Mini 884 - Last Man Standing (Over)

[Sotty7]

If you did an ISO of me properly you would know when amished became "town"

I haven't been active lurking. I have taken stances on all of the major points in this game. I have said Ben is likely town, VP too. I voted Ecto, I took a position on Ecto v Vi. I have said you are probably town. Apart from my side track on Amished for a little while I have said the scum is likely d3x pretty much for most of the game. I also stand by my call over Vi's play once she was shot a second time. It was clear she was frustrated, she tried to shoot me and I wasn't even the top player on her list.

It's my opinion you can make anyone scummy with a PBPA if you try hard enough.

[VP Baltar]

my set up speculation is 2 cowboys and a sheriff against the town, btw. otherwise we could have three cowboys and the sheriff could be a "traitor" role, but given the killing mechanics i think that would unbalance the game.

I actually agree with you here. I think the scum group is some compilation similar to this with the sherriff potentially being a third party (maybe, though flavor indicates otherwise).

I will look at your sotty points, but I think you are way off target here. I don't feel she's active lurking IN THE LEAST. He posting frequency is pretty consistent with what I know from her regardless of alignment. I also cannot really see her as being Ecto's partner.

[Cobalt]

dj, who is scum if sotty flips town?

that's not how it works. you answer my questions first.

That's not how it works. you are the wagon and I am the confirmed doctor. Answer the question.

[Benmage]

my set up speculation is 2 cowboys and a sheriff against the town, btw. otherwise we could have three cowboys and the sheriff could be a "traitor" role, but given the killing mechanics i think that would unbalance the game.

I actually agree with you here. I think the scum group is some compilation similar to this with the sherriff potentially being a third party (maybe, though flavor indicates otherwise).

The sheriff is probably the gf or something in this flavor. Invest immune makes sense.

[Nachomamma8]

Unvote, Vote: Don_Johnson

Do I really have to explain this vote?

[Vi]

Vote Count:

don_johnson (6) ~ d3x, Cobalt, Benmage, PorkchopExpress, VP Baltar, Nachomamma8

Sotty7 (2) ~ Amished, don_johnson
d3x (1) ~ Sotty7

VP Baltar (0) ~

PorkchopExpress, don_johnson

Benmage (0) ~

Nachomamma8

Not Voting:

pwnz,

VP Baltar

[size=0]Ami 0 | Benmage 0 | Cobalt 0 | d_j 0 | Nacho 1 | PExpress 0 PROD1 1 | pwnz 1 | Sotty 0 | VPB 0[/size]

-(Still) Nothing new to report~

--With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
--Deadline is

2200 EST on Thursday, December 10 2009.

(This is your last day!)

------

Mod scene forthcoming. Do not panic.

------------------------------------------PLEASE CONSIDER THIS TOPIC *LOCKED* - DO NOT POST------------------------------------------

[Vi]

Everyone finally agreed to put their guns down. It gave them more free hands to grab someone and put them into a noose.

Wheel of Morality; turn, turn, turn - Tell us the lesson that we should learn:

--- don_johnson ---

Vanilla Townie

--- Lynched Day 1.

Night actions are due in 72 hours. Day 2 will begin at around this time on Saturday (my time).



------------------------------------------PLEASE CONSIDER THIS TOPIC *LOCKED* - DO NOT POST------------------------------------------

[Vi]

Dawn broke and the remaining members of the town resumed their normal boisterous blustering.
"Remaining", because they couldn't get a harrumph out of the one with a knife in her back.

--- Sotty7 ---

Town Marshal

- Killed Night 1...

-----

Vote Count:

Not Voting:

Amished, Benmage, Cobalt, d3x, Nachomamma8, PorkchopExpress, pwnz, VP Baltar
[size=0]Ami 0 | Benmage 0 | Cobalt 0 | d3x -- | Nacho 0 | PExpress 0 | pwnz 0 | VPB 0[/size]

-It is now Day 2!

-I have not received a reply on d3x yet.

--With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
--Deadline is Saturday, January 2 2010.

[VP Baltar]

I don't understand that at all. Amished, I want to hear from you first.

[Benmage]

I don't understand that at all. Amished, I want to hear from you first.

Expand.

[Cobalt]

I think we should do 1 daykill and a lynch today, assuming we have 3 scum.

[VP Baltar]

I don't understand that at all. Amished, I want to hear from you first.

Expand.

Sotty was not an obvious kill choice. She was under a great deal of suspicion at the end of the day. Cobalt claimed doc yesterday, and yet wasn't killed.

Marshall sounds like some sort of cop, which makes it even worse. Maybe she breadcrumbed somewhere and that is who the scum found her out...still seems like a weird kill.

@Cobalt-I don't want to assume anything. I'd rather talk this out first before we make any quick decisions. Not saying I'm opposed to your plan necessarily, but I don't want anyone just firing off their guns at a whim like yesterday. Anyone who does deserves to be lynched immediately.

[Benmage]

I think we should do 1 daykill and a lynch today, assuming we have 3 scum.

Where's that leave us worst case scenario wise...entering tomorrow, assuming one NK and all killed are town?

We have 9 alive...so its likely 7-2.

If we miss twice today and they kill another we enter D3 with 6 players, 4 town 2 scum. Majority 4 to lynch....thats sort've lylo for if we mislynch again and they NK we'd enter D4 2town2scum.

[Cobalt]

We have 8 alive, Ben. And why would you think it's 2 scum?

[VP Baltar]

I wonder how the lylo in this game is going to work though....depending on who goes and what kinds of shots the scum have, town could still technically win a 2-2 matchup if they shot first and shot correctly.


This going to be a bitch of a game to try and figure out I have a feeling.

We should probably lynch d3x since he's probably the scum that killed Sotty.

[VP Baltar]

Also, just so you know, I think we could very easily have had 4 scum at the start of this game giving the killing power of the town + a cop.

[Benmage]

We have 8 alive, Ben. And why would you think it's 2 scum?

Oh shit we have 8, not nine alive. One scums dead, i said 2 scum remaining.

[Cobalt]

Oh that's right, ecto flipped scum.

[Benmage]

Also, just so you know, I think we could very easily have had 4 scum at the start of this game giving the killing power of the town + a cop.

Possible, but is this likely if they all shoot the way ecto did?

4 means if D1 we mislynch they NK, and enter D2 all shoot theres 6 alive with 4 scum, and an easy win.

[Amished]

... Did you lose your memory VP? DJ and I were basically the only two suspicious of her yesterday; and dj's dead now. Also, you know better than to speculate about *one night kill*.

None of this adds up, and if it wasn't 2:30 in the morning, I'd expand upon this and my point about yesterday. In the morning!

Vote: VP Baltar

You really always are scum when I'm town, aren't you? Though, if so this is the first time you haven't killed me N1; so we're making progress!

[VP Baltar]

Also, just so you know, I think we could very easily have had 4 scum at the start of this game giving the killing power of the town + a cop.

Possible, but is this likely if they all shoot the way ecto did?

4 means if D1 we mislynch they NK, and enter D2 all shoot theres 6 alive with 4 scum, and an easy win.

But as I said before, we have GUNS! Lylo might not work the same here where it's a simple numbers game.

@Amished...so I kill a scum, my town reads flip town, and you think I'm scum.

[Vi]

Jazzmyn replaces d3x! Everyone welcome her!

[Benmage]

Yeah VP, you're makin my head hurt. Day and NK scum tho is pretty powerful.

[VP Baltar]

Hi Jazzmyn.

@ben-I agree it's powerful...but so is a cop/doc combo (if Cobalt is telling the truth).

[Benmage]

Hi Jazzmyn.

@ben-I agree it's powerful...but so is a cop/doc combo (if Cobalt is telling the truth).

Why are you auto-assuming marshal = cop?