Mini 852- Crayola Catastrophe Game Over (Post 1158)

[SocioPath]

Sorry, I kinda am still a noob, but I joined MS and Epic Mafia (a chat mafia site) about the same time, and drunk is more common there. Drunk is basically a town roleblocker, which really helps if you have a lot of scum PRs. Although, it could just be a post restriction, perhaps hinted to in the D1 lynch scene. But if it is a post restriction, why would Batt be looking for a replacement? And is he looking for a replacement? So many questions...

Requoted for easy of reading:

I joined

Epic Mafia

(a chat mafia site)

drunk is more common there

[Kirbyoshi]

How would you know it doesn't exist, Socio?

[Pomegranate]

It's just that it's somewhat unlikely that the role is not in this game.

[Kirbyoshi]

Fine then. Doctor variation? Jailer variation? Something went on with GDude last Night.

[SocioPath]

How would you know it doesn't exist, Socio?

The meta does not exist.

Clearly shown by no one knowing what the crap you are talking about.

It's just that it's somewhat unlikely that the role is not in this game.

How is it unlikely that the role is not in the game?

Going by the FLAVOR, and ONLY FLAVOR. GD hung out in bars and drank a lot.
GD also didn't post to the point of NEEDED TO BE REPLACED.
Mod adds FLAVOR to such saying he was gone cause he was passed out drunk.
Stop confusing reality with mod flavor.

[Pomegranate]

It's just that it's somewhat unlikely that the role is not in this game.

How is it unlikely that the role is not in the game?

I meant that it's unlikely that it

is

in the game.

[Kirbyoshi]

I'm just saying, there has to be some reason he didn't respond to the "roll call" (who DID put Chibo in charge? lol). I agree, now that I know there's no meta for it, that it's unlikely there's a drunk. However, there must be some reason. Thoughts?

[SocioPath]

I'm just saying, there has to be some reason he didn't respond to the "roll call" (who DID put Chibo in charge? lol). I agree, now that I know there's no meta for it, that it's unlikely there's a drunk. However, there must be some reason. Thoughts?

BECAUSE HE HAD TO BE REPLACED DUE TO NOT PICKING UP PRODS.

[Nachomamma8]

Well, I'm not. You are seemingly trying to dodge responding my points against you by saying that I'm twisting your words.

You have no points against me.

Is that really your entire defense? That has to be the laziest scum defense I've ever seen in my life, Socio. For someone who is extraordinarily good at picking up reads on someone when they attack you, you definitely don't defend yourself well.

@Kirby: Socio is right about the situation with GD. Mod flavor doesn't mean a whole lot. It's. just. mod. flavor. GD didn't pick up his prod. He's getting replaced. End of story.

@Pomegranate: A screamer is a pro-town role that can roleblock anyone from killing. Also, when targeted for an NK, it will "scream" and attract the whole town to kill the murderer, but it won't live through the night. Hope that made sense...

[Kirbyoshi]

Well, I guess I learned something this game. One should always try to learn something from every game. Now, back to Chibo.

[Pomegranate]

^^^ QFT about the last bit.

[Nachomamma8]

Chibo is lurking because he can't come up with a good excuse, Kirby. So I'd suggest you start looking elsewhere for suspects, Kirby.

[SocioPath]

Well, I'm not. You are seemingly trying to dodge responding my points against you by saying that I'm twisting your words.

You have no points against me.

Is that really your entire defense? That has to be the laziest scum defense I've ever seen in my life, Socio. For someone who is extraordinarily good at picking up reads on someone when they attack you, you definitely don't defend yourself well.

You haven't said anything I need to defend myself with.
I defend myself when needed.
You go 'ALL YOUR ATTACKS ARE OMGUS, AND THAT MAKES TOWN NOT WANT TO ATTACK YOU'
I respond with 'el oh el, kay.'
Nothing you've said has any realm of logic behind it.
You didn't listen to a single word I said when you made that 'attack.'
Although, this IS helping me get a better read on you IF YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN.

[Nachomamma8]

1) Explain post 496. How does players attacking you help you get better reads on you?

2) Quote where I said that all of your attacks are OMGUS.

3) Re-say what I didn't listen to.

[SocioPath]

1) Explain post 496. How does players attacking you help you get better reads on you?

It doesn't help get better reads on ME. It helps me get better reads on them, the people attacking me. When I see attacks directed at me, I can more often than not, determine if the attack is coming from town, or coming from scum.
Therefor if someone attacks me and they are town, I'll likely see that they are town.
If someone attacks me and they are scum, I can usually pick up on that as well. Either that or they are a VI. Which I'd lynch as well.

2) Quote where I said that all of your attacks are OMGUS.

A townie who is not 100% sure of your scumminess will be reluctant to attack you in fear of having a weak argument used against him.

A townie would be afraid to attack you because

you sound like the only case you make on people stem first from their attack on you.

3) Re-say what I didn't listen to.

No townie is ever 100% sure of anyones scumminess.

And why would a townie be afraid to attack me? You are arguing the exact opposite of what I'm saying. I think it is you who doesn't understand.

If I get a better read on people that attack me, and a townie attacks me...then obviously its easier to gauge whether or not that attack originated from a townie. You are seemingly trying to twist my words to make it sound like every case and attacks I do is nothing more than OMGUSes.

[Battousai]

Vote Count:

ChiboSempai (2)- Nachomamma8, Kirbyoshi
Nachomamma8 (1)- Yankee
Kirbyoshi (1)- SocioPath

Not voting (4): Pomegranate, ChiboSempai, GreenDude, elvis_knits

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch

Jahudo replaces GreenDude as soon as I get a confirmation message

Deadline is still Nov 3!

[Nachomamma8]

Sorry, #1 was a mistype. The second "you" should read "them".

2) Alright, now explain how either of those statements are false.

3) From the way your posts on your strategy sound, it looks like you make cases from people who attack you. Because this is your primary strategy and you've been here over a year, I assume you're good at it. So, if you were scum using the same strategy, you could pick apart a townie's weak argument on you and make them look scummy. So, a townie who is a little suspicious of you but not confident in his/her case may stop from commenting on their suspicions in fear of being misconstrued.

If the preceeding paragraph has incorrect logic or stupid conclusions, point out the sentence in which they start.

[Jahudo]

Hello! I haven't read anything yet.
Tell me which Yellow you prefer / can read. (This is normal yellow)

[Nachomamma8]

I love you so much, bro. Yellow 3 and Pear are pretty easy for me to read.

[Kirbyoshi]

I see nothing wrong with using normal yellow, Jahudo, but of course, I'm using the tiger skin, so do whichever you want, and if I can't read it, I'll just highlight it like I do with Socio.

[Yankee]

Isnt Yellow3 my color? You have to post in the color the mod gives you i thought....

[ChiboSempai]

I wasn't lurking, I said in my post I would be back soon. I was away for a Smash tourney on Sat and didn't get home from NY till late Sunday. I'm at work now which means time to catch up lol.

I honestly don't understand Yankees claim. I don't suppose it really hurts us per se, but confirms a townie for us if we believe him. To the mafia they already knew he wasn't with them (if he's not mafia) so it's really no different to them. Also he's practically not a power role anymore. There's no way he has his shot still because if he did he wouldn't be posting this.

But like, why exactly did you role claim?

[Yankee]

i role claimed because i thought it could help the town out somehow and it wouldnt matter since im not a PR anymore really. Also i found it odd that the only kill during the night was my kill, and everyone thought it was odd for the mafia to pick Zazier so i figured if i told you guys that it was me that killed Zazier then it might help some.

[Kirbyoshi]

imo, role claiming when you don't have to is always bad. If you happen to be vanilla (or, in this case, an exhausted one-time-use PR), it gives scum one less target, since they will try to kill the PRs.

[Yankee]

True i guess, didnt think of it like that....