Mafia 102: No-Frills Game Thread(Town wins!)

[WarWound]

meh pom to me seems alittle more scummy than bgmc

---------------------

Super Accurate* Vote Count(as of post 700):

malpascp - 1(mask man)
crypto - 1(Ojanen)
muh316 - 1(Sando)
bigmc109 - 5(Empking, SerialClergyman, malpascp, Pyromaniac, Pomegranate)
Pomegranate - 6(Kaiveran, crypto, hiphop, charter, bigmc109, WarWound)
SerialClergyman - 1(muh316)

Not Voting:Trumpet of Doom

It takes 9 to lynch, 6 at deadline.

*Not guaranteed to be accurate.

[Pyromaniac]

If you had not read the thread how would you know who looked scummier?

[WarWound]

ive been reading what has been said lately at the very least, page or 2 or three

[Pyromaniac]

That is hardly enough to determine who is scummier.

fos WW

[hiphop]

I reread SC's case on Bigmac, and found it convincing. For instance, like the way he tunneled a newbie as scum, which he did in this game too. Of the lynches that seem probable, his is the best.

As charter said did you not do this too? Did you not attack a newbie? Are you not accusing Bmc of doing the exact same thing that you did? Did you not hint that that was scummy? Are you not admitting that you did a scummy thing? As Crypto said, you just admitted that you were scum.

WW hasn't done anything. Staple acted scummy.

Is this supposed to be the answer to charter's question? If it is, it doesn't fly with me. Why can't Bmc claim the same thing as to why he voted for staple? Oh wait, he did. It looks to me the only reason you are voting for bmc is because his bw is the only other large one, that isn't yours. Admit it.

Bigmc seems to be setting up mislynches and attempting to lynch staple, who seemed more like n00b town. Though I'm not sure about WW.

First of all Staple seemed like a noob. Townie I doubt it.

2nd of all, I would think that replacements would carry the same feeling if they haven't done anything, because they are playing the same spot. Their roles don't change.

I dont want to read the whole thread then get my ass lynched, if you still want to lynch me do it now and do not waste my time, thats why i havent been posting

If that is the case you should never of replaced in, and you should do us all a favor and ask the mod for a replacement. If you don't care about this game you should not be in it. Besides you have had over a week, plenty of time to have read the whole thing. Not only that, but you can learn from more experienced players on how to improve your game.

Also you said you read the past two pages. How do you know if any of it is true? What if I said that crypto voted for himself, would you believe it?

[SerialClergyman]

^ I like this post.

[Empking]

Unvote

Vote; WW

I think I was wrong about BigMc.

[Trumpet of Doom]

Checking in; my read's at about page 14 or so. I won't be able to finish it this weekend, but I should be able to before deadline.

[crypto]

Checking in; my read's at about page 14 or so. I won't be able to finish it this weekend, but I should be able to before deadline.

Just skip every other post by me. That should speed it right along without missing much.

[charter]

Empking, why not vote for Pom?

[crypto]

Pyromaniac's BMC vote reminded me . . . after the hundredth reconsideration, I've warmed up a little to the theory that BMC was setting up for two straight mis-lynches on Staple and Muh. But I still think the whole argument is a shoddy reason for knocking him off day 1.

I don't get why Staple isn't scummy. I don't care if he's new to the game. Asking people to give him things to comment on was insane. He didn't/doesn't do that in his other game.

WW looks bad, but irrational play seems to be standard for him.

Anyway, keep the Pom wag going. I don't think lynching BMC or anyone else for information is worth it considering her scumminess blows everyone else out of the water. I'd take the easy scum lynch any day. Even so, her interactions with BMC and her attacks early on are intriguing. If she flips scum, a couple of players are 80% clear in my eyes.

[mask man]

Sigh, whole game looks like it'a slowing down. Anywho, my idea was to use this day epically here but other than getting a vote analysis the only thing to do is ask questions, but so far my questions have been left rather unanswered and the questionees have flaked off of the snow pile. I might as well hurry this up, maybe tomorrow I'll fit something in.

Vote: Pom

[crypto]

@crypto: What do you think of charter alignment-wise, after being the one that had to yell out 'bigmc isn't being scummy, you are using shit-logic and staple is scum.'(please call me out if I misrep'd you.), I'm surprised you don't have a vote a charter, and instead are more eager to lynch pom.

I don't think I answered this. I can't get a read on Charter. I find the diversion from Staple very fishy, but again I no longer have much of a town read on BMC.

[charter]

To be honest, Staple replacing out when he was under pressure was far scummier than anything else he did. No one brought that up though.

[Empking]

Empking, why not vote for Pom?

I'm not convinced about Pom and I think WW is scummier. (Plus it'd be more informative.)

[mask man]

To be honest, Staple replacing out when he was under pressure was far scummier than anything else he did. No one brought that up though.

I'm not saying I noticed this, but normally I don't like to make points out of replacing. I find it really dirty, but he was rather new.

[Pomegranate]

Blindly voting is profoundly scummy.

Unless it's blindly voting for me, right?

[crypto]

Correct.

[Pyromaniac]

hiphop, why would they have the same feel? You should not lynch someone solely on the actions of the past player.

[crypto]

Can someone tell me why RayFrost replaced out of this game and then continued to post boatloads in his other games?

[Scigatt]

Prodded malpascp and Ojanen.

[hiphop]

You should not lynch someone solely on the actions of the past player.

Exactly, but you can't completely diminish the actions of the other player either.

You said he seemed like a noob town. This means he must have spit out a few towntells (I don't know where, your the one that said he seemed like a townie.) If that is so, are you willing to throw them out the window, or put them in the cabinet for use later? Like I said they have the same role. If staple is town ww is town and the same goes for scum.

[crypto]

NINJA AVATAR CHANGE. *falls asleep in chair*

[mask man]

You better fucking not.

[hiphop]

Crypto, you are like a man with many faces.