Mafia 104 - Revenge of the Crimson King - Game!

[Riceballtail]

Semi-serious. I usually avoid policy lynches, but I have a habit of being on the other side as Emp in most games we've played together. Thus, I have one red flag already.

[WarWound]

vote socrates

for doing omgus vote and hello everyone

[Merkabah]

I'm with Glork on this one. Exalt is scum. The fact that he wants to accuse Glork of OMGUS seals it. I'd vote, but we decided in our hydra that Amish would do all of the voting for clarity's sake.

My intention is there, however.

-VPB

So you're 2 people?

Yeah, this is a hydra account between Amished and VP Baltar.

@wicked-I don't know. Do you?

[WarWound]

vote socrates

for doing omgus vote and hello everyone

WOOO i came in really late pls forget that vote as i see were out of rvs on page 1...

unvote

[Glork]

I pointedly refuse to answer Wicked's question to me.

[Exalt]

Glork had posted. This was probably an intentional mistake to make your case look bigger. Convince me otherwise.

Since it was obviously such a momentous case on my RV, I would like to say that I do not care enough to convince you of anything, because I am always right! (and I also didn't notice that Glork posted when I picked out a name on the list to RV, so yes it helped my case so I thought) The fact that it is making such a stir makes me believe I am on to something. Only scum freak out over a RVS vote, and only scum would defend a player based on them freaking out over a RVS vote.

I'm with Glork on this one. Exalt is scum. The fact that he wants to accuse Glork of OMGUS seals it. I'd vote, but we decided in our hydra that Amish would do all of the voting for clarity's sake.

My intention is there, however.

-VPB

So you are scum with Glork? That is quite a confession Merkabah. You had discussed all of this at a previous time, huh? Could it possibly have been in a... i dunno.... pregame quicktopic? HMMMM

Why not end it then?


Tarhalindur - Can you please explaiin how Cyberbob slipped?
Vaya - Are you scum?
Devestation - Is Vaya scum?
Mufasa - What is your opinion of Snow_Bunny so far?
WarWound - Have you been lurking?
Snow_Bunny - RayFrost already figured out who's scum. Don't you believe him?
Riceballtail - Was your vote for Empking serious? Do you support policy lynches?
Socrates - If you are good at logic, then wouldn't you make the game more difficult for the town if you were scum? Why would it be a bad idea to vote for you because of this?
swimmer4lyfe - Are you scum?
Glork - Is swimmer4lyfe scum?
Empking - Is Glork scum?
SolemnJ - Is Empking scum?
Merkabah - Is SolemnJ scum?
Pads - Is Merkabah scum?
Infinis - Is Pads scum?
Raivann - Is Infinis scum?

Where is my question Wickedestjr? You have said that you are now ending your RVS questions and getting down to business, so why am I left out here?

Also

Wickedestjr: Are you scum?

[Seraphim]

"He seemed impressed by the way you came in.
'Tell us a story
I know you're not boring'

I was afraid that you would not insist.
'You sound so sleepy
just take this, now leave me'"

Vote Count

Tarhalindur(1)

- Merkabah

Vaya(1)

- Kise
Devestation(0) -

Mufasa(1)

- Raivann
WarWound(0) -
xRECKONERx(0) -
Snow_Bunny(0) -
Riceballtail(0) -

Socrates(2)

- Cyberbob, MonkeyMan576
Wickedestjr(0) -

Exalt(1)

- Glork
swimmer4lyfe(0) -

Kise(3)

- xRECKONERx, RayFrost, Pads

Glork(1)

- Exalt

Empking(1)

- Riceballtail

RayFrost(1)

- Wickedestjr
SolemnJ(0) -
Merkabah(0) -

MonkeyMan576(2)

- Socrates, Snow_Bunny

Cyberbob(1)

- Tarhalindur
Pads(0) -
Infinis(0) -
Raivann(0) -

Not Voting(8)

- Vaya, Devestation, Mufasa, swimmer4lyfe, Empking, SolemnJ, Infinis, WarWound

With 23 alive, it is 12 to lynch.
Deadline: 30/11/09

[Infinis]

I had no idea #105 was going to be epic (this seems like it's going to be fast too)

So I apologize but

@mod /replace

I can stay if you can't find a replacement, but I loathe lurkers and will become one trying to keep up with two games (at the speed they both go) Since I work and this sight is banned and I commute and what not.

[swimmer4lyfe]

@wicked: yes! wait I mean no...oh god I always get these questions wrong

Man, you guys take the RVS way further than anything I've seen before.

... And there's the first slip of the game.

Unvote: Riceballtail, Vote: Cyberbob

Tar, I have a lot of respect for you and imma let you finish, but can you explain what you are talking about here?

I think this is the scummiest post here. It's pretty obvious what Tar is referring to. People are RVSing it up, and usually the person that tries to show themselves as serious and waiting for RVS to be up is very likely to be scum.

I think its silly to ask Tar to clarify, and shows a subtle connection between you and Cyberbob.

Vote: RayFrost

[Cyberbob]

It's pretty obvious what Tar is referring to. People are RVSing it up, and usually the person that tries to show themselves as serious and waiting for RVS to be up is very likely to be scum.

Ahahahahahahahno. Trying to get people out of the RVS is protown, especially given the rather short deadline in this specific game. Nice try though!

[Merkabah]

Unvote
Vote: Exalt

[Exalt]

Unvote
Vote: Exalt

Gotta love when I call you scum and you vote me without explanation for it

nice to meet you newbscum!

UNVOTE

VOTE: Merkabah

I can do it too.

[RayFrost]

I think this is the scummiest post here. It's pretty obvious what Tar is referring to. People are RVSing it up, and usually the person that tries to show themselves as serious and waiting for RVS to be up is very likely to be scum.

I think its silly to ask Tar to clarify, and shows a subtle connection between you and Cyberbob.

Vote: RayFrost

What cyberbob said is true.

Anyways...

It is not obvious what Tar was talking about.

Wanting the RVS to be over in order to get some real discussion and scum hunting going on is pro-town, so that couldn't be a slip.

I didn't see anything that was really... noteworthy about Cyberbob's post, so I asked Tar to clarify.

Also, since when is asking for clarification a scum tell? It's a null tell

at best

, since it requests more information, it doesn't say "I think you are wrong cuz [flimsy reasoning]" or "I think you are wrong cuz [super awesome reasoning]." It just asks "what are you talking about here?"

Nice try, though.

pro tip: don't try to defend your scum buddies so much that you end up reaching for some reason to chainsaw defend (wait... isn't that a tell tar thought of? )

[MonkeyMan576]

I think this is the scummiest post here. It's pretty obvious what Tar is referring to. People are RVSing it up, and usually the person that tries to show themselves as serious and waiting for RVS to be up is very likely to be scum.

I think its silly to ask Tar to clarify, and shows a subtle connection between you and Cyberbob.

Vote: RayFrost

What cyberbob said is true.

Anyways...

It is not obvious what Tar was talking about.

Wanting the RVS to be over in order to get some real discussion and scum hunting going on is pro-town, so that couldn't be a slip.

I didn't see anything that was really... noteworthy about Cyberbob's post, so I asked Tar to clarify.

Also, since when is asking for clarification a scum tell? It's a null tell

at best

, since it requests more information, it doesn't say "I think you are wrong cuz [flimsy reasoning]" or "I think you are wrong cuz [super awesome reasoning]." It just asks "what are you talking about here?"

Nice try, though.

pro tip: don't try to defend your scum buddies so much that you end up reaching for some reason to chainsaw defend (wait... isn't that a tell tar thought of? )

RF's post here seems overly defensive. Often if someone is overexplaining their actions it's because they have a guilty conscience. The RF/CB connection seems plausable.

Unvote:
Vote: RayFrost

[Cyberbob]

facepalm.gif

[RayFrost]

RF's post here seems overly defensive. Often if someone is overexplaining their actions it's because they have a guilty conscience. The RF/CB connection seems plausable.

Unvote:
Vote: RayFrost

1. I'm overly defensive, get over it.

2. I didn't explain my actions all that much, I was pointing out the flaws I saw in the action of the person voting me.

3. I fail as town, so yeah... I do have a guilty conscience.

4. The reason of the person quoting me for voting me was crappy, but the game is barely beginning, so I consider it valid to respond to any points made against me rather than ignoring it. It does this thing called promoting discussion.

5. you using a highly flimsy reason for voting me is noted.

Good day, monkeyboy~

[MonkeyMan576]

RF's post here seems overly defensive. Often if someone is overexplaining their actions it's because they have a guilty conscience. The RF/CB connection seems plausable.

Unvote:
Vote: RayFrost

1. I'm overly defensive, get over it.

2. I didn't explain my actions all that much, I was pointing out the flaws I saw in the action of the person voting me.

3. I fail as town, so yeah... I do have a guilty conscience.

4. The reason of the person quoting me for voting me was crappy, but the game is barely beginning, so I consider it valid to respond to any points made against me rather than ignoring it. It does this thing called promoting discussion.

5. you using a highly flimsy reason for voting me is noted.

Good day, monkeyboy~

My reasoning is hardly flimsy. For early in day one, I'd say it's pretty good, at least to make you scummier than anyone else, and your comments seem to confirm my hypothesis.

[RayFrost]

... confirm your hypothesis that I'm going to defend myself from people's posts?

Congrats, u r a genius!!!11!!!111

[Glork]

MonkeyMan, how is Ray being

overly

defensive, and how does being defensive make Ray more likely to be scum?

[Kise]

Tarhalindur(1)

- Merkabah

Vaya(1)

- Kise

Mufasa(1)

- Raivann

Socrates(2)

- Cyberbob, MonkeyMan576

Exalt(1)

- Glork

Kise(3)

- xRECKONERx, RayFrost, Pads

Glork(1)

- Exalt

Empking(1)

- Riceballtail

RayFrost(1)

- Wickedestjr

MonkeyMan576(2)

- Socrates, Snow_Bunny

Cyberbob(1)

- Tarhalindur

Holy shit.. we just got modconfirmed!!!

Wicked, stop being a party-pooper.

[MonkeyMan576]

MonkeyMan, how is Ray being

overly

defensive, and how does being defensive make Ray more likely to be scum?

I explained that over-defensiveness indicates guilty conscience.

I just think that the passion of his defence(it didn't really require the five or so sentences that he posted) wasn't equal to the level of attack.

[RayFrost]

MonkeyMan, how is Ray being

overly

defensive, and how does being defensive make Ray more likely to be scum?

I explained that over-defensiveness indicates guilty conscience.

I just think that the passion of his defence(it didn't really require the five or so sentences that he posted) wasn't equal to the level of attack.

ITT monkeyboy tries to convince the town that defending yourself to anything above some arbitrary extent is a scum tell.

[MonkeyMan576]

MonkeyMan, how is Ray being

overly

defensive, and how does being defensive make Ray more likely to be scum?

I explained that over-defensiveness indicates guilty conscience.

I just think that the passion of his defence(it didn't really require the five or so sentences that he posted) wasn't equal to the level of attack.

ITT monkeyboy tries to convince the town that defending yourself to anything above some arbitrary extent is a scum tell.

Nice strawman.

[RayFrost]

Over defensiveness = defending yourself too much = scum tell

you said five or so sentences is too much

this is an arbitrary number

thus, I don't see a straw man.

[MonkeyMan576]

Over defensiveness = defending yourself too much = scum tell

you said five or so sentences is too much

this is an arbitrary number

thus, I don't see a straw man.

The strawman is that it's not an arbitrary number. I didn't set any number, I just said it was my opinion. And not referring to me by my actual name is an appeal to emotion.