Troll's first role was Town which Troll said when Troll asked what the other roles others had gotten were. Crypto would only have gotten one role PM as him be a replacement. Incidentally, unless the scum can day talk Troll finds fairly likely that him be telling the truth due to the entirety of his part in the exchange for this issue. Playing as he did with another role strikes Troll as something that would involve more subtlety than Troll expects from him (that no be meant as an insult.)
Troll now sees what it was Charlatan no understood at the end of day two. The plurality vs. majority confusion be believable and be why Charlatan would have said him thought that the lynch was already a foregone conclusion without thinking that the day was already over. As we now know that both wagons were on town there no would have been a reason for either scum or town to fake that mistake. Troll knew that when day two started but was trying to figure out how it happened anyhow in case it would be useful to know.
As Troll said earlier, Charlatan's claim do be convenient. It actually no be so convenient as the one that Scien gave in
Newbie Game 791 when him was scum as that one was supposed to reveal the entire scum team (that be the claim Papa Zito was referring to a bit ago.) Further, Scien's given motivations for the night actions there no fit as well as Charlatan's do here. Charlatan wanting Scien to go first with his claim actually matches well also if him had no result when tracking him for exactly the reasons that him gave.
Papa Zito's bullet proof vest item claim probably be even more convenient. It gives a reason for us to potentially believe that the other version of the game was one where there no were roles and instead there were items. At this point no one has any evidence that there were either roles or items in the first attempt at this game so that be a nice way to make Charlatan look worse. Papa Zito as town should have been using that rather than the claim that this be a mountainous game as his defense from the start if it were true.
Troll continues to believe that this no should be a mountainous game. If it do be then there should only be two scum so we no be in LyLo anyhow. Otherwise the balance no works at all and, as Troll said, with the reviewers involved Troll would expect even a backup setup to be at least reasonably balanced. It still be possible that we have already lost any power roles we had (or items if Papa Zito's version be correct) but the insistence by Papa Zito that this be mountainous be bizarre.
Vi being a reviewer makes the tracker role reasonable because Vi has strong, very public views about cops, specifically that them no should be used. Having a tracker as an information gathering role in a game that Vi had any part in designing be, if not expected, at least not at all surprising. Actually, this now helps Charlatan a bit given his statement about hoping a cop might investigate him during the night. Troll no thinks him would bother bringing that up if him knew this about Vi and him would likely have been somewhat likely to claim cop instead of tracker as a fake claim if him lacked that knowledge.
Troll wants to hear what Ojanen's role was last game before doing anything in the way of voting but at this time Troll finds Charlatan's reasons for how him acted to be reasonable and consistent. Papa Zito's reactions to being accused as him has on the other hand no feel consistent and fails to be convincing as a defense. If we were at the deadline Troll would be voting for Papa Zito now.
-Zorblag R`Lyeh
I was hoping someone would contradict PZ, but retrospectively that would be a really stupid move.
