Newbie 843 (Game Over)

[PaltryExcuse]

As time goes on I get more and more pushed to the middle, rather than the pro-Zach lynch feeling I had at the beginning of the day. I still feel that Zach has been, up until his vote on Starbuck, sitting back and going with the flow... essentially going on whatever lynch was most popular. He has come out fighting today, and tubby seems to be relying on his cop claim understandably. I still doubt there was no night one kill, so that clears manho for me. I've started to even think we may have a play at mutual bussing as both Tubby and Zach were under pressure yesterday... though this is not a strong feeling. Both believe that the 2nd scum is in the pairing of Starbuck and Kyiv though, with both thinking a different one of the two is scum. I'm not sure how I feel about that.
After all this confusion, I feel I may be overthinking the issue, and my original gut on Zach when entering the game was correct.
Off of myself for a bit:

tubby216

i may be an ass but i am not the correct lynch for today

What were you trying to accomplish with this post? Upon seeing it D2, it convinced me of nothing except that your guilt was more probable.
Secondly, your promise of investigating Starbuck is understandable, however if Zach is not the RB then it is all for nothing.

Zachrulez

2 days to the deadline.

I'm happy with my Wraith vote, just to make sure that's clear.

What's isn't clear to me is why you were happy with that vote. I still think the case on WoS was weak and he was lynched for a lack of defense / deadline.

No lynch

Just bringing this back up. I'm starting to see this as more plausible for some weird reason. If we lose either Zach or tubby, then the other is scum... so I doubt that'd happen. So, if mafia NKs, we're left with one less target. I think it might simplify things at this point. I dunno. Could someone tell me reasons why we shouldn't NL? I'm not convinced by my own anymore.

[tubby216]

tubby216

i may be an ass but i am not the correct lynch for today

What were you trying to accomplish with this post? Upon seeing it D2, it convinced me of nothing except that your guilt was more probable.
Secondly, your promise of investigating Starbuck is understandable, however if Zach is not the RB then it is all for nothing.

the quote, i wanted people to really look at what i was saying and not at my play style.

no it won't be all for nothing cause atleast we lynched scum. then we get an extra day.
if i get rb'd then either you or kyiv or starbuck gets killed. cause if they kill manho you are confirmed when he flips doc. once zach is lynched and flipps scum i am confirmed so that leaves us at very least 2 confirmed townies goin into tomorrow.


see i thought about the no lynch as well, but in the no lynch senerio, i get rb'd agian (so no info gained)

and paltry gets killed, then its me, manho on one side and zach and his partner on the other with the townie in the middle

or kyiv or starbuck gets killed and its paltry in the middle agian either way there is no info gained.

and its definate lylo

[PaltryExcuse]

@manho: Your V/LA ended yesterday. Where are you?

[PaltryExcuse]

@Mod: Prod on manho please.

[tubby216]

mod i need replaced puter issues

[manho]

i'm sick again, and that's why the V/LA last until today.

i believe tubby more than zach, tubby is pro-town after he claimed, and the change in behaviour is significant.

i really don't like the idea of no-lynch. if we no-lynch and paltry get nk'ed, tubby get blocked, we will be in lylo with no information gained. mylo is better than lylo as if we lynched the scum today, we will get some extra days. and the situation will be even better if the roleblocker was lynched.

so,

vote: zach

[PaltryExcuse]

Ya, I don't think I'm going to be swayed to vote for tubby today. I'm less sure of myself than at the beginning of today, and I think I'm ready to lynch... so:

Vote: Zachrulez

Here's hoping...

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Sorry guys, no access this past weekend. Looking for a replacement for tubby.



Official Vote Count!

*Zachrulez 3 (tubby216, manho, PaltryExcuse)
tubby216 1 (Zachrulez)

Not voting:

Starbuck, Kyiv.


4 to Lynch.

[hohum]

mass prod going out.

[PaltryExcuse]

Got prodded. Still here. Don't know what to say at this point.

[Zachrulez]

I'm kinda resigned to my fate now and am just waiting to be lynched I suppose.

Don't think anything I say at this point is going to change that.

[PaltryExcuse]

@Mod: Are 3 people being replaced? (Tubby, Starbuck and Kyiv) I just read the Queue. Is this the point where a game is considered to be abandoned?

[Zachrulez]

Oh wow, really?

[Zachrulez]

Yeah, this has gotten somewhat confusing. On looking at the que yesterday, I was under the impression that a replacement had been found for Tubby, but it was never announced in thread.

Didn't even realize that Starbuck and Kyiv are no longer in the game either.

[PaltryExcuse]

Ya, no kidding. I think the mafia at this point is REAL LIFE. It has taken out half of those remaining in the game.

[Starbuck]

I apologize for my absence. My Great Grandmother passed away last Thursday and I have been doing nothing but working on getting myself home for the memorial service. I've been able to keep up with at least two of my games except this one and another. I think it's time to ask for a replacement.

I apologize guys. I've never asked for a replacement before, but I just can't keep up.

[PaltryExcuse]

Not at all, Starbuck. Take the time you need.

[Kyiv]

Err... have I been kicked out of the game then?

[PaltryExcuse]

I would think not if you're here... but I know hohum was looking for your replacement according to the Newbie Queue.
Might want to PM him.

[hohum]

I won't replace anyone still interested in playing the game; however, you guys need to get some posting done.

Mr. Finch replaces Sanjay/Tubby

as of right now kyiv picked her role up and I'm still looking for a Starbuck replacement.

[Kyiv]

Okay first off, I want to apologize for not posting much this day. Though you have to admit I'm not the only one. But Zach's resignation isn't entirely swelling me with confidence. Town should fight to their death, but I guess a pure cop claim doesn't give him much to work with. Let's hope the two replacements have more to say.

[PaltryExcuse]

unvote

until I hear from the replacements.

[manho]

i'm still here and my vote are still on zach.

[PaltryExcuse]

Just pointing this out, but, Kyiv had not one but two chances to vote out Zach if her and Tubby/replacement were scumpartners. I'm crossing that possibility off my list. (Although my vote is probably going back on Zach unless something convinces me otherwise by either replacement).

[Zachrulez]

Starbuck could have hammered as well could she have not?