Open 175 - Picking Simplicity (Game Over)

[Toro]

You know what? This game needs a swift kick in the head.

Vote: WarWound

[SpyreX]

You are right. However, the chances of WW being scum are minimal.

Unvote, Vote: Zaz

Now, this, on the other hand.

[Nikanor]

Zazie is still in this game?

(Sorry, I've been busy. Too many commitments. )

[Col.Cathart]

Blargh, Exams...

I'll try to do re-read later today.

[Flava Flave]

Vote Antihero

Pomegranate and Toro are probably scum too.

[Toro]

Vote Antihero

Pomegranate and Toro are probably scum too.

Any reasons for you thinking this?

[Flava Flave]

Probably.

[SpyreX]

?

That's pretty awesome right there.

[yabbaguy]

Anti-town behavior is exactly what we need right now. I approve.

[Iguana]

Not anti-town, its about the most informative lynch we can do.

@Spy - Compramise with a whoever replaced Hyl lynch?

[semioldguy]

Vote Count 12:

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

Pomegranate

(2) – Head_Honcho, Col.Cathart

yabbaguy

(1) – Nikanor

skitzer

(1) – Iguana

WarWound

(1) – Toro

ZazieR

(1) – SpyreX

Antihero

(1) – Flava Flave

Not Voting (11) –

Blastinus, skitzer, yabbaguy, WarWound, Grimmy, Antihero, Yankee, Pomegranate, YankCane151, ZazieR

Notes:

* Prodded: Grimmy, WarWound, Head_Honcho
* Blastinus did not pick up his PM from Tuesday, I will start searching for his replacement
* Searching for replacements for Antihero, Yankee, Pomegranate, YankCane151, ZazieR and Blastinus.
* Deadline currently on hold.

[SpyreX]

HAHAHA Yankee replaced Hyl?

Unvote, Vote: Yankee

[SpyreX]

Needless to say Iguana yea I'm down. <3

[Iguana]

unvote
Vote Yankee

[Head_Honcho]

not a fan of a yankee lynch at all. Hyl was protownish and his lurking out wasn't really under scummy circumstances. Would lynch antihero in a second before lynching yankee.

But still, I am content with my vote on pom.

[Head_Honcho]

actually an antihero lynch doesn't look bad at all at this point.

[Col.Cathart]

Ok, I guess nothing really happened since my last post. I still like my vote on Pom, though I'm willing to switch for Zaz as well. He posted regularly in other game, I'm in, so his not posting here, ESPECIALLY after promising us some major revelation is really scummy.

[WarWound]

i would like to be replaced good day

[semioldguy]

StrangerCoug replaces ZazieR

MichelSabelheart replaces YankCane151

[StrangerCoug]

Hello I was already working on a PBPA when I got sent my role, and I'm on page 14 right now.

Unvote

if applicable.

[StrangerCoug]

If I missed anything important that you want my stance on, speak up.

#34 12Keyblade: Dice voting is frowned upon.
#38 Nikanor: Freudian slip.
#46 Iguana: For some reason, this is giving me a stronger newb tell than a scum tell.
#49 Iguana:

DEFINITE

newb tell.
#74 Head_Honcho: Hyl is discouraging posting? Where?
#88 12Keyblade: Of what use is this?
#99 Pomegranate: Am I reading this post right? OMGUS'ing over something ridiculous weak?
#102 Nikanor: I beg to differ. I hate the bandwagon stage.
#119 Hyl: Going with the flow with that 12Keyblade vote. Not liking it a lot.
#124 Flava Flave: What the hell makes you say the random voting stage never happened? Also following Hyl with the 12Keyblade vote.
#127 12Keyblade: I can't comprehend this.
#130 zwetschenwasser: #128 is not a Freudian slip.
#132 zwetschenwasser: And this tells Col_Cathart what?
#157 Toro: Switching words up is scummy.
#168 WarWound: I don't like how your first post after officially replacing in is asking if we are going to kill Nikanor. You're not providing useful input.
#177 WarWound: I'd vote him at this point were I playing at the time. I'm not getting the newb tell I did from Iguana—I'm getting a scum tell from not participating in serious discussion and instead just chucking questions about the game looking like he cares.
#179 WarWound: Is following the town some sort of disease spreading like mad? That's the third time I've picked this up.
#204 foilist13: Either foilist13 is being hypocritical or I owe him a reread, as I don't remember him showing up much either. (

Note:

This was typed up before I picked up my role.)
#209 Iguana: I haven't had the first paragraph hold true with me, but I may simply have an aggressive playstyle that rarely lets newbies cut some slack.
#227 Scott Brosius: Although I agree with the first part, WarWound could also have come from another site.
#238 WarWound: Obviously dislikable.
#240 dramonic: Huh? I have a town read on Iguana at this point.
#250 skitzer: You should not have brought up breadcrumbing. It tells the scum that there's a hint as to the breadcrumbing player's role in the post, and anybody who doesn't see that as rolefishing is very inexperienced.
#263 Flava Flave: Gut scum read.
#274 Flava Flave: This post is making me think. The back of my head is yelling "Lining up lynches!", but 12Keyblade is scummier to me than Dramonic at this point in the game. Pomegranate would require a reread before I see a case on her.
#285 WarWound: Why the insult?
#301 WarWound: It makes no sense to me to decline to scumhunt out of fear of mislynching. If nobody scumhunted because everybody was afraid of a mislynch, the game would grind to a halt.
#305 Hyl: If I read the setup correctly, this is a day start. Iguana can't have investigated anybody on Night 0. I see where you're coming from with that statement, though.
#311 Iguana: My town read on her went to hell with this post.
#322 Blastinus: The first paragraph is defending Iguana with WIFOM.
#340 Nikanor: *shoots self in head after reading about fakeclaiming as town*
#346 SpyreX: No, foilist13 is not scum for voting 12Keyblade; the latter has committed legitimately scummy actions. (I also have the former's role, but that says nothing really.)
#417 WarWound: Will you scumhunt, damn you? You gave Toro a very easy question to answer and I don't know your stance on anybody.
#423 Blastinus: My only problem with this is that I don't think 12Keyblade was merely inactive.
#428 WarWound: You don't make an attempt to defend the case—you simply dismiss it by implying that the reasoning is bad. Why is the reasoning bad?
#529 zwetschenwasser: What!?
#546 yabbaguy: This rubs me completely the wrong way and is basically saying you aren't putting effort into this game and don't care to.
#561 zwetschenwasser: I'm not surprised by his later lynch. This guy called somebody whose lynch he'd support town, something that's been the topic of discussion for about a couple pages now.
#566 WarWound: I don't like people advocating a policy lynch on a player when there's a legit case on them.
#570 WarWound: Same problem as with #301. If there were a dayvig in this game and I were it, I'd shoot you right now.
#659 Grimmy: LOL at L+1 vote.
#669 Nikanor: Oh come on. You can come up with a better reason for a vote on anybody than

THAT.

At this point I'm pretty convinced that WarWound is scum. Yes, we understand that a lot of the people on the site from whence you came don't have a very high intelligence level. That does not give you the right to opt out of scumhunting because you're afraid of a mislynch. Town doesn't lose if they mislynch once (unless there are five- and six-player games that I don't know about). Town loses if they mislynch too many times. You've also been throwing a lot of

ad hominem

attacks and otherwise useless content.

Vote: WarWound

I like Iguana and to some extent Nikanor as scum too. Blastinus is neutral.

[Flava Flave]

People should listen to Head Honcho. He's town AND right.

Stranger, I don't random vote. And having more than one suspect isn't "lining up lynches".

[MichelSableheart]

Checking in. Reading the thread. Post tomorrow.

[StrangerCoug]

People should listen to Head Honcho. He's town AND right.

Stranger, I don't random vote.

That's fine, but there's not much of a point in denying that random voting happens in practically every game on this site that I know about.

And having more than one suspect isn't "lining up lynches".

I have no problem with people having more than one suspect. You wanted one person dead before another, and I'm wondering how good of a reason you had before it. I'll have to play that post by ear since what you said corresponded at least partially to my reads, though.

[Flava Flave]

Yeah, it happens. But I don't do it, so for me, there is no RVS.

Yeah, I wanted my top suspect dead before other suspects. And yeah, there's a reason for it. I'm more confident that Antihero is scum than Pomegranate. Common sense.