Perfectionist Mafia - Resultas

[Santos]

Two cops!!?!?!?!?!?!1111!111!! *does the no pants dance*

[Santos]

BloodCovenent, while saving yourself from catching up with that claim, who do you want to lynch today BESIDES Snow White or Mufasa?

[almightybob]

I take it you'd like me to skip my analysis and previous questions asked? And just claim?

I'm a cop.

I was hoping for claimpost, followed by analysis and question responses, because I didn't want another SW-case with only 4 days to go. Looks like I was right.

Just to be absolutely clear: you're claiming Town Detective too?
So how many cops are in this bloody game?


Also,

@SW and BC

: Did either of you do any breadcrumbing?

[almightybob]

@Mod: Your votecounts are all screwed up to hell.

I've only just noticed, but in votecount 11 you have a total of 21 votes placed by 18 people. And votecount 12 is off as several people have noted.
I'm going back to do a proper votecount. Hold on.

[MrSuave]

okay... can anyone sum up what's happened this last week... so I don't have to spend hours looking? it would be reaaaaaaallly nice =D

[Sanjay]

BC, how does being a cop mesh with your seemingly attention seeking RVS behavior?

[xRECKONERx]

BC's claim is obviously bullshit. Can we just lynch him please.

[almightybob]

almightybob's unofficial (but accurate) votecount

BloodCovenent - 7 (EtherealCookie, xRECKONERx, Sposh, saberwolf, starbuck, almightybob, wickedestjr)
Snow White - 4 (My Milked Eek, DeuxiemeOctopus, Mufasa, dramonic)
FaerieLord - 1 (Snow White)
Sposh - 2 (MrSuave, BloodCovenent)
Mufasa - 3 (DeathNote, sanjay, Santos)
xRECKONERx - 1 (FaerieLord)

Not voting - nobody

[almightybob]

Reck, what happened to this?

WHY THE FUCK ARE WE STILL LYNCHING THE CLAIMED COP? ARE YOU ALL FUCKING MAD?

My god. If you guys lynch the claimed cop on D1, I will replace the fuck out of this game, I'm not playing with such an awful town.

What makes BC's claim less valid than SW's? That it came second? If it was the other way round and we'd pushed BC to claim first, would you now be urging us to lynch SW because her claim was bullshit?



I do think that one of these claims is bound to be fake. I'm just not so sure which one.

[Santos]

Well, if we lynch BC today and he turns out to be the cop then Snow White was lying...and vice versa. What terrifies me is that they're possibly both cops until a flip.

[xRECKONERx]

Snow White's claim seemed legitimate. I think BC's is obviously scum who has been run up on a lynch and is now pulling out his last saving card in order to save his own ass. Seriously, the chances of there being two cops are so slim they're pretty much non-existant... the fact that BC waited until AFTER Snow White had already claimed her flavor role (Town Detective) to claim the exact same thing is also pretty sketchy. If he had claimed with role flavor or something that was different than Snow White's, maybe I'd buy it.

As for now, there's no way I'm voting anyone else until BC is lynched.

[Santos]

I will vote for BC because I agree Snow White's seems more legit. If BC wanted to be a true mafia player, then he would tear Snow White up in an unprecedented defense where we will all look in awe that we'll have to change votes to SW and save BC.

*crickets*

[Deuxieme Octopus]

BC must die!

vote: BC

But seriously, I'd lynch Snow White or BC at this point, but the vote count seems staggeringly one-sided, and being so close to deadline, might as well put my money on the horse with the best odds.

[Starbuck]

So this is what bothers me about both claims....neither said "Town Detective" which I would think if they were, they would claim the flavor to a "T".

I'm leaving my vote on BC because he seems to just be trying to save himself at the last minute. While SW's claim was rather scummy too, BC just seems to be saying anything to keep himself from a lynch.

[Sanjay]

That doesn't really bother me about either claim. We all have the town detective PM available to us, so claiming the flavor to a "T" doesn't really do anything to help the claim.

BC's claim does seem kind of bogus though. I have no idea why it is so spartan. You'd think with all the attention BC has attracted he would have put more thought into the possibility of claiming.

[BloodCovenent]

So this is what bothers me about both claims....neither said "Town Detective" which I would think if they were, they would claim the flavor to a "T".

I'm leaving my vote on BC because he seems to just be trying to save himself at the last minute. While SW's claim was rather scummy too, BC just seems to be saying anything to keep himself from a lynch.

This is an open set up, so anyone really knows the flavor to a "T".

[Starbuck]

So why would you say "Town Cop" and not "Town Detective" when that's one of the reasons most people are skeptical about Snow White's claim?

[BloodCovenent]

So why would you say "Town Cop" and not "Town Detective" when that's one of the reasons most people are skeptical about Snow White's claim?

Because those two roles are nearly identical.

[Starbuck]

So why would you say "Town Cop" and not "Town Detective" when that's one of the reasons most people are skeptical about Snow White's claim?

Because those two roles are nearly identical.

That doesn't excuse the fact that the ROLE in this game is DETECTIVE and not COP.

[BloodCovenent]

So why would you say "Town Cop" and not "Town Detective" when that's one of the reasons most people are skeptical about Snow White's claim?

Well, I guess I see your point, my role has a cop like ability. But the extra guess part, I wasn't looking forward to.

[BloodCovenent]

So why would you say "Town Cop" and not "Town Detective" when that's one of the reasons most people are skeptical about Snow White's claim?

Because those two roles are nearly identical.

That doesn't excuse the fact that the ROLE in this game is DETECTIVE and not COP.

But the thing that you may fail to realize, is that...
1. it's been a while since i've checked my PM, until recent, of course.
2. I haven't been the most active, leaving this game near the end of my to do list.

[Starbuck]

Why are you leaving the game at the end of your to do list when we can all go to your profile and do a search of your posts and see you active elsewhere?

You ARE avoiding this game. It's blatantly obvious.

[BloodCovenent]

Why are you leaving the game at the end of your to do list when we can all go to your profile and do a search of your posts and see you active elsewhere?

You ARE avoiding this game. It's blatantly obvious.

Because it's been generally boring for me. I'm not sure why. I was more enthusiastic about it before the game started. Originally I was just in to replace, but when I saw that there was little interest in it, and it was re-opened, i felt obligated to /in instead of /in to replace.

Yea, my excuses are lame, I just have had difficulty getting into it, especially with what's going on at school and stuff.

[My Milked Eek]

Eek!

Back in a few hours.

[Santos]

Unvote

Vote: BloodCovenent

Bet ya I can get lynched faster than you :p