EtherealCookie wrote:So.
BJL is useless townie. This is not enough to have me lynch him on day II. We are going on a dangerous path if we're going to kill off people just because they're useless, when we should be on the hunt for scum. So, keep your vote where it's at, Meji. But, if he shows up townie, I'm going to go, "I told you so", given he didn't have any scum tells and you support your vote over the fact he's being useless, which doesn't have to be a scum tell.
bjl is not voted for being useless. he is voted for the fishing, and it is a scum tell.
I hope we can get a replacement for Pianist soon.
and you hope you can get some help.
No, I am sure bjl is town because I know who scum is now.
so why you are sure tubby and me are both scum? only cop can be sure about who is scum by investigating, but a cop can only investigate once as it is day 2 now. so no one can be sure who are the 2 scums, except for the scums themselves.
So you follow a lynch all lurkers policy?
Wow.
you are twisting my words. the inverse of "all lurkers are not scum" is "some lurkers may be scum", that's not the same with "all lurkers are scum". if you know logic, you should know it.
Did you bother reading my post? It seems you didn't.
I was giving reads of people on the Bandwagon. Separately for their actions on each bandwagon. You showed up pro-town Day I. I did not have any suspicions of you. However, your subtle defense of Tubby has changed my mind otherwise.
i don't know if you are thinking in a proper way. maybe you think me looking pro-town day 1 is scummy. who know?
So, just because someone is sure that a person is scum, that means we should ruin all further discussion and hammer? Seems like a scummy thing to do.
seems like? no, it is scummy, and anti-town. but i like his hammer as i really think he is scum. i also like a hammer now as i really think bjl is scum.
Why the hell would scum lie in Twilight, when scum is already dead?
how many games had you played? i have seen lots of times scum saying he is townie in twilight.
Yes, the difference is that the person I am defending does not seem scummy at all.
so why bjl is townie except that "tubby and i am the 2 scums".
I know that. You had your reasons for voting for him. When did I say you didn't? Are you telling me if a man follows a guy jumping off a bridge, he still cannot have his own reasons for doing so?
no, you said so:
cookie wrote:Oh man, Manho. The guy who followed me onto Wrath's bandwagon quickly, and now I'm scum?
and it didn't answer my question why you can't be scum if i vote after you.
No, that's called holy crap, you're trying to attack me along with Tubby, who is extremely scummy, and gang up on me. You must be scum buddies! Sorry for noting relations between players.
no, tubby is scummy as he vote you, and i am scummy as i vote you. that's OMGUS.
A decent case is never good enough a reason to lynch. A good case is the only time you lynch.
so did you have a good case to show that tubby and i am definitely scum?
Once again, I have to ask, do you read the posts?
Crazypianist isn't going to talk more, given he asked for a replacement, so there's no point of telling him to.
crazypianist needs to speak more implies crazypianist and his replacement and his replacement's replacement and... , as they are regarded as the same player in this game.
