults looked more like strategic distancing than genuine emotion.

Post 115 – Why ask EC about Bear,

Shrine

?

Wanted to hear more from EtherealCookie.

Post 107 – Which is why Bear’s vote after the no-lynch was for you and not for FC? Why didn’t you address this vote from Bear when you thought he was trying to catch scum by voting no-lynch?
Actually, talking about this, how come you didn’t even ask anything about it?
You giving him a way out is also noted. (

Shrine

)

He didn't back up his vote, so it was clear he wasn't planning to go anywhere with it.

Re-phrase the first question?

No, I don't feel that it's a bus. I am not Scum,

let alone aligned with him

. I don't really see how his vote could even be interpreted as a bus.

Oh? How do you know?
Also, how come you did comment on EC’s vote against you, but not Bear’s vote against you?

You're interpreting it wrongly. "Aligned" as in, being partnered with him via role [scum partners, ect.].

I commented on EtherealCookie's vote because he put forth a reason for his vote. BigBear gave me nothing to comment on.

Post 250 – Why the unvote,

Shrine

?

I'm not interested in pursuing Far_Cry's/your lynch.

[Shrinehme]

EBWOP

Bringing up the idea of a jester, is actually scummy

Why?

-Good way to lynch a player who says stupid things.
-Jester discussion is a distraction from scumhunting, which is good for scum.

To the former, placing forth the possibility x is a Jester when their actions are scummy would be used to

deter

their lynch, [e.g. "No, x just looks like a Jester to me. Y looks like actual scum; let's lynch him."] no?

Latter makes sense.

[brothernature]

Lulz is it really that hard to put all of that into one post instead of spamming up two pages? And yes, I'm a fan of Higurashi.

Post 169 – Why aren’t you discussing, while observing, brothernature? Also, noted that you showed right up after a player voted for you.

Like I said, I'm observing and lurking, just not posting. He asked where I was. I told him I was lurking.

You lurk and instead of giving your own intake, you ask for the opinion of the new guy? What’s up with that, brothernature?

Indeed I do.

At least he has posted content, something you haven't done since a while. How come?

Actually, I'm pretty sure I've never posted any content whatsoever.


And to Sanjay, I really don't like Cookie right now. He's posting all this random shit and distracting the town, making it harder for us to get stuff done. My random shit, however, is more so on topic, just in a jokingly way, most the time.

[Peabody]

will post soon..

Wow, Zaz... maybe you could shorten into 1 post?

[Sanjay]

Lulz is it really that hard to put all of that into one post instead of spamming up two pages? And yes, I'm a fan of Higurashi.

Post 169 – Why aren’t you discussing, while observing, brothernature? Also, noted that you showed right up after a player voted for you.

Like I said, I'm observing and lurking, just not posting. He asked where I was. I told him I was lurking.

You lurk and instead of giving your own intake, you ask for the opinion of the new guy? What’s up with that, brothernature?

Indeed I do.

At least he has posted content, something you haven't done since a while. How come?

Actually, I'm pretty sure I've never posted any content whatsoever.


And to Sanjay, I really don't like Cookie right now. He's posting all this random shit and distracting the town, making it harder for us to get stuff done. My random shit, however, is more so on topic, just in a jokingly way, most the time.

brothernature, if that's all you can come up with, I don't think your sitting and observing is really justified. Unless you explain to me how posting random shit and distracting the town is a scum-tell, you are basically telling me that after all the observing you have observed basically nothing.

When are you planning on posting your thoughts on the game, exactly? Is it a matter of piling votes on you? Because I'm sure there are a bunch of players that would be happy to oblige.

[Looker]

Zaz, you rock.