Perfectionist Mafia - Resultas

[Max]

The saying one for sorrow two for joy, held correct today. As the town slowly tore apart Snow White shred by shred the clothes went flying the havoc the mayhem. It was over so quickly.

Snow White, Detective, Lynched Day 3

With the mayhem traveling across the town a fire had begun, unlike any old fire, it was a spit roast and surprise surprise it was one with a twist. There was a human, with an apple in it's mouth. Carved into the nice succulent juicy meat was a message

xRECKONERx, Traitor, Roasted Alive, Twilight 3

3 for a girl... 4 for a boy...

Vote Count:

Snow White: (Snow White, Sanjay, MrSuave, Mufasa, xRECKONERx, Santos) + After hammer (dramonic)

6 To Lynch... Who Couldn't Count.

Note: I just noticed a flaw in the people voting selves at beginning of the day, in LyLo situations it will cause mafia quicklynch. Which wasn't the intention of the rule. So I will make it that in LyLo situations a self-vote will not contribute to the lynch toll.

Night 3... BEGINS (You have until monday evening or until I receive all choices + Recognition from mafia they are willing to end the night)

[Max]

mod: if a framer uses his ability on someone who gets investigated, but the investigator is meant to get a guilty read, does that turn it into an innocent read?

?

It turns any guilty read to an innocent. Any innocent to a guilty.

[Max]

"Wake me up... before you go go..." was playing on the radio. One person had failed to wake the town up when they went went the way of the dodo... Inside the mouth of this rather unusual corpse was a bowl of icecream.

saberwolf, Vanilla Townie, Killed Night 3

With that only 8 remained... what could the town do to fight back? I suggest they lynch someone.

8 Alive, 5 To Lynch

[Max]

Original Roll String: 1d7

1 7-Sided Dice: (2) = 2

13th December = 1
14th = 2
etc.
19th = 7

[Max]

Deadline = 17th of December

day begins now!

[Sanjay]

I was reading over almightybob to try to figure out who he investigated night one and I think this is a deadend.

If you look at this post it seems to me like almightybob is dropping a DeathNote guilty breadcrumb, which is all well and good if not for three reasons:

1. almightybob's sanity was not confirmed.
2. DeathNote was town (that's the big one)
3. It seems like a bad strategy to predict guilties if you were the cop. And unless almightybob predicted correctly, I would be surprised if he hadn't predicted correctly.

Maybe given point 1 it's not even worth searching for almightybob breadcrumbs.

Thoughts?

[dramonic]

If there is a masonry, now would be a nice time to claim.
If we mislynch today we're pretty much screwed if both kills hit town.

[manho]

back from V/LA

this game is really fast, i left for a week and 6 player died, almost one per day. need some time to reread the thread.

[Max]

I'm sending out a prod to all players to let them know it's day again.

[Mufasa]

Finish what I started.

vote mr suave

[Sanjay]

For the same reasons as before?

[Mufasa]

Yes.

[Santos]

Vote: manho

Need moar manho.

[MrSuave]

why do we need more manho?

[manho]

cop-SW was roleblocked and vig-mufasa was redirected, so our last 2 scums are roleblocker and redirector, right?

let's analyse the vote count: (i'll assume for all mislynch there exist a scum in the wagon)

D1: although BC was the lynch, SW was nearly lynched:

Vote Count - 11!

9 Votes:

Snow White

(

My Milked Eek, saberwolf, AlmightyBob

, Deuxieme Octopus,

Mufasa

,

Starbuck

, Faerie Lord,

Wickedestjr

, dramonic)

scums are in {manho (replaced DO), FL, dramonic}

End Of Day Has Been Reached

10 Votes

BloodCovenent

- 10 (EtherealCookie,

xRECKONERx

,

Sposh, saberwolf, starbuck, wickedestjr

, DeuxiemeOctopus, Santos,

almightybob

, FaerieLord)

this is not a mislynch but i can see scum jump into it late when the lynch is inevitable. also, i don't believe scum-cookie will stay on the godfather wagon for the whole day 1.
scums are in {manho (replaced DO), Santos, FL}

8 Votes:

Sposh

(EtherealCookie,

saberwolf

,

xRECKONERx

, Sanjay,

AlmightyBob

,

mufasa

,

elvis_knits

, FaerieLord)

scums are in {cookie, sanjay, FL}

Vote Count:

Snow White

: (

Snow White

, Sanjay, MrSuave,

Mufasa

,

xRECKONERx

, Santos) + After hammer (dramonic)

scums are in {Sanjay, MrSuave, Santos, dramonic}

as i know i'm not the scum, FL is the scum or (dramonic, santos, (cookie/sanjay) are all scum).

vote: FL

note that the conclusion is true if my assumation is true.

other analysis coming when i have time.

[Sanjay]

It's nice to have the data here, though I am seriously headscratching that you don't really seem as interested in the people off the BC wagon (me, Mufasa, dramonic, MrSuave) as the people that jumped on it late.

Is there a reason why you think being on the wagon but late is more suspicious than being off the wagon?

As for the power roles of the last two mafia, I think your assessment of the situation is probably off. If you had a roleblocker and a redirector, wouldn't the better choice be to redirect investigations instead of roleblock them? You could basically turn the cop paranoid or naive. That gives away less information and more misinformation.

I think what more likely is that Snow White was roleblocked by the serial killer. Which is good, because A) the town is quite likely out of powerroles to block now anyway and B) it means there is the potential for cross-killing.

What do you think about this possibility? Had you thought about it before this post?

[Sanjay]

MrSuave, what differences do you see exactly between dramonic's play as town and his play here? I've played with him as town and no differences really jump out at me.

[Sanjay]

FaerieLord, is there a reason why you weren't on the Snow White wagon? You seemed quite ready to lynch Snow White the day before, and AlmightyBob flipping cop certainly shouldn't have deterred you.

[FaerieLord]

FaerieLord, is there a reason why you weren't on the Snow White wagon? You seemed quite ready to lynch Snow White the day before, and AlmightyBob flipping cop certainly shouldn't have deterred you.

It was one of the quickest wagons I'd ever seen. Had I the time to vote, I would've.

Also, rereading and all. I'll answer you soon manho

[Sanjay]

Were you aware of the wagon and waiting to vote?

[Mufasa]

Where is the activity?

[dramonic]

I abducted it. I'd like everyone to answer the following:

Are you in a masonry?


If masons claim, we'll have a good bunch of confirmed town. It'll make it pretty easy to net the remaining scum/SK.

[FaerieLord]

Were you aware of the wagon and waiting to vote?

No, I was just unaware. By the time I read the thread, voting had happened

@Manho. Reread the votes in context. Both the votes for Sposh and BC were for one reason.
To lynch SW the next day. Granted I was wrong about SW, but I never pushed either of those wagons/

as i know i'm not the scum, FL is the scum or (dramonic, santos, (cookie/sanjay) are all scum). vote: FL

How did you get to that conclusion? I honestly cannot follow your logic

[manho]

It's nice to have the data here, though I am seriously headscratching that you don't really seem as interested in the people off the BC wagon (me, Mufasa, dramonic, MrSuave) as the people that jumped on it late.

Is there a reason why you think being on the wagon but late is more suspicious than being off the wagon?

As for the power roles of the last two mafia, I think your assessment of the situation is probably off. If you had a roleblocker and a redirector, wouldn't the better choice be to redirect investigations instead of roleblock them? You could basically turn the cop paranoid or naive. That gives away less information and more misinformation.

I think what more likely is that Snow White was roleblocked by the serial killer. Which is good, because A) the town is quite likely out of powerroles to block now anyway and B) it means there is the potential for cross-killing.

What do you think about this possibility? Had you thought about it before this post?

my mind really didn't work right yesterday. i still think a scum would jump on the BC wagon, although there is likely a scum not on it. i would say 1 on it and 1 off it, so we also have scum in {sanjay, dramonic, MrSuave}.
and our SK may have the roleblocking power, right. so we now have a redirector so sure and another scum with unknown power, right?

@Manho. Reread the votes in context. Both the votes for Sposh and BC were for one reason.
To lynch SW the next day. Granted I was wrong about SW, but I never pushed either of those wagons/

i'll read the exact vote in context when i have time. but you are now saying that you hammer others to get SW lynched? there is no logic in it, although i was also wrong about SW.

as i know i'm not the scum, FL is the scum or (dramonic, santos, (cookie/sanjay) are all scum). vote: FL

How did you get to that conclusion? I honestly cannot follow your logic

i assume that there exist a scum in each mislynch wagon, and from that assumption, i deduce that FL is the scum or (dramonic, santos, (cookie/sanjay) are all scum). i vote you as you have the highest chance to be the scum.

[Mufasa]

I'm sorry guys but I lied, I never was roleblocked, I targeted starbuck and guessed wrong .