Newbie 839 - Game over

[Starbuck]

Mod - Can we have a round of prods please?

[Starbuck]

So I wanted to provide a little insight:

Maemuki is pretty much posting everywhere but here. A simple click on her profile link and a search of her posts proves this.


CSL has posted nothing but fluff and his last post is on Sunday. He is well past the 72 hour prod and I request a replacement for him.

[CSL]

Sorry I went away on you all. I never anticipated leaving for a trip without prior knowledge beforehand. I got back last night, but was too tired to do anything.

Maemuki, get in here and post.

Checking on questions directed at me.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Well unless something surprising happens it looks like this day might end up coming down to Bub's decision as I'd expect CSL and Maemuki to crossvote putting them both at L-1 with Bub the only one not voting.

Since you're the one likely in the swing role, Bub, how about you take the lead and give us your thoughts in regards to which way you're leaning and why.

[Maemuki]

Maemuki, get in here and post.

Says you! You're the one that replaced two weeks (?) ago and never posted anything of context, so stop being:
a. hypocritical,
b. following everybody.

Make some scumhunting of your own for once. Kthx.

So. Analsys. Post. Now.

@ Starbuck,
so you're saying I should hold back? People on other games won't hold back, so why should I? And why is it an indicator of alignment? You usually get more rude with people you distrust - I distrusted him, therefore...

You seemed to take a pretty firm stance on Teh. Nice slip.

Did you even read what I said? Guess not.

[Starbuck]

What you are doing is called active lurking. You are posting everywhere else but here. I have provided a full analysis of the game and you have yet to respond.

[starkmoon]

Prods sent. Vote count later when the antihistamines kick in.

[Feeres]

Hi, checking in, I'll be busy today (Saturday night you know) but I'll check back on the rest of what's going on tomorrow.

[Bub Bidderskins]

Man, I let myself get prodded. Sorry about not posting, but I was working on a writing contest that I recently learned was due today, and that was three days ago X-(.

Regardless, I'm glad that there's some content being posted now. As far as CSL and Maemuki, I'm not liking either one. CSL is either lazy or just doesn't want to help the town.

Maemuki hasn't helped the town much either, and has just posted a bunch of fluff. As of right now, I'm keeping my vote reserved for when it's needed.

[Starbuck]

So you are fence sitting and are only going to vote when it's convenient and opportunistic for yourself.

[Feeres]

Maemuki has contradictions in her posts - agree.
Those contradictions add up to become voteworthy - disagree.
Maemuki is active lurking, scummy behaviour - agree.
She should be lynched because of both contradictions and active lurking - partially agree.

Starbuck, do you have anything more to add about Raskol after page 5? Your analysis only focused on the first 5 pages and DDD thought it would be insightful to comment on him.

CSL has unanswered questions - agree.
CSL hasn't answered really anything yet - agree.
He should be lynched based on this - partially agree.

We are getting quite close to deadline, I was expecting to have some more insight from Bub especially following DDD's tiebreaker post, the one where he pointed out that the lynch might be entirely up to what Bub thinks about the situation. Both our accused players are at L2 so if he had voted already, we might be in to night with the other accused hammering thereafter.

CSL, post at least some insight before the deadline, otherwise I'm supporting your lynch. DDD, what are your reasons for voting Maemuki? Is it just the mentioned theory and gut feel about scumminess still or has anything changed since then?

[Starbuck]

Feeres, what I commented on about Raskol is what I found scummy. I think he did do some scummy things when Diakron was still in the game, but as of late, he's really not scummy enough to warrant my vote.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

I think we have to assume we're still under deadline with only possible extensions for forum down time. That means Maemuki and CSL need to vote, probably for each other and Bub needs to declare who he intends to hammer if that's the case so we can get a claim to evaluate before deadline.

[starkmoon]

How much longer than the couple of hours I am aware of was the forum down?

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

How much longer than the couple of hours I am aware of was the forum down?

For me I'd say down time was roughly midnight to eleven AM-ish so rounding up about twelve hours, plus there might be more when they actually move servers.

[Starbuck]

How much longer than the couple of hours I am aware of was the forum down?

As DDD said, it was down for about 12 hours.

[Raskol]

I think we have to assume we're still under deadline with only possible extensions for forum down time. That means Maemuki and CSL need to vote, probably for each other and Bub needs to declare who he intends to hammer if that's the case so we can get a claim to evaluate before deadline.

You seem somewhat indifferent to the lynch choice today.

Why leave it in bub's hands without trying to convince him your target is the better one?

[Starbuck]

Wasn't it left in Bub's hands yesterday? Why would you be so willing to do that again, DDD?

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

I think we have to assume we're still under deadline with only possible extensions for forum down time. That means Maemuki and CSL need to vote, probably for each other and Bub needs to declare who he intends to hammer if that's the case so we can get a claim to evaluate before deadline.

You seem somewhat indifferent to the lynch choice today.

Why leave it in bub's hands without trying to convince him your target is the better one?

The facts are on the board, if I need to reiterate them I will, but I've stated my piece on the matter. I'd rather not leave it up to Bub, but it's the only way I see things going as CSL and Maemuki seem to have no interest in finding other targets and I expect will cross-vote out of self-preservation.

Of course you could help make it so that fact is irrelevant by joining me in voting for Maemuki because I have no interest in a CSL lynch, he may be useless as a bag of wet sod but I see little reason to suggest he's likely scum and not just an idiot.

[starkmoon]

Alright, add a day to the deadline.

[CSL]

Well, I'm waiting for a votecount before I do anything.

[Starbuck]

Well, I'm waiting for a votecount before I do anything.

Dude are you serious?

You have cases against you.

Unvote, Vote: CSL

How about now?

[Starbuck]

Last vote count can be found at the bottom of page 12 for your information. It's called looking at stark in iso.

[Starbuck]

Looks like claim time for you buddy. You're at L-1.

[CSL]

Dammit...There's a case against me, I'm at L-1, and due to my current behavior, no one is going to believe my claim.

Oh, well.

Claim: Townie