Mini 891 - British Comedy Mafia (Game Over)

[jasonT1981]

Guys I am sorry, I have asked to replace out, my hospital treatment got bumped up as a space became available. When I signed up to the game I was not due to start rehab until mid-Jan 2010 but as that got bumped up it has left me very little time for mafia.

This is not just for this game, I have asked to be replaced in all my games.

Sorry, and good luck.

[imaginality]

Sorry to hear that jason, best of luck with the rehab.

Unvote

[Fuzzyman]

Does the departure of Jason make it any more or less likely that he is scum? I should think not.

This, in addition to trying to stifle healthy Josh role discussion, earns you an

FoS

.

[Budja]

^ just lost quite a few town points.

There is a difference between healthy discussion and game-distracting, filler which has been solved ages ago.

Can we just kill BC or a lurker now ? I have enough town-reads to want to slice off some deadweight.

[BloodCovenent]

^ just lost quite a few town points.

There is a difference between healthy discussion and game-distracting, filler which has been solved ages ago.

Can we just kill BC or a lurker now ? I have enough town-reads to want to slice off some deadweight.

Wait.... me?

[Fuzzyman]

^ just lost quite a few town points.

You did too, by ignoring my inquiry on post 200.

There is a difference between healthy discussion and game-distracting, filler which has been solved ages ago.

Did you miss Josh's last post? It's still relevant. Besides, you've been partaking in this "filler" yourself quite a bit as well.

Can we just kill BC or a lurker now ? I have enough town-reads to want to slice off some deadweight.

Lynch-happy much?

[Fuzzyman]

^ just lost quite a few town points.

There is a difference between healthy discussion and game-distracting, filler which has been solved ages ago.

Can we just kill BC or a lurker now ? I have enough town-reads to want to slice off some deadweight.

Wait.... me?

Have you reason to believe he's talking sbout someone else? Yes, you.

[BloodCovenent]

I'm going to throw my 1 OMIGUS card down right now.

[imaginality]

Does the departure of Jason make it any more or less likely that he is scum? I should think not.

Vote: jasonT1981, a pressure vote to encourage him to do what he said he would

He's replacing out. Since my vote was aimed at getting more activity from him, the fact we'll have a (hopefully) more-active replacement means there's no need for my vote to stay on him.

I'm going to go hassle Locke Lamora now.

Vote: Locke Lamora

Meta scum read plus lurkerlicious. Come on Locke, give us something.

[Fuzzyman]

Does the departure of Jason make it any more or less likely that he is scum? I should think not.

Vote: jasonT1981, a pressure vote to encourage him to do what he said he would

He's replacing out. Since my vote was aimed at getting more activity from him, the fact we'll have a (hopefully) more-active replacement means there's no need for my vote to stay on him.

Mkay. Definite miss by me.

[imaginality]

Re. Josh's role thing, I thought it was all pretty damn clear what treestumping involved. Until his latest post, that is. Like Josh, I can't see how (a) 'a treestumped player can still be killed' isn't in direct logical contradiction with (b) 'a treestumped player is dead for all game purposes'; I thought that assuming (a) was clearly ruled out by (b) was logical on my part but apparently not, it seems.

[Budja]

I'm going to throw my 1 OMIGUS card down right now.

Look where my vote is .

@Fuzzy, I was under the impression I had no town points.
I'll place second and third on our two lurkers ATM.

[ortolan]

Tenth vote count

Budja (5): Josh Lyman, Snow Bunny, BloodCovenent, Netopalis, Fuzzyman
Josh Lyman (1): Chinaman
BloodCovenent (1): Budja
Snow_Bunny (1): danakillsu
Netopalis (1): MacavityLock
Locke Lamora (1): imaginality

Not voting (3): ConfidAnon, Locke Lamora

7 to lynch

I'm sorry I missed you from the votecount MacavityLock (dunno how that happened). I would prefer if votes were placed on a separate line in future to make it easier to spot . I am replacing jasonT1981, I hope everything goes well for you (update: I have replaced Jason with danakillsu). I've also realised my replacement rules were too lenient. If Confid and Locke don't pick up their prods I will attempt to replace them within 24 hours (if possible). In the future I will seek replacement within 24 hours of the time when a prod was requested if it is not picked up.

[ortolan]

danakillsu replaces jasonT1981. Thanks a lot danakillsu!

[Chinaman]

OK, first let me

confirm

vote: JL

secondly let me say I can not believe I am the ONLY person voting him with this 4 page claim he's got going on. A claim, I might add, that is a pretty stupid ability. IF everything he has spewed out about his ability is true, I think the MOD was smoking crack when he thought it up. (no offense MOD if he indeed is not a lying scum)

I say this because there has been something grossly overlooked IMO. Anything is possible, but this ability has a major flaw. Here's what doesn't make sense to me: If he hits scum with it, what's the point when there is a flip? Why would the scum get to continue to talk? Everyone would ignore him anyway! So it's a pro-town ability in the fact it makes a townie unable to die (well, not anymore..?) but unable to vote at the same time? That's not a very good pro-town ability imo.

And here's what sealed the deal for me JL.

Apparently, once a player has been stumped, they can still be killed and thus have to stop talking. This is what I was told; it seems contradictory to me, but I will have to go back this evening and re-read some thread and some PMs.

YES! it DOES seem very contradictory! That's why you should die! You are either lying scum and your claim got the better of you, or you are completely worthless town. Lets go through your "powers" thus far.

-You can target someone at night
-Once
-If it's a scum player, they get to continue to talk but we have a flip so it's like killing them, but not.....
-If you target a town, you take away their vote, but the are confirmed and can continue to talk.
-If you target a town with a PR, you fuck them in the ass by taking away THEIR PR with yours, but hey, they can still talk and are no better than a confirmed townie.
-If you do target town, scum can kill them anyway N2.
-If you target the same town scum do, that townie dies and you lose your power anyway (due to using it)
-You are about as confirmable as me trying to prove aliens don't exist.

I think that's the skinny on your claimed ability.

More votes JL pls.


I think that's pretty much the just of it. Die now scum.

[BloodCovenent]

Just got a call from a friend, and I gotta go soon so I just wanted to chime in.

I think that i've said I don't like the claim either. That being said, there really wasn't much that I had against Budja. I guess it's just time where I put my money where my mouth is.

Unvote:
Vote: Josh Lyman

[Snow_Bunny]

I felt a bit behind, so I'll try to catch up as soon as possible.

Lack of Budja votes makes me sad. Let's see if someone has taken over his place.

[Josh Lyman]

@Mod: I am going to be partially V/LA until Monday. "Partially" means I may only be online once per day.

[Fuzzyman]

I felt a bit behind, so I'll try to catch up as soon as possible.

Lack of Budja votes makes me sad. Let's see if someone has taken over his place.

I voted after your most recent request, if that's what you're asking.

[ortolan]

disregard

[Snow_Bunny]

I don't see why people are attacking Josh when he has an easily confirmed claim. And, after all, Budja is the right lynch for today.

[Chinaman]

I don't see why people are attacking Josh when he has an easily confirmed claim. And, after all, Budja is the right lynch for today.

Snowbunny...his claim is NOT easily provable, and even if it was, I don't know if I would want him to. Read my previous post and tell me a 100% way to prove it and even if we could prove it, how it would be helpful to town in any way...

I would FOS you for this post, but I'm assuming it's because you are still catching up. If you are done catching up, let me know.

[Locke Lamora]

I'm here. Will post as soon as I can (tonight/tomorrow morning).

[Snow_Bunny]

More Budja votes, please.

Do you want more votes, or do you already think of Budja as lynch-worthy?

I think he's lynch-worthy.

I have no interest in a Budja wagon right now and feel like a

Vote: Neto

is in order.

Then, what's your stance on Budja? Do you think he's town?

Wait a minute....So if someone were to NK someone you stumped, they'd then be unable to post?

1. Kill actions trump stumping, so if I target someone who is also targeted for a kill, they are

killed dead

and can't post anymore.

I'm quoting rather than rephrasing, as I just don't know how to make it any more clear.

It's hard to believe that you are quoting a message with the mod when that usually ends with modkilling. I mean, it is possible, but unless the mod confirms that quoting communication is allowed, I'll think this is false.

FoS: Josh

I don't see why people are attacking Josh when he has an easily confirmed claim. And, after all, Budja is the right lynch for today.

Snowbunny...his claim is NOT easily provable, and even if it was, I don't know if I would want him to. Read my previous post and tell me a 100% way to prove it and even if we could prove it, how it would be helpful to town in any way...

I would FOS you for this post, but I'm assuming it's because you are still catching up. If you are done catching up, let me know.

Ok, read your last posts, and the pages about Josh's claims, and I'll have to agree with the points brought up. The claim just got bad enough (I wasn't even aware it was a one-shot and had all those restrictions, so, it seems it's not easily confirmable), and I'm not buying it. I thought he was town playing poorly, but unless that crappy claim is truth, I don't think that's possible.

I still think Budja is lynch-worthy, but Josh just took his post.

Unvote, vote: Josh

[danakillsu]

Hi guys. Will read, but for now,

unvote