ElectricBadger wrote:Hmm. I don't think you intended to claim that you're town because you're aggressive; I think you were indeed just responding to a question. However, it provides a legitimate insight into your reasoning for playing so aggressively.
Does that make sense?
Legitimately wifom. Not only wifom, but wifom based on interpretation...which one could say, wifom based on wifom.
ODDin wrote:
1) I noticed a worrying thing about hewitt. He's acting very cautiously, he says he doesn't want to vote until he's certain that someone should be lynched. All the while he says he feels there's nothing to comment on and that the farside/scien discussion hurt the game. He must have realised that good discussion and strong arguments won't just come out of the underbrush singing songs. They need to be made. If he's town, then it's in his best interest to try to get better arguments. Yet he's not doing such an effort. Fine, he's reluctant to use his vote for that end (although it could've been useful, I think) - but how about asking questions? He says he finds farside scummiest, but he doesn't question her, he doesn't try to push her, pin her down, anything of the sort, to get better arguments. He's not really pressing anyone else either. He seems content enough sitting in the corner.
This is damn good.. Well thought out. Correct even... its a shame you're scum and hes town. You're playing better.
ODDin wrote:
2) At one point Fuzzy said he's going to reply to my questions just after he got an answer from farside. While the significance and relevance of these questions is lower now, it's still worthy to note that he didn't, actually, answer them at any point.
Did you ask it of him again? (prior to this statement)
ODDin wrote:
4) Post 235 by Nik and the ensuing discussion is disturbing me quite a bit. He's answering instead of me for things directed specifically at me and defending me. This looks an awful lot like buddying.
It's okay if you're town and think farside's arguments against me are wrong - but I'd expect you to wait for me to answer before saying anything. Otherwise, you're basically handing me a defence. What if I'm scum and these statements by farside would've tripped me and caused me to slip up?
This is very poor scumhunting there.
AHAHA i cant believe i came across this again! (ok) The last part is true, only because you're scum and Nik (meh, we'll go with isnt at the moment(point is you two arent same scum team)) Now my point is hilarious. I just did this same sort've buddying..answering (obvious questions) for others in a recent game mini 842. Now i did so on a fellow town. Well scum and bad townies jumped all over me for doing so in some awful wifom buddying argument. Like you're doing here... Its just personally funny because you're scum and this is the second time i'm seeing scum use this argument in an attempt to push a case on a townie(opposing alignment). (scum should really stick to the lurker/active lurker strat...works well)
ODDin wrote:
1. I feel that being overly agitated and annoyed over small and not so significant arguments is scummy. This is partly because I feel one wouldn't normally get so agitated over it, making me feel the agitation might be artificial and not genuine.
2. Town don't generally feel the need to assert their towniness without provocation, and don't implicitly or explicitly say "I'm town, I'm town" when it isn't called for. This isn't a "too towny" argument - far from it. There's a huge difference between "looking very townie" and "consciously trying to look very townie".
1. Can you show me where she was "overly agitated and annoyed" i really didnt get this huge aggressive feeling.
2. Wowwww. L2read Scien. I rescind EB+Oddin team. They're both scum but i forgot theres two teams. Scien+Oddin = a team. (Psssst Oddin, its good to read your partners posts and not merely skim them...hell a bus or two wouldnt hurt your cause either...but its too late for this game.)
ODDin wrote:It isn't, on its own, a terribly strong argument - because I can't, at this point, be sure that you're lying. It's a possibility to keep in mind. And it was important, IMO, for the rest of the town to be aware of the possibility. Knowing a new option is never a bad thing. People were given brains to decide for themselves whether that option is reasonable or not.
Also, I am not taking the "you must be scum approach". I'm taking the "you might be scum for all I know and this here could be a scummy thing to do" approach, which I take for everyone, naturally.
You say it's not scumhunting? Fine. Think so if you wish. In my personal opinion I'm doing quite enough scumhunting here.
Wah wah wah (
) AtE much? There was another post of Oddins where all i felt was boohoo prior to the one i did point out. Now i wish i did for all 3 reference.
This guys trying to walk on eggshells and be switzerland too much.
ODDin wrote:
9) Once again I would like you to pay attention how farside is making
much ado about nothing.
Ooo good play(musical?).
farside22 wrote:When a comment like I made can be skewed to be a interptation of hey look I'm agressive so I must be town or scum and you point to it as scum while saying all my points I made had merit but you find my aggression scummy because of another game I find you not to be scum hunting but using excuses to buy a vote.
Word, this.
Riceballtail wrote:
That said, ODD is definitely scum. Farside/Scien cannot be in the same faction, but could still both be scum.
VOTE:ODDin
The first part of this quote which i didnt quote is bad. This part however is. True n True.
Wulfy wrote:
4. For your argument to be legitimate, you would have to actually go back and prove that no reasons exists (or are not arbitrarily fabricated) so that you can reason that it is truly an OMGUS vote. Damn, you think people would learn this in novice games.
RBT: Your idea is awful. Day 1 claim in this setup might not be bad, but it's not game winning and gives scum more information than town gains. Actually, it just gets worse the more I think about it.
Champ.
"ITT Benmage is making Shakespeare look cool. I need to bring you to my high school." -Vi
"If i must blantantly follow somone a player cannot do better than blindly following benmage" - tubby216
.
