Mini 892 - Mayor Mafia (GAME OVER)

[nhammen]

I am very happy with the choice for mayor. And I would have liked Hoopla to have commented on him before Monkey got so close to lynch. Too bad. Too late. I wanted to see if Hoopla was willing to choose Kyle as his life saving wagon rather than Monkey.

[SerialClergyman]

*her

[MonkeyMan576]

I'm not happy with Socrates position on me, but I'm willing to support him. The town could have made a worse choice.

[Socrates]

If all three wagons are on town players, then I expect the scum to evenly distribute themselves among those wagons, with very little interplay between them. They would be very comfortable to just letting the town push wagons on each other and just take a very hands off approach.

As such, my first instinct would be to look at the more lurkish type players who have been mostly going with the flow: Col. Cathart, SaintKerrigan, and maybe RECK and DDD a bit.

In this scenario, Nhammen's vote hop is an anomaly that I doubt a scum would make, just because it is a wholly unnecessary move, but it would be a weak town tell at best.

[SerialClergyman]

Socrates - who is scum? Which wagon are you encouraging now you have a double vote?

[Socrates]

I figured that my 565 made it clear that I am still pushing for a kyle lynch.

[Hoopla]

I am very happy with the choice for mayor. And I would have liked Hoopla to have commented on him before Monkey got so close to lynch. Too bad. Too late. I wanted to see if Hoopla was willing to choose Kyle as his life saving wagon rather than Monkey.

What difference does it make to you when you should not know either alignment?

[nhammen]

If you must know, I had thought of the possibility of a kyle Hoopla pair, and wanted to see if you had any reason not to switch.

[Hoopla]

If you must know, I had thought of the possibility of a kyle Hoopla pair, and wanted to see if you had any reason not to switch.

He isn't a bad lynch - I'd support it over my own.

[Col.Cathart]

Antiprod. I'll post something, after I'll be back from work. Luckily, it looks like I'll have some more time than 'hour a day' since weekend, so maybe I'll finally pick up some activity.

[MonkeyMan576]

If you must know, I had thought of the possibility of a kyle Hoopla pair, and wanted to see if you had any reason not to switch.

He isn't a bad lynch - I'd support it over my own.

Is there any lynch you'd support over your own? This is an incredibly scummy post. That being said, Kyle is in my top 3 scum prospects still. I would switch if that's what the majority decided.

[MonkeyMan576]

*you wouldn't support

[Hoopla]

If you must know, I had thought of the possibility of a kyle Hoopla pair, and wanted to see if you had any reason not to switch.

He isn't a bad lynch - I'd support it over my own.

Is there any lynch you wouldn't support over your own? This is an incredibly scummy post. That being said, Kyle is in my top 3 scum prospects still. I would switch if that's what the majority decided.

No, there isn't. I am confirmed town to myself and do not know the alignment of anyone else in the game, so I should support anyone elses lynch over mine. This is essentially the same logic that Socrates got elected for.

[charter]

Just waiting for the Monkeyman lynch.

[MonkeyMan576]

If you must know, I had thought of the possibility of a kyle Hoopla pair, and wanted to see if you had any reason not to switch.

He isn't a bad lynch - I'd support it over my own.

Is there any lynch you wouldn't support over your own? This is an incredibly scummy post. That being said, Kyle is in my top 3 scum prospects still. I would switch if that's what the majority decided.

No, there isn't. I am confirmed town to myself and do not know the alignment of anyone else in the game, so I should support anyone elses lynch over mine. This is essentially the same logic that Socrates got elected for.

Yes, but you are not giving good reasoning for anyone else to follow your lead so the post is redundant.

[Hoopla]

Stop trying to link yourself with me.

[MonkeyMan576]

Stop trying to link yourself with me.

LOL, Nice try. It's also obvious that's not what I'm doing. I have every right to criticize your play as anyone else.

[Hoopla]

Have you ever fake-claimed as scum before, Monkey?

[MonkeyMan576]

Have you ever fake-claimed as scum before, Monkey?

Sure...have you?

[Hoopla]

Have you ever fake-claimed as scum before, Monkey?

Sure...have you?

Nope.

Can you link me to some of those games?

[MonkeyMan576]

Mafia 91 - Hell Aboard The Purple Flower
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=10946

TTGL Mafia
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 54&start=0

Although I don't know why I'm giving this to you in good faith when you don't have any meta to go on.

[SerialClergyman]

Have you ever fake-claimed as scum before, Monkey?

Sure...have you?

Nope.

lol

[Hoopla]

Monkey, did you purposely choose to leave out Mafia 89 which is perhaps the one scum game most closely relating to your play here. You claimed a town watcher there.

Interestingly the two games you have actually played as cop, you were lynched on Day 1. Mini 795 you did not get to claim due to an impending deadline, but in Mini 838 I noticed you were a lot more reluctant to claiming your role, and only did so after a prolonged period of pressure. It seems in this game you used a claim as a means of deflating your wagon similar to the Mafia 89 fakeclaim.

[charter]

Should we lynch Hoopla after that very blatant lie?

[MonkeyMan576]

No, I forgot...I don't have a list of all the games I play in. Please explain how that is more closely related to my play here.

I didn't claim to deflate my wagon. And I don't think I claimed early either. And your analysis is entirely convinient to support your "any lynch is better than my lynch" stance, it doesn't make me any scummier than anyone else.